50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Wilbraham

“First time visiting. Love the atmosphere & decor. We were seated right away for a Friday night dinner with no reservation. Service was great. Meals were fantastic! We had Chicken Parmesan and Gorganzola on Main. The portions were so large that I had two more meals of the chicken gorganzola to bring home (not a complaint). Definitely worth it! My only negative comment is that there was supposed to be spinach in that dish and if it was there, it was cut too small to find. We will go back!“

“This place was absolutely amazing their food was delicious the customer service was great would definitely recommend“

“Pizza is always great and delivery drivers are amazing! 5 stars“

“Always a good time! Especially when they have live, local music🎶“

“Highly Recommended. 8.45/10 I ordered the XL 18" Italian Meat Lover, consisting of pepperoni, ham, meatball and sausage and added bacon and ricotta. Crust: 24 hour fermentation. Crisp. Very flavorful. Airy. Excellent texture. Well done bake. 9.25/10. Sauce: Balanced. Fresh. Vibrant. Not overpowering. Tasty and flavorful. Contributes to overall flavor. Robust. While I very much enjoyed this sauce, it seemed different from my original visit and less sweet. 9.25/10 Cheese + toppings: Great cheese and melt. Excellent sausage that was very flavorful. Great crispy bacon. Good but not great pepperoni. Very mild ham that I didn't love. Meatball just okay / borderline. Ricotta was okay but was not creamy like I prefer and was a bit crumbly in texture. 7.25/10 Size/Value: XL is a 18" and the specialty Italian Meat Lover was $23.99 (base cheese is $20.99 in this size). Additional Toppings are $1.29/ea for Large and XL, however I realized after I was not charged for bacon (not included in the Meat Lover and ricotta (assuming error). I will gladly pay them the $2.58 for the (2) extra toppings. This is the most affordable 18" Meat Lovers in Citrus County. Foam cups but they now have ceramic plates (my last experience didn't love the dine-in paper plates). VERY happy about this 😂 ❤️ 🍕 Owners Ted and Kim are actively engaged and very sweet people, as identified from my original review last month. While the location is a little out of the way for some, it makes perfect sense for them as it's around the corner from home, including staff. I didn't mind the location. Local community members (Ted is a local Rotarian) who offer 10% veteran / police / fire discounts. I appreciated that they spoke well of other pizza restaurants, supporting the community. Ted previously mentioned while other places may do things differently, that there is room for everyone as they all have their niche. Kim is from NJ (one of the pizza capitals) who pushed Ted to start this pizza venture. While he's been in the food industry, this is his first pizza business ownership. They use the industry standard Bakers Pride (quality) ovens. You may have had his food before as he does the cooking for the famous "Beast Feast". Looking forward to going back and trying their white pizza 🍕 ❤️“

“I was extremely impressed with everything about this place! It is in a service plaza and if you know anything about service plaza’s your choices are usually limited to franchise fast food.

This pizza restaurant serves pizza, pasta and chicken tenders and I must say that the quality of food and service was excellent!

To start I was greeted by this amazing personality called Robin. Robin was so warm and, welcoming and friendly that I almost thought I was visiting family. She asked great questions to inquire about what I had a taste for. She then made some recommendations and made sure that I was getting something that I would be happy with. I ended up trying the pizza, spaghetti and meatballs with extra meatballs and cheesy garlic bread. She informed me that it would take a few minutes because she had to make the bread sticks by order. I took the food to go and she made sure my food was packed to travel!“

“We moved from chicopee and looking for a great pizza shop we tried many but this one is the best all the food you can not go wrong with and the people make you feel like family when you walk in . iIt is a small shop but worth it family always ask for pan pizza when we go to their home to visit :) thank you for your service PAN PIZZA we will travel when we move“

“We visited Mario’s for the first time on Friday Feb 27th after seeing a Facebook ad for their fish and chips dinner. We were beyond surprised and very pleased with the entire experience. The fish and chips was the best we have had, the waitress was very attentive and friendly. Although the place is small it was super busy with lots of take out orders but that didn’t affect the dining room orders coming out in a timely fashion. We most definitely will be visiting again real soon to see what other delicious choices they have on their menu. Great job Mario see you again soon.“

“After browsing through Facebook I spotted a plate of fish& ships and my friend and I drove in from South hadley for a taste, We Loved it very much. Great Food,and great Customer service.“

“I’ve been coming to Family Pizzeria for years, and even left them a 5-star review over 7 years ago. After a long break since 2020, I finally made it back—and I’m happy to say the place is just as great, if not better, than I remember.

