21 Best Pizza Restaurants near Gardner

“so accommodating and friendly! I have a severe gluten allergy and the owner took such great care of my son and I. really appreciated it! the meal was life giving and my son loved the spaghetti and meatballs. I highly recommend!“

“delicious pizza and quick, friendly service!“

“Great place for pizza and subs! Can’t believe I just found them this year! Love the Steak bomb sub which quickly became a favorite! The grilled Veggie is delicious too! Finally tried the Steak Bomb pizza, and WOW! It was so good!! We have done both pick up & delivery and ALWAYS great service.“

“The best Pizza my husband and I have ever eaten in this whole area! We ordered the house pizza,the ingredients were fresh,the crust was a thin crust, just the way we like it,the sauce was so good,with real mozzarella cheese.also,my grandson who is a picky eater ,ate a whole small cheese pizza by himself.you can tell they take a lot of pride making their pies.if you want good pizza,I would recommend coming here any day,and the owners are so friendly!“

“Always love their food! Ordered a cheeseburger plate last night and they always make it just right! Fries were also excellent. My family members each got a pizza. A small pepperoni and a small Hawaiian. Always good quality and was delivered before the time stated online! Highly recommend! Also if you don’t want two separate burgers or you’re not sharing with someone, just ask for two patties on one bun!“

“I have loved the Thanksgiving toasted for years.
Ever since they merged over to Papa Ginos, they forget it EVERY single time. I've come to a point where I stopped ordering it, due to the negligence of not getting the gravy. It does seem like a silly thing but it really makes the sandwich complete.
Other than that it has been great.“

“Colonial Grille is hands down one of the best restaurants in this area. The seafood is always so tasty. We have always had 10/10 meals here. The staff is welcoming and the drinks are great. Please, please, please advertise!! Your staff deserve to make the most that they can and your chefs deserve the notoriety!!“

“I have been ordering from this location for about 6 years now and have never received the spectacular service like Nathan gave. I called concerning that my son's pizza was not going to be delivered on time and Nathan went above and beyond to try to help.“

“We love Pizza Palace 🙌 I've never had anything bad here. the scampi pizza...🤯😋 highly recommend“

“Mike’s pizza was an obvious choice when staying for a couple days at Great Wolf Lodge. It was less than 10 minutes from the facility, had an easy online order option, and was a fraction of the inflated-resort pricing at the park. Our large order, right before close, was executed to perfection. The owner met me at the counter, and had a pleasant conversation about the history of his shop, and how long he’d been operating out of that building. The atmosphere was great, and I would absolutely go back if we come to town again.
The food was spectacular and the portions were phenomenal. We had a couple specialty pizzas, a couple orders of boneless chicken, and jalapeño poppers. Everything was great when we first got it, and was just as good cold the next morning when we finished the leftovers we had.“

“I saw some good reviews online, so my wife and I decided to give it a try. Wow! I could not believe how good the food was. They actually hand battered their chicken fingers for my chicken finger sub. It was amazing! My wife got the cheese steak and it was one of the best she has had in a long time.
Although this place is old, it is very clean. There was one woman working both the sub shop and the convenience store, but she had no problems and was a pleasure to talk to.
This place has a little of everything. Ice cream, convenience store, and pizza and sub shop.
I will definitely be going back to try the pizza.“

“best lasagna ever since my Dad's homemade mild sauce very hot fresh“

“Chicken Parm Sub Amazing.“

“Their always friendly and the foods always fresh and delicious 😋“

“Amazing variety and great prices! Always fresh food ❤️“

“I just had the best toasted turkey sub I’ve ever had! He does a great job !“

“This has always been our go to pizza place, but this is the first time I have ever ordered a seafood plate from a pizza store. My husband and I really enjoyed the fish and onion rings. Good quality fish, perfectly cooked, great onion rings and very good coleslaw. Will order again.“

“We got a simple mushroom and onion pizza and it was amazing. The crust is simply the best we've had in the area. Our new favorite! The sauce was super flavorful and good fresh ingredients just added to the enjoyment. Thank you! We will be back! Great garlic bread! Good fresh and cold crispy salad. Thanks again!“

““Stefanos’ House of Pizza is truly a gem! The quality of the food is consistently top-notch – every pizza is perfectly cooked with fresh, flavorful ingredients. Beyond the amazing taste, the service is exceptional. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and always goes above and beyond to ensure a great experience. Whether dining in or ordering for takeout, Stefanos’ makes you feel like a valued customer every time. Highly recommend for anyone craving delicious pizza and great service!”“

“I ordered a standard 16 inch with pepperoni, extra cheese and beef toppings, and it is just phenomenal. So happy to have another great pizza joint in the town.“

“The staff were very friendly and kitchen was clean, not to mention the food was delicious. I chatted with the owner and he was so down to earth. Im definitely going here more often.“