12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Holyoke

“Ordered GF pizza. Sooo good!!! Its usually a hit or miss. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.“

“the staff was so friendly and helpful. the restaurant was actually closed, but since they had 2 larger parties still there finishing up they sat us. we felt bad and we told them we would leave and they insisted we stay. we are so glad we did the food was delicious and so flavorful. it was also very reasonably priced for the quality and quantity. we plan to go back and try several other items we saw on the menu.“

“Giant pizza 🍕 slices! Excellent service!😁“

“Tried their chowder at a “chowder fest” this weekend and it was totally delicious. I would highly recommend it 👍🏻👍🏻“

“Good food and great people!“

“This is hands down the best pizza in Massachusetts, maybe the best pizza anywhere. I moved from Phoenix about 4 years ago and was missing my favorite pizza spot until I found Fat Tomato, which quickly became my new favorite pizza spot. Now I am kind of addicted and have to get a Tuscan Roni at least once a month. I agree with all the other reviews about how fresh the ingredients are—they use really good quality ingredients and it makes such a difference. Also, the owner was kind enough to give me some free cannolis to try and they are SO SO good! Would definitely recommend giving this place a try if you’re in the area—it’s a Western Mass hidden gem!“

“Capri is one of the best pizza places in Massachusetts. ( Been going for 40 years!) When I lived in western MA we would go every weekend. I live in the eastern part now but still go when visiting family. Out this way, many places including some that have been reviewed by "influencers", the box weighs more than the pizza and the cost is more!“

“This place is awesome. Their food is consistently very good, prices are reasonable, and the staff is always very quick and friendly. Their gourmet grinders are my go to and are usually good to feed two people. 10/10! Thank you for all you do!“

“I have eaten here more than 3 times and this place is a must. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. Great for the portion and quality of food. This place was easy to find parking, family friendly, and great location! Highly recommend you stop and have a lunch or dinner with the family. The owner Joshua and Jessica made me and my family feel welcomed and where a pleasure to interact with! I will be going there again very soon!“

“It is open until 3 am.Good pizza“

“I don’t do delivery here because they use Doordash for delivery services. But when I do pick up it’s pretty safe. They re-made my pizza fresh the other day because they gave me the wrong order. Only took an extra 15 minutes and it was perfect. It’s a good amount of food for the price and the toppings are always consistent.“

“Love Schermerhorn's! always abundant great food“