22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newton

“Great pizza and staff. Chef worked her buns off. A great sign.“

“Fantastic pizza!! The crust is crispy and tender like it should be. Cooked perfectly. The other non-pizza items are ALL great as well. Nice little bar area too serving great drinks.“

“O. M. G. DELICIOUS. Can’t get enough of their pizza!!“

“Was a Boston resident for 60 years , moved to central Mass 6 years ago , still cannot find a really good pizza like the ones from Boston but I can honestly say whenever I head back there I'm usually stopping to grab a pie before I head back home and and I've got a thermal insulated bag , it's still hot enough to eat without having to reheat in the oven , highly recommend you give it a try but everyone has their own preferences , hope you like it as much as I do“

“This is a nice local pizza place where the pizzas, though a little doughy and oily, hit the spot in the right way.Food (4/5):There is a large variety of pizzas, from which you can buy slices, or pies ranging from medium to large. I got a medium pie for a 20$ that I was able to eat over two meals myself (I got the clam pizza). The taste of the pizza was very good, but it was a bit oily for my tastes. Plus, the dough was a little chewy; I like to eat the crust, but it's a full mouth workout to eat. Although I think the 20$ price tag for a medium pie was a bit pricy for my tastes, it's definitely better than what you get at a chain.Service (5/5):The people who work there are very friendly and are rather quick in producing your order. Sometimes they strike a conversation while you eat or wait (only if you want to though)!Atmosphere (4/5):The vibe is of a local pizza joint, which I appreciate; it feels very local. However, there's not much seating around; only about 3 to 4 tables inside, 1-2 outside, and 2 hightops with no seats. Great if you're just picking up, but eating there might be a bit cramped.Overall, a great joint for some non-chain, local pizza!“

“Food was very well prepared and the food runners delivered it quickly. The waiter himself was a bit slow to visit but quick to run off, once with my unfinished beer glass. Didn't even have enough time to tell him I was not finished. Forgot our bread. Asked if we wanted parm cheese then forgot to bring. The open view kitchen is great. Only thing that bothered me from atmosphere was the acoustics. Difficult to hear people talk at the table.“

“Amazing pizza, perfect crust, and friendly service! My top choice for a pizza night.“

“The toasted Italian was great“

“I drive all the way to Newton from the North Shore to get this pizza! It’s a slice of heaven! The staff are very friendly and genuinely good people. Nick is the owner-so nice to chat with and Ashley is one of the workers who makes me feel like I am the Top costumer!The absolute BEST!10 out of 10“

“I grew up on this food since I was a little kid I would stop by and grab some slices or an Italian sub. It's family owned and operated and a staple in the community and was happy to see they survived covid. I would highly recommend you support this family owned business , great people!“

“Oak Hill Pizza was recommended by the front desk staff at the Residence Inn in Needham, Ma, and they were right on the money. We placed a fairly large order, four pies and sides, for an impromptu 2nd birthday party for our grandson. All of the food arrived at the time requested, piping hot, and absolutely delicious. The person who took our order over the phone was courteous and helpful. I should add that we're from Michigan, land of the one inch crust, where pizzas are often judged by how much they weigh. It was a delight to encounter an East Coast pizza with a thin, crispy crust, with the emphasis on quality toppings and great flavor, instead of enormous quantity. When we return to Boston, we'll be sure to order our pies from Oak Hill!“

“Cupcakes are the best! Great selections!“

“This location seems to have been revamped with a new staff, the pizza I got was exceptional. Previously this used to be the worst Domino's location I've ever been to, but they've really turned things around. Glad I gave this place a second chance“

“Five Stars all around! HOWEVER, the website is very difficult to read and manuever. Black text on a dark background made it very challenging to place an online order.“

“We came to this spot for a meeting. we heard about this restaurant from quite a few people. Well, it was very successful. we were warmly welcomed by the staff and we felt very good. The food was just great. We had a great time and we will visit this place again. we highly recommend this place.“

“We recently hired Sweet Tomatoes to cater our backyard wedding. From the moment we spoke with Hedy, we felt at ease. We knew we loved the food, but we were immediately sold on her. She was friendly, kind, and helpful. She made suggestions for the menu and was sensitive to our guests with allergies. She provided a menu that was mouth-watering. Our guests could not stop raving about the hors d’oeuvres and the pizza. Our guests with gluten, dairy, nut, and even tomato allergies were well taken care of.

Hedy thought of everything. She was easy to work with and thought of details that we had forgotten about and took care of them for us (getting enough ice, providing adorable ice buckets for our drinks).

Most importantly, Hedy and her INCREDIBLE staff made us feel so well-taken care of at our wedding. They were kind, friendly, attentive, and went the extra mile with the cleanup (they organized our porch for us, ok? Come on, who does that?!). The servers made sure we were fed, and at the end of the night, Hedy had carefully packed slices of each kind of pizza for us and left them in our freezer because she suspected we were too busy to try everything while we were mingling with our guests. So thoughtful.

I simply cannot recommend Hedy Jarras and her phenomenal Sweet Tomatoes staff enough to cater your next event. 12/10, 6 stars, 5 thumbs up, 100% rotten tomatoes review, A++.“

“The owner is authentically friendly . The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. Prices are affordable and food is good and portions are a good size. We come here allot , my husband and I. We get either a small or large cheese pizza. It’s consistent of good quality, we have been coming here for years. Below is a picture of a small cheese we shared . I hope you have an opportunity to enjoy this neighborhood pizza joint .
??

Parking: They have plenty of meter parking no worries.“

“From the moment we decided to have Pizza Market West Newton cater our Christmas party, we knew we made the right choice. This local, family-run business went above and beyond to ensure our event was nothing short of spectacular. The quality and taste of their food were incredible, leaving all our guests raving about the delicious pizzas and the variety of options available. Their attention to detail, prompt service, and warm hospitality added a personal touch that made our celebration even more special. It's not just the mouth-watering food that makes Pizza Market stand out; it's the passion and care they put into every order. We couldn't have asked for a better experience and are grateful to have such a gem in West Newton. Highly recommend to anyone looking to make their event memorable with fantastic food and service!“

“great pizza hot rolls and dipping oil. kid friendly excellent service“

“Otto just hosted an event for us and from start to finish they were professional. All the pizza’s were a hit but the most popular was the bacon, potato and chive. Yummy! My fav was their pepperoni! Highly recommend Otto if you’re looking for the best pizza!“

“Great pizza! Came here based on a recommendation and our family gives two thumbs up! Will definitely be returning often.“

“I recently brought some friends to MIDA Newton for the first time, and it was an unforgettable experience! Our server, Guillermo, was an absolute gem—friendly, knowledgeable, and enthusiastic as he walked us through the menu, sharing his favorite dishes and highlighting the evening’s specials. We ordered two pizzas, the Caesar salad, arancini, burrata, and for dessert, the chocolate gelato and raspberry sorbet, and every bite was absolutely delicious. The warm, inviting atmosphere of the Newton location was perfect, and we loved the open view of the spotless kitchen, which the staff kept pristine even at the end of a busy night. Everyone we encountered was delightful, and we couldn’t stop raving about the food, service, and overall experience. We can’t wait to return!“