50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Lexington

“We went there for the first time the other day and we were absolutely pleased with everything there. The food was delicious, expertly prepared, and the atmosphere was spot on! The staff was friendly and eager to talk with us like we were family! I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a great meal.“

“I've ordered from this place a few times and it is always prepared quickly and quality is as expected. The service is polite and friendly from employees such as Neshlihan. I will likely order again from this place, especially with the generous deals including free pizzas which are occasionally offered!“

“Definitely one of the top places in Greater Boston area with great taste and affordable prices. Went there yesterday and tried their pizza and a few subs for the family. Incredible taste and superior customer service. Just ordered more food through delivery today for lunch as well. And, the food was amazing and arrived in a timely manner. So glad to have finally found a great place with authentic Greek/Italian flavors in the area.“

“india Pizza in Lexington, MA - A Hidden Gem. I recently visited India Pizza in Lexington, MA, for the first time and wasn't sure what to order. I decided on fried chicken and fried vegetable rice, which turned out to be an awesome choice. The rice came out first, and it was fantastic. The chicken was perfectly crisp, just the way I like it, even though I didn't request it that way. The customer service was top-notch—very professional. I only interacted with one staff member, but the service was fast, and I didn't have to wait long for anything. I highly recommend you try their food. I'll definitely be coming back. Excellent service all around! I'm not a person who try different culture foods. The reviews sold me. The Service I received again was top notch 👌 👍“

“Nick’s Place on Massachusetts Avenue in Lexington, Massachusetts, offers some of the best comfort takeout food around. I love picking up a couple of meals here for me and my wife when neither one of has the time or energy to pull together dinner after an exhausting work day. Enjoy - Robert.“

“Stopped on a whim on the way home from the airport with a family member. Ordered the garlic bread, chicken broccoli alfredo, eggplant parm w/ alfredo sauce and tiramisu. The food was amazing! I can’t remember having a better tiramisu anywhere else. I wish I lived closer I would definitely be there on a regular basis. Set up is not typical, you order at the counter and they bring you the food. But you get your own drink from a cooler or iced water, silverware, napkins and bus your own dishes. So I was a little off put that I tipped 20% to do all the service myself. Staff was friendly and did give us to-go boxes when we asked for them. Would definitely recommend!“

“Tucked between a laundromat and a corner store, this humble pizza spot doesn’t try to impress you—and that’s exactly its charm. The kind of place where the menu board hasn’t changed in years, the soda fridge hums loudly in the corner, and the smell of dough and melted cheese hits you before you even open the door.

The pizza itself is refreshingly unpretentious. The crust has that perfect balance—crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside—with just enough char to remind you it was made by hand, not by conveyor belt. The sauce leans slightly sweet, clearly simmered longer than most, and the cheese is generous without crossing into greasy territory. Toppings are simple and classic, but fresh enough to matter.

What really makes the place stand out is the atmosphere. It’s casual in the truest sense—no curated aesthetic, no attempt at trendiness. Just a few worn tables, a steady stream of regulars, and staff who greet people like they’ve been coming in for years (because most of them have). Service is quick, friendly, and refreshingly real.

This isn’t the spot you go to for gourmet slices or Instagram photos. It’s where you go when you want a reliable, satisfying pizza that tastes like it belongs in your routine. Honest food, fair prices, and zero fuss—sometimes that’s exactly what you’re craving.“

“Just ordered some yummy chicken bowl AMAZING! Hands down the best food I’ve had in a while!“

“Pizza is really good and both appetizers we shared were delicious, enough for 6 people.

Why I wasnt a big fan of this place:
1. My white wine wasnt very chilled and my friend’s paloma cocktail wasnt a hit.
2. And before it has been 1.5 hours even they just brought the check to the table which is kind of a mood killer for me.
3. When I asked to get black pepper for the pizzas, one waiter said we dont have it…. then a few minutes later it was brought in a little dish - how do you not have peppper in a pizza restaurant?“

“YUM - AAAYY - ZING!!

