25 Best Bakeries near Brewster

“Love getting my baked treats from Geri! From her Hummingbird wedding cakes and her tasty cranberry bread made with local cranberries to her fantastic sour dough! Everything she makes is delicious. Highly recommend getting your next sugar fix from Cape Cakes! Geri is the best!“

“Just stopped here for our last breakfast out on our way home from our week stay. The gift shop is beautiful, and the bakery is so worth the visit. I grabbed a variety of muffins and scones for my family, and all items were delicious and fresh. Everything about the Hopkins House Bakery has put it at the top of my must-visit-again list.“

“We ordered our elopement cake from Eat Cake and it was perfect! We were able to do two different flavors, both delicious - most people ate left overs for breakfast the next morning. Ordering process was seamless with a quick turnaround and I would definitely recommend!“

“We purchased Cranberry Scones they were incredible!! Blueberry muffin and chocolate chip banana muffin delicious. We will only go there for baked goods and tell our friends and family. I would give them 5+ stars!“

“We have gotten a lot of cakes from Brenda over the years and they have always been more than we expected!“

“We tried the raspberry filled donut, blueberry scone with lemon icing, gluten free brownie, and vanilla cake with strawberry filling and Earl Gray frosting. Everything was very good but the cake and brownie were our favorites. The bakers were very friendly to talk to. We highly recommend!“

“Definitely a very busy shop. It is absolutely worth the wait though. The muffins are ginormous, and breakfast sandwiches are great. You have to get there very early to get the muffins you want. I have started ordering online for pick up. You have to order by 8pm the day before, and can chose what time you pick up. That way you can guarantee you get the muffins you want and tou dont have to wake up at dawn. Been going here for years and love that they have this new location with easier parking than their Lower County location.“

“It's been a tradition now for 4 years to get a chocolate covered donut with sprinkles for my granddaughters birthday which we celebrate here while on vacation, she loves it and of course I need to get one for the ride back to the house, never disappointed..
Love woolfies.“

“The sfogliatelle are the best! The flakiest shell pastry with not too sweet ricotta citron filling. But they're only available Fridays and Saturdays because they take 3 Days to make! Cannolis filled to order with pistachio nuts are divine.“

“👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽“

“Trish made a beautiful and delicious birthday cake for me this June. My Dad and I enjoyed it immensely! Thank you Trish! I highly recommend Kiss Me Cakes!“

“Whenever we’re in Cape Cod and have a birthday or special event we always order from Corner of Yum! Carole is so great at accommodating our dairy free needs and everything always tastes AMAZING! She makes beautiful cakes (the hummingbird cake is our favorite) and made the most adorable cupcakes for my daughter’s first birthday. We will keep coming back for sure! They also have a great chai latte! Thank you Carole and Corner of Yum!“

“Bought a loaf of the English muffin bread to take home. So glad we did! Absolutely delicious. Can't wait to grab more next time we are in the area.“

“Best donuts ever. I wish they. were open Year round.“

“Ordered custom Gender Reveal cake & came out beautiful & delicious. We wanted white cake marbelized in pink or blue (we discovered my first grandchild is a girl so ours was pink). The frosting was a traditional piping & cover of delicious whipped cream & it had lots of lovely pink & white roses of yummy buttercream.“

“Found this place on google. So glad we did. Our kids loved the hot chocolate. A little disappointed no frozen coffee drink, but very much enjoyed my iced mocha! Fantastic customer service. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Delicious blueberry pie.👍“

“Great quality coffee products, as well as breakfast pastries etc. Love the friendly staff as well. The atmosphere in Brewster is warm and inviting, super casual. Manuel and his crew do a great job! Love the new 'outpost' in Chatham as well. Best coffee in town there, and I always stop in when I'm in town. Buena suerte!“

“Excellent customer service. It’s so easy to expect unhappy employees during these difficult times, but this is never the case here. Always friendly, smiling, genuinely happy. I ordered a burrito for my children forgetting 1 does not enjoy tomato’s. I came back in to order something more simple and the lovely employee gave me scrambled eggs and bacon in a to go bowl, complimentary. She didn’t have to do that. It was my error. So much appreciated. The food is fresh with flavor, and that’s hard to come by when ordering “quick” bites. Cheers“

“Quite possibly the best breakfast bagel sandwich that I've ever had. Sausage egg and cheese was out of this world. Kind of on the expensive side, but that's the world we live in now.

I like being able to eat my messy bagel sandwich out in the back yard dining area.

When I'm back in the area I will eat here again every time for sure.“

“Really good and surprisingly large donuts. We waited in line 25 mins just to get inside (not a problem as the place is clearly popular) and order. We ordered 4 donuts (plus 2drinks) but as we were going to keep the donuts in the car while we spent a few hours at the beach I requested a box (she has started to put them in a bag). Well I don’t know why she got so upset that I requested a box, she gave me the meanest stare and smirk instead of just saying ‘sure no problem!’- the lady from Jamaica. That made us feel very uncomfortable. Then when we check out the tip screen comes up and you guys expect a 25% tip? Please take care of your customers and drop The attitude:) a box costs 50 cents max.“

“Best, best lunch in the area! My favorite?! The East-West sandwich with extra extra amazing kimchi!! Check it out and I promise you will find an amazing menu and fabulous team who serve up joy and tasty treats every day! 🙌🥳💖“

“The best staff and Cold Brew on the Cape!!!“

“I love going to Buckiesbiscotti , everything there is fresh and delicious 😋“

“One of those sandwiches people may overlook at first because it’s meatloaf… until they actually try it. The meatloaf sandwich at Chatham Cookware is unbelievably delicious — juicy, flavorful, comforting, and packed with homemade taste in every bite. Fresh toppings, soft bread, and the kind of flavor that instantly brings back memories of summers on the Cape. Honestly the perfect sandwich to grab and take to the beach. Some foods just feel nostalgic… and this is definitely one of them. ☀️🏖️🥪“