15 Best Italian Restaurants in Plymouth

Leena's Kitchen Italian • $$
63 Long Pond Rd, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Brunch Smashburger
Mushroom Arancini
Bresola Carpaccio
Brunch Pizza
Chicken Parm
Bolognese
Meatballs
Carbonara

“We have passed by this place a number of times and never went in. I will not pass it again. first off the beet salad and Caesar salad were wonderful. Very fresh, unique with the salad having pistachios, and the Caesar salad having these great flat croutons. Very tasty.. we ordered the margarita pizza as it was good Friday. This was exceptional with a very crispy thin crust. They had a special on a German chocolate cake which we decided to share. This was exceptional. I hope they put this on the menu as a regular. The coconut was enhanced with sea salt and caramel which made it extra special. The staff was very attentive, the atmosphere is kind of special. A mix between art deco, and 60s vibe. Very unique. Don’t pass by this place.“

4.4 Superb180 Reviews
Stracco's Subs And More Sandwich Shop • $
85 Sandwich St, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Cake and Lobster Tail
Italian Sub
Chicken Parm
Steak Bomb
Meatball
Pilgrim

“Super cute family owned restaurant located in Plymouth. The pilgrim sub was one of my favorites by far, and the Italian sub is probably the best I’ve ever had. My husband often gets a steak and cheese, which is also his favorite in town. They have also catered dessert trays for family events that have been delicious & very reasonably priced. Definitely a go to sub shop for us!“

4.7 Superb33 Reviews
Rose & Vicki’s of North Plymouth Pizza • $
358 Court St, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Cutlet Sub with Lettuce Tomato Onions and Mayo
Pepper and Onion Pizza
Turkey blt Sub
Meatball Sub
French Fries
Cheeseburger
Carrot Cake
White Pizza
Italian
Greek

“The delivery driver was very nice. That's where this love story ends. If this pizza could talk, oh, the stories it would tell! My guess is that whoever made it was having a very bad day or was mad about my lactose intolerance. I will say I've never before gotten a cold, disheveled pizza at any location, but there's a first time for everything.***update***I got a call, and they apologized and made sure I was taken care of. Great customer service.“

4.5 Superb60 Reviews
Monte Christos Restaurant Pizza • $
745 State Rd, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Monte' Special Pizza
Mushroom Onion Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Steak and Cheese
French Fries

“Place is awesome and comforting to see it like it was when I was a kid!! Awesome food still!! Was in there tonight so busy one phone call after the next and I must say the lil girl working phone and take out was amazing!!! What a multitasker!!! Great job!!“

4.2 Good54 Reviews
Tuscany Tavern Bar • $$
294 Court St, Plymouth

“This would rate five stars if it had parking. Otherwise terrific food with a limited menu. Also the dining area is nice but basic. Lacks the ambiance due to its location but the open kitchen helps. Service was excellent with dutiful knowledge of wines and pairings. I would go there again and again. Thoroughly enjoyed the food as usual; no unpleasant surprises.“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Mamma Mia's Restaurants Italian • $
3 Village Green N #312, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Tortellini Soup
Eggplant Tower
Caprese Salad
Garlic Bread
Greek Salad
Italian Sub
Meatballs
Linguine
Sauce
Pizza

“Went to Mamma Mia's in the Pinehills after taking our granddaughter to see Santa and it was an excellent end to our day. We sat in the bar area and the service was outstanding. Both my wife and I ordered saltimbocca (me veal, her chicken). The food was delicious and the portions big enough that we each had a second meal left! The bartender was efficient and accurate in our order. She checked on us several times to make sure all our needs were taken care of. My wife had a martini and said it was well made.Parking: Not sure of number of spots but we had no problem finding parking on a Saturday afternoon.“

4.1 Good65 Reviews
Cafe Strega Italian • $$
16 Main St Ext, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Ravioli Di Costolette Di Manzo Brasati
Spaghetti Alla Carbonara
Ravioli All Aragosta
Penne Alla Siciliana
Penne Alla Boscaiola
Crespelle Ripiene
Mango Sorbet

“I was having a bad night and this restaurant completely turned everything around for me. Starting with the Hostess who was engaging, funny and very invested in making sure we got a seat. We had a reservation but we arrived 45 minutes early. The atmosphere is quaint and comfortable. There is a pleasant chatter in the restaurant from everyone having a nice time, but it is not so loud that you can't hear everyone at your table. The staff is unsurpassed. Our waitress in particular made our night.(Ashley M) She was hilarious and thought we were fun too. (Always a good feeling!) Now for the food... We started with a fresh, delicious Caesar Salad. Followed by incredible Chicken Parm with the most delicious red sauce! We wrapped up our evening with a hugh, delicious piece of chocolate cake and Vanilla Bean Gelato. We WILL be back again and again. I regret that I waited this long to try Strega!“