Words are insufficient to describe my excitement for Mario’s!!!

I’ll start with THIN CRUST - Classic Neapolitan pizza, ITALIAN style. Then FRESH FRESH FRESH ingredients make all the difference. I look forward to it, whenever I can make it, usually for lunch on Friday, the only week day they’re open at 12:00 noon. Awesome vibe that’s 100% local local local. Small place, mostly take out, but you can seat 3-4 people at the window counter, which I love. Old school marble counter, with comfy padded bar stools. You have to know it’s here as the location is a tad off the beaten path of prime visibility. Which ‘proves’ one of my philosophies ‘ great location, often mehh food, not so great location - the food must be amazing. So many amazing points …. One of which is the ACTUAL MARIO! Punctuating the super local CHEF OWNED cafe. He’s here all the time, super nice guy, a joy to chat with … and he truly loves making incredible pizza!!“

“Genuinely awe-struck by the size of that Super Beef. Next time I'll order it light sauce because this swimming pool trend is insane, but the beef was outstanding, the peppered sauce had a great bite. Staff was awesome and cordial. Dining room is... Hey it has chairs and tables. Fine for me.“

“Best place,great food.Highly recommend 🥰🥰🥰🥰“

“My favorites include deep dish pizza, chicken salad sub, roast beef sub, and spinach pie.“

“Family had dinner at Stoked in Cohasset last weekend….what a great meal! Pizzas were SO delicious, as were the Greek and Caesar salads. House wines were really good. Children loved their meals too. Our server was terrific, fun and attentive. An overall perfect experience…casual and delicious!! It was a little quiet when we went, but it was early. Can’t imagine this local gem will be quiet very often! We’ll all be back ! Nana from Hingham“

“Small hole in the wall but Fire pizza!“

“Everytime we are in the area, Pino's is our go to. Even if we go out to another restaurant, we get a Pino's Pizza to take home. The best pizza around.“

“The best pizza in Boston!“

“I came here, buzzing, after a show at the Sinclair tonight and they were open Monday late night so I got 3 slices of goodness, except...it was greatness...the mushroom & onion slices are so primo, munchies heaven, and the whole team is on point. Really great pizzas here with lots of skill added...“

“This restaurant is what the definition of a hidden gem is. The food is fresh, delicious, exactly what you look for in a great slice of pizza. They have many options, including burgers and subs, which all are made fresh to order as well. The prices are also reasonable, but what makes it stand out more are the specials they have which make the meals 10x more affordable for a solid
meal. It’s truly wonderful to see a place that actually cares about the people for once. But then the service stands out most to me, the people are the kindest, always accommodating, never rushing me to finish my meal, and making sure I feel welcomed and acknowledged at all times. They treat everyone as a community, which I think should happen more often. Everyone is welcome there and they make sure of it. I definitely recommend coming here, you will fall in love with it!“

“Great pizza and staff. Chef worked her buns off. A great sign.“

“Independently-owned neighborhood joint. Incredibly warm, welcoming, friendly owner. I love that it’s right across the street from the library. Can’t beat $3 for a flavorful cheese slice, delectable crust! Eggplant parm’s great too. Always hits the spot! 😊“

“My experience today was amazing - Nicole was so helpful with ordering and our friends received a delicious hot meal with more than enough for a second meal. Thank you all for taking such good care of our request!“

“the food was fresh outstanding! You must try it“

“I guess we would be considered regulars. The food is exceptional and it is matched by the service we receive.
Jason was a server last night and he was friendly attentive and patient since one of our group members did not make it.
Rick has put together a team that is cohesive, efficient and friendly.
Thank you for the total dining experience!“

“The best pizza and sandwich’s around delicious 😋 best customer service when you have an issue with door dash thank so much harry for lunch 🥰“

“What an amazing place. In these times when we are still not comfortable dining indoors this place rocks. The chef behind these dishes knows a thing or two about bringing beer garden food to a totally new level. Thank you chef and staff in front of the house.“

