Fat Tomato
$ • PizzaAbout Fat Tomato
Customers' Favorites
Sweet Potato Fries Served in Small Pizza Box
New York Thin Crust with Pepperoni
Classic Italian Pizza
The Wise Guy Pizza
Cauliflower Crust
Meatball Grinder
Tour of Italy
Tuscan Roni
Crime Scene
Porky Pig
Fat Tomato Reviews
135 ratings
Share your opinion about Fat Tomato
It’s ight
Ps. The owner is
Ps. The owner is
I Beg for everybody to try this place out you owe it to yourself. This is in my top two pizza places of all time And I’ve tried a lot of pizza. The owner is just a nice dude that loves making pizza and let me tell you he does it right. Nowhere else in the state, let alone Holyoke even comes close this pizza I promise. Just look at this photo, where else is making you something that even looks close to this good. And trust me it taste even better than it looks. I have ordered...read full review
This is the best pizza in the Holyoke area. I got a large pepperoni last night, absolutely delicious. Tasty, great sauce, perfect under carriage and nice crust. Can’t wait to try the other pizzas on the menu. Highly recommend.
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 4 - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 7PM |
Fat Tomato is a restaurant that serves exceptional Italian cuisine, including delectable pizzas and grinders. The reviews praise the establishment's dedication to quality ingredients and attention to detail in their food preparation. The "Cattlemen Pizza," "New York Thin with Half Pepperoni," and "Sicilian" are among the customer favorites, with the crust receiving high acclaim for its crispiness and flavor. Customers also appreciate the restaurant's selection of Italian specialty items available for purchase. Many visitors praise the pizza, especially when picked up fresh, calling it the best in the area. The menu also includes hearty sandwiches like Philly flyer hero, which can be a meal for two, as well as salads, wings, meatball appetizers, and ice cream cookies. Customers note that Fat Tomato is a small business with staffing challenges, so some wait times and hours may vary, and patience is appreciated. Recent reviews highlight that the pizza is considered the best in Holyoke, with perfect crusts and delicious toppings like ricotta. One reviewer enjoyed the Ma's Garden pizza and a generous portion of tiramisu, praising both for their quality. Overall, Fat Tomato is a beloved destination for those seeking authentic and flavorful Italian food.