14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newburyport

“Great Pizza! I was in your shop on Saturday, 29 Oct. This is what I have been searching for. The pizza reminds me of what I used to get in the 1940's and 1950's at pizzerias and barrooms. Thin, with the cheese and tomato spread right up to the edges. Almost foldable but not stiff. The flavor is satisfying and peaceful with a cold drink. The staff was extremely polite and accommodated me with a spaghetti sauce that was not on the menu. Judging from the continuous phone calls and pick-up orders, a lot of people have already discovered you and share my taste . Keep doing the Good pizzas. What a taste! When you've ordered tastey pizza, you know it at the first bite.“

“Great Pizza, fresh , best in Newburyport“

“Went yesterday for the 1st time & WOW!! Best fried clams & scallops I have ever had!! I have to say they were "sweet" and out of this world! Friendly place & Mary was a great server!!“

“Just the best. I don’t want to insult him by calling him old or small, but him working the oven at 9:45 on a Tuesday, I don’t have enough respect to give. When you pick up your food he’s humble and kind. Makes me proud, there’s a right way in America, and that’s it.“

“Amazing pizza 🍕 Talked about this pizza for a year and a half Finally able to have a slice as delicious as I remember“

“Great old school atmosphere and pizza!“

“I have trouble enjoying pizza made anywhere else. This is my favorite pizza.“

“Such a consistent experience. Both pickup and delivery.“

“It was our first time at Oregano and it did not disappoint..the Lasagna pizza was to die for..we sat outside cause we had our two small pups with us..our waitress was attentive and really pleasant I wish I remembered her name..Great experience would definitely go back!We were there on 7/21/25 early afternoon..“

“Extraordinary! Restaurant Week menu in Nport is superior to any other places. My first time and I will be back for sure.“

“Best pizza in town, for thick crust. Always happy to go to this Dominos. The only reason for the 4 stars for atmosphere is that the store has great potential since it is located on a beautiful marshy pond. Wouldn't it be fun in the summer to have a small deck for eating out on that lovely spot.“

“Haven’t been here since I was a young kid almost 25 years ago and the pizza still taste the same exact as it did when I was a kid so good full of flavor definitely will be coming back“

“Awesome pizza it’s a must try“

“Excellent service and food. The sitting is a little tight, but I still enjoyed the meal. We were checked on regularly and our waitress was top notch. The close proximity of other customers lead to a more communal dining experience which can be enjoyable depending on who you are near.“