“We placed a big order for my son’s first birthday party this past weekend and we were so happy with both the food and great service. We called the night before because we weren’t sure if we had ordered enough and the owner answered the phone and was happy and quick to assist us. We already loved the food, but it’s nice knowing that the owner and the staff care so much about what they do and their customers. We will happily continue to order food from here!“

“First time in Nee England and my buddy joined a bowling league. So I told him lets go and I’ll just chill at the bar. This place is awesome! Great flatbread, great beer and great service! If I’m ever up this way again I’m for sure making a stop here.“

“Lived in NYC for many years and became a pizza snob. My wife and I searched for good pizza in Boston for the better part of a year and became addicted to this place. Sauce is delicious and flavorful. Crispy crust, tasty pepperoni. Just an awesome pizza. Bravo.“

“Food and service are excellent!“

“My 1st experience was great/ friendly and delicious! I’ll be back.“

“The food is great! Definitely try the corn pizza. However don't bother calling ahead or asking for the wait time. We called ahead and still had to wait 60 minutes. It isn't really their fault, a table that was finished with their food sat and chatted for 50 minutes.“

“First time going there and the toasted ravioli, pizza and Nomna’s meatballs were very good. Highly recommend 🍕“

“Great pizza and fantastic service. Taylor is super nice and made us feel welcome, being so far from home 🙂“

“Was looking for a new pizza place to try, Nella’s is great! Generous with the toppings. They don’t skimp. Solid undercarriage and perfect proportions of sauce and cheese. Delicious. Must try!“

“Great food and great staff.“

“It was very yummy. The kids were happy. The staff was excellent.“

“Melt in your mouth delicious roast beef sandwich!!“

“Had such a great experience at Papa Gino’s in Stoneham! My mom and I ordered a large cheese pizza and a small breadstick, and everything came out fresh, hot, and delicious. What really made the visit stand out though was the service. Anthony was absolutely amazing. He was friendly, attentive, and went out of his way to make sure everything was perfect. It’s rare to come across service like that these days. Definitely coming back again soon!“

“Fabulous pizza !! Thank you“

“Great Cafe, got turkey sub, had lunch with my Aunt Rachel. Food was made Fast .“

“Delicious authentic food, very friendly staff. Def worth it!“

“The pizza was great! The kids asked to come back the next time we’re in the area. They were impressed with the size of each slice! - Franchesca - Rochester, NY“

“Best pizza in Waltham Crew was efficient and friendly Love papa ginos“

“Family had dinner at Stoked in Cohasset last weekend….what a great meal! Pizzas were SO delicious, as were the Greek and Caesar salads. House wines were really good. Children loved their meals too. Our server was terrific, fun and attentive. An overall perfect experience…casual and delicious!! It was a little quiet when we went, but it was early. Can’t imagine this local gem will be quiet very often! We’ll all be back ! Nana from Hingham“

“We were visiting from Florida and was told we had to go Regina’s pizza so we did. Well we were not satisfied. It’s was average. So we found Cal’s and gave it a try. It was literally the best pizza and wings and ice cream we’ve ever had! The people were so friendly and upbeat. The restaurant was so clean and very well managed. If I lived here this would definitely be my #1 go to restaurant. I give this a perfect 5 🤩🌟⭐️🌟⭐️🌟“

“I love the pizzas, of course! My favorite: a white Roman with fresh spinach and tomatoes. Yum!“

“So I want to start by saying Kim was by far the most patient sweetest person. Her customer service skills were amazing I couldn’t have been more satisfied. I’m not from the area so she was patient and explained some of the best options. She was an amazing help. Not only would I come back for the service but the pizza was also wonderful.“

“Very unassuming place! I was greeted with warm and smiley Italian chefs behind the counter the moment I stepped in. Ordered take out of half &half large pizza (buffalo chicken and canivora) for my husband and I to share. You know it’ll be good when your pizza is kneaded and baked by an Italian 🤤 will be back to try their pasta!!“

“I love this place!! I recommend a lot of people !! For me is the best place to have a good pizza, around Allston Brighton!!“