Natalie's Pizzeria

1312 Commonwealth Ave, Allston
(617) 277-7662

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Danaé Barg

Ordered Alfredo through DoorDash and received pasta with chicken and marinara sauce. When I called I was told I was speaking to a manager who then informed me they didn’t have all the ingredients to make fettuccine alfredo so they sent me this instead? Turns out I wasn’t speaking to a manager who then just hung up the phone on me.I’d call and ask if they have all the things on their menu before ordering.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brooke Anderson

I was disappointed with my order tonight. I ordered from Uber eats - I got a cold Italian sub and a cheesecake dessert. The menu days the Italian comes with oil and vinegar, but there was no dressing on it and it was dry. They also gave me a chocolate cake instead of a cheesecake.

Jon Gravely

We ordered a sandwich and quesadilla. The sandwich was dryer than the desert with absolutely no sauce. The quesadilla that was supposed to come with sour cream and salsa didn't have any. The tortilla was cooked poorly and also lacked the chicken we requested as well.

Food: 3

Service: 1

maple georgia

This place needs to be reported. They don’t close anywhere near 3:30 am. They were closed at 10:45 pm when I went. If you don’t open late then don’t post that you do

Jay Randle

The Pizza was the absolute best i’ve had a very long time. I had the Buffalo chicken pizza and I don’t usually make reviews but it was so good i had to leave one.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Ethan Park

STAY AWAY. Ordered from here on Uber Eats to end up being completely scammed. Ordered alfredo chicken fettuccini, a cheeseburger with all toppings, and two soda cans. Ended up receiving some random pasta dish that tasted like raw tomatoes, no garlic bread when it said it’s included, a burger with nothing but a patty in two buns (not even cheese when its a cheeseburger), the burger came with 10 tiny short leftover fries and onion rings, and no sodas. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. If they respond to this review they’ll probably just say something like sorry and not do anything about it because half of their reviews are clearly all one stars. Once again, DO NOT EAT FROM HERE.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Trevon Jackson

Don’t waste your time, orders are mediocre

Marissa Symia

I enjoyed the pizza and the service as well. It was a blessing on our trip.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Mrugank Kothadiya

Worst Service Ever. Don’t go. Don’t ORDER!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nicole Pirog

As someone who works a job which lends itself to ordering food at 3am, I can confidently say my options are not only limited but usually pretty terrible. Until we found Natalie’s. The Margarita pizza is BOMB. We tried the calzone last night, and that thing has cheese baked right on top. Outstanding. It never takes long, the delivery range seems to be wide (we order it to Waltham) and it has never disappointed. Bartenders and other night walkers take note, 10/10 this place will treat you right.

Food: 5

M T

I literally got 2 cakes when I ordered 2 large pizza after waiting for 3 hours. Dont ever get food from here they will make you wait for hours and wont even give you your food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ahmet yasin ERDİL

The worst pizza I have ever eaten in my life, it arrived burnt and we received it 1 hour

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken

Joelle Choiniere

Great pizza, great time.??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yvonne N

Pizza is great! I love that they are open so

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza

Han Xia

Pizza was cold. I’d give it 3 stars if it was warm but even so the pizza was mediocre. The only reason I don’t give it one star is because it’s open until 2am on a Saturday.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Loading...