3.9 Good31 Reviews
Stevie's Pizza Plymouth Pizza • $
46 Main St, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Pizza De Catupiry

“Stevie’s uses high quality, fresh ingredients, and the difference can definitely be tasted! Their pizza toppings are portioned generously and everything is cooked just right! I’ve been told by someone who works there that the kitchen is always kept exceptionally clean! The people who take orders on the phone and the drivers are very friendly and courteous. Five star + IMO!“

4.1 Good24 Reviews
Plymouth House Pizzeria & Pub Pizza • $
50 Long Pond Rd, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Meatball or Sausage
Mozzarella Sticks
Gluten Free Pizza
Steak and Cheese
Chicken Broccoli
Pepperoni Pizza
Combo Appetizer
Buffalo Chicken
Philly Steak
Sandwich

“Ordered 3 pizzas, cheese, Hawaiian and pizza skin, unbelievable flavor. Light crispy crust with a clean tasting dough. I have previously ordered the chicken parm and that is the best I have ever had. Go try it out for yourself, we will be back.“

4 Good46 Reviews
Toscana Restaurant Italian • $$
87 Sandwich St, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Gnocchi Bolognese
Veal Marsala
Picatta
Tuscany
Caprese

“Authentic Boston North-end dining experience in Downtown Plymouth. Fantastic food, drinks very relaxing atmosphere , keyboard entertainment on Weekends with Joe K… Always allow yourself a very relaxed evening to dine,it is small quaint and you will not be rushed.“

3.9 Good40 Reviews
Long Pond Pizza Factory Pizza • $
25 Home Depot Dr, Plymouth

“I eat here a lot during the lunchtime hour because it is close to my work place.Whether I am calling or going in, they are very fast, receptive and nice.The food is cooked great, it isn’t messy and there are a million options.The prices are on the lower end compared to neighboring establishments so that is also a benefit!If you haven’t stopped in, swing through and try them out.“

3.8 Good23 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
102 Colony Pl, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Chicken & Gnocchi a Creamy Soup Made with Roasted Chicken Italian Dumplings and Spinach
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
Chocolate Brownie Lasagna
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Create Your Own Pasta
Endless Garden Salad
Spinach-Artichoke Dip
Chicken Parmigiana
Minestrone Soup
Lasagna Fritta

“My post isn’t about the food which is always good. Our waiter was Justin. Nicest kid on the planet he provided excellent service.His parents must be proud. Since moving to Plymouth a couple years ago we finally made it. Would come back in a heartbeat.“

3.9 Good76 Reviews
JoeK Music Piano Bar at Toscana's Plymouth Italian • $$
87 Sandwich St, Plymouth

“Authentic Boston North-end dining experience in Downtown Plymouth. Fantastic food, drinks very relaxing atmosphere , keyboard entertainment on Weekends with Joe K… Always allow yourself a very relaxed evening to dine,it is small quaint and you will not be rushed.“

3.5 Good14 Reviews
Bertucci's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
6 Plaza Way, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Broccoli Alfredo
Craft Your Own Calzone
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Tuscan Chicken Wings
Chicken Piccata
Any Small Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Bread and Oil
Cheese Pizza
Margherita

“Went for lunch with my very Italian fiancé and we were impressed! David was friendly and when I asked for a recommendation he went into great detail between my two choice to make it easier. I was not disappointed. It was roughly $60 for the both of us (which isn’t bad in today’s world). The service and food was good enough that we left a 40% tip, left full and satisfied and will be back in the future.“

3.8 Good109 Reviews
Mamma Mia's Restaurants Italian • $$
122 Water St, Plymouth

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Marsala with Pasta
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmigiana
Gluten Free Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan
Homemade Noodles
Pasta Bolognese
Cannoli Dessert

“Went to Mamma Mia's in Marshfield tonight. The restaurant was closed but the bar was packed. Got a seat at the bar and could not believe what I was watching. There was a young girl named kira behind the bar not only was she the bartender but she was the bar back she was the hostess, the waitress, the server, the the bus girl, the Keno there was nothing she didn't do well maybe except for cook but she did it all at a hundred miles an hour and everything she did was 100% right drinks were right, food was right, she was right on time, nobody had to wait she was an amazing amazing server/bartender and I just wanted to say I think she was great! Also have to say she kept every single person happy. It was amazing to watch her work and I think any employer would be happy to have 10 more of her!“

3.6 Good114 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More In Plymouth

map Map