The dining room is clean, cozy, and welcoming with exposed brick, friendly vibes, and plenty of seating. The staff was warm and attentive throughout our visit, making the experience feel personal and relaxed. It was great to see the same sense of family and community I remembered from before.

We started with their tortellini soup and stuffed garlic bread—fresh, hot, and comforting. For entrées, we had the spaghetti and meatballs and the lasagna. Both were flavorful, generous in portion, and served piping hot. The sauce is rich and classic, the kind that sticks with you in a good way.

Family Pizzeria still lives up to its name—great food, great service, and a place that feels like home. I came back to upgrade my review, and I’m glad I did. If you’re looking for an authentic local spot with hearty Italian comfort food, this is it.“

“My favorite pizza is the garlic ricotta mozzarella it is so good“

“The only pizza we'll eat. family members in MA sometimes as me to grab them a pie on my way when I visit!“

“I’ve loved Monson pizza for as long as I remember. I just love the pizza and the grinders are great too. The employees, well, they have never once been rude or unhelpful, they are always wonderful. You can always count on Monson pizza for pleasant experience and good food!“

“They have the best Veal and Sausage parmigiana Grinder one of the best in the area This is my go to Spot from now on“

“I've been going to Indian Orchard pizzeria for over 40 years. Before I was tall enough to reach the counter. The pizza tastes just as good today as it did 40 years ago. The prices are the best around. The lady of the shop Mrs. Ferrara is such a kind and loving woman. When I walked in there May 1st 2026 I couldn't believe my eyes. There she was running the shop at 90 years old! She puts so much love into making pizza and that's why it's still tastes great to this day!! Here's to many more years Mrs. Ferrara!!!!“

“excellent restaurant with nice seating. owners care about their customers. been going here for 20 years.“

“Best pizza place in Massachusetts! Atmosphere is filled with cheerful people service is fairly quick when ordering out although I've never ate in i am assuming its also great also there efforts to help the earthquakes in turkey is well harted“

“We have not been for 2 years. New owners have painted and looks like new carpets, and booths are more comfortable! Had a calzone which was delicious. And spouse had a Italian grinder, states it is perfect. Great food, new owners have done a great job.“

“Excellent food and service. Clean“

“Eggplant parmigiana was wonderful , pasta al dente , sauce not too acidic 👌... fries, pizza, wings are also delicious. Husky never disappoints!!!!
Except for Mondays since they are closed but we all need a break don't we lol
Delivery driver is very courteous! Great restaurant over all“

“literally THE BEST around!!! and the young lady at the counter is so sweet and professional!! they couldn't have chose anyone better to provide such polite, amazing customer service with a smile!! Never seems frustrated, nor overwhelmed... I don't know why it took me so long to try this place! it is now my definite go to! As soon as you walk in you smell the pizza place you remember as a kid... A REAL pizza shop!!!“

“just ordered 2 large Italian grinders and they were great. fresh bread lots of meat and didn't have to pay extra for lettuce, tomatoes and peppers !“

“We ordered 2 large grinders. One steak and cheese and the other was tuna.
They are the biggest and best grinders and very fresh.
Take out today and I'm sure we will have plenty for 2 more full meals.
Palermo staff, this was excellent.....
Outstanding quality food and friendly atmosphere“

“We were visiting the area on a shopping excursion and were recommended this establishment by another local business owner. The place is very clean and the staff are courteous and attentive. The Tikka pizza was very tasty. The sauce was delicious and not too salty. Would definitely eat there again.“

“As a self-proclaimed foodie (and someone very loyal to my usual pizza spot 👀), I had to see what the hype was about at Bella Milano’s after multiple staff at my job kept mentioning their meat lovers pizza (PAUSE).

Let me just say… y’all nailed it. The flavor was on point, but what really stood out was the topping distribution! Every bite had the perfect balance. No empty slices, no overload in one spot… just consistent, quality pizza all the way through. Especially close to closing, I appreciate the quality control.

I’m not saying I’m ready to fully commit yet 😂 but let’s just say I’ll definitely be ordering again… once I figure out how to break up with my other spot.

Highly recommend.“

“Best food and very polite workers! Love them!“

“No doubt a 5 star review for this pizza place! When we came in we were told we could get seated anywhere we’d like . Our two children were offered high chairs. Our waiter was very pleasant. The food was ready quite fast!! you could tell the food was homemade , the mozzarella sticks were out of this world! Overall we were very pleased with our experience!“

“Best pizza in the area. The young men that work there are so kind and respectful. Especially Erik, he’s my favorite“

“Best pizza in springfield hands down! If you like italian thin pizza this is the place also has great crinkle fries and the Also sell homemade Patty's cupcakes that are the best ? been coming here for years for that italian pizza flavor“

“I ordered 3 party sized pizzas for delivery the next day. The girl taking the order was very pleasant, as well as the delivery driver. He was also right on scheduled time. Pizza was delicious and hot. Great experience overall. Thank you!!!“

“Every time we come here it’s phenomenal“

“We thoroughly enjoyed our hamburger and cheese pizza. We got delivery and it came very fast. It was hot and delicious. We will definitely be ordering from you again. Thanks so very much.“

“I ordered for the first time for pizza last week. Everything we ordered was perfect. Even the slices of pizza were amazingly even. I ordered my pizza without cheese due to a dairy sensitivity and that was also done just right. I will be a return customer for sure. Thank you“

“grinders are excellent delivery is loyal and friendly“

“I ordered a meat lovers calzone tonight and it was definetly worth the time and money. Excellent 5 stars!“

“Absolutely delicious. Definitely go try them out!!!“

“Best food around!!! All the Greek dishes are outstanding. Family owned and operated- great people.“

“Staying in the area and wanted to try something new, we order a sandwich, some apps, and fried dough. Our food was AMAZING! Not only was it hot when we got it home, but everything was delicious. The girl working behind the counter was so friendly! Will def be ordering again when we are back in the area.“

“As a local business owner that frequents Anthony's Restaurant, I've yet to have a less than great experience. Many locals truly appreciate the quality the owner puts into his authentic dishes. The pizza is always great, with generous toppings, the meatballs are homemade and flavorful, the sauce is also taseful and the dishes are plentiful! The owner has been in the business for decades and truly cares deeply about thir customers experiences and is very friendly. This restaurant includes a family effort, they provide a clean and positive family experience and local business love their food as well. I know personally, because I provide gift cards on behalf of business relationships in the area & their always happy with their experiences. I recommend giving them another try - to those who had unfortunate past experience, they've got a better crew than they once had. Keep in mind it's been profoundly challenging these past few years on small businesses & good help dosen't come easy.“

“They have the best wings and great customer service! Highly recommend!“

“life long favorite. One of the few places that can cook chicken wings good“

“Food is spectacular The best Italian since I moved to Connecticut Our server was excellent“

“Spacious, good service, many tv’s“

“First time at Milanos, very good experience. The two people behind the bar were efficient and friendly — I had a spicy marg and a tasty spritz with strawberry and fig. Friendly patrons at the bar. Pizza was delicious. Alfredo and manicotti both good. Very welcoming environment. It’s an hour drive for us and we will for sure be back.“

“Only place I order from, Best pizza around!!!“

“Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. I feel like since the economy has gone downhill, everyone seems to be skimping on everything. Not the case here, I’ve only ordered twice but I have been so happy with the food both times. Everything is so fresh and there is actually enough cheese , which seems to be an issues many places these days. Will be my go to for pizza from now on!“

“Good piZZA ON A budget, feeds whole family of four under $30. The tracker is great tells you exactly when to go and pick up your order. We do the 6.99 medium 2 topping pizza when you buy two or more and get a cheesy bread with marinara sauce is perfect. On pizza Philly steak and mushroom with extra cheese and sauce is perfect. Highly recommend , the parking lot is large and has a lot of shade.“