23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newton

“Great pizza and staff. Chef worked her buns off. A great sign.“

“Fantastic pizza!! The crust is crispy and tender like it should be. Cooked perfectly. The other non-pizza items are ALL great as well. Nice little bar area too serving great drinks.“

“Frank Pepe's is my favorite local pizza restaurant. Their New Haven style pizza is a thin crispy crust with minimal toppings that's cooked in a coal oven.
It comes out hot and steaming and delicious.

Their tomato pie (only available in season) and their clam pie are unique classics.

My favorite is their pepperoni and cherry tomatoes. The pepperoni comes out crispy and lightly burnt and it's perfectly complemented by the spicy peppers.

It's great for kids and families, and it's a unique place for dates!“

“Fabulous pizza !! Thank you“

“This is a nice local pizza place where the pizzas, though a little doughy and oily, hit the spot in the right way.Food (4/5):There is a large variety of pizzas, from which you can buy slices, or pies ranging from medium to large. I got a medium pie for a 20$ that I was able to eat over two meals myself (I got the clam pizza). The taste of the pizza was very good, but it was a bit oily for my tastes. Plus, the dough was a little chewy; I like to eat the crust, but it's a full mouth workout to eat. Although I think the 20$ price tag for a medium pie was a bit pricy for my tastes, it's definitely better than what you get at a chain.Service (5/5):The people who work there are very friendly and are rather quick in producing your order. Sometimes they strike a conversation while you eat or wait (only if you want to though)!Atmosphere (4/5):The vibe is of a local pizza joint, which I appreciate; it feels very local. However, there's not much seating around; only about 3 to 4 tables inside, 1-2 outside, and 2 hightops with no seats. Great if you're just picking up, but eating there might be a bit cramped.Overall, a great joint for some non-chain, local pizza!“

“A classic spot for consistent, delicious Italian American dishes.

I went to Fiorella’s with my aunt and cousin, who had both been there many times. The food is great, pretty typical Italian American dishes with a few less common additions, and everything tasted fantastic. They also have a good wine menu, great cocktails, an impressive selection of mocktails.

Our server was amazing! Jamie went above and beyond and truly gave us some of the best service I’ve ever experienced. She was friendly, patient, knowledgeable, and understanding.

I will definitely come back!“

“I drive all the way to Newton from the North Shore to get this pizza! It’s a slice of heaven! The staff are very friendly and genuinely good people. Nick is the owner-so nice to chat with and Ashley is one of the workers who makes me feel like I am the Top costumer!The absolute BEST!10 out of 10“

“Amazing pizza, perfect crust, and friendly service! My top choice for a pizza night.“

“Super Dough Pizza Co catered our wedding and it was phenomenal! Ian was so helpful and a great communicator leading up to the event, service was excellent, and everyone raved about the food. I also want to especially shout out Ian for making our dairy free guests feel extra welcome with their own dairy free pizza and extra entree. Couldn't recommend more!“

“The toasted Italian was great“

“I grew up on this food since I was a little kid I would stop by and grab some slices or an Italian sub. It's family owned and operated and a staple in the community and was happy to see they survived covid. I would highly recommend you support this family owned business , great people!“

“Oak Hill Pizza was recommended by the front desk staff at the Residence Inn in Needham, Ma, and they were right on the money. We placed a fairly large order, four pies and sides, for an impromptu 2nd birthday party for our grandson. All of the food arrived at the time requested, piping hot, and absolutely delicious. The person who took our order over the phone was courteous and helpful. I should add that we're from Michigan, land of the one inch crust, where pizzas are often judged by how much they weigh. It was a delight to encounter an East Coast pizza with a thin, crispy crust, with the emphasis on quality toppings and great flavor, instead of enormous quantity. When we return to Boston, we'll be sure to order our pies from Oak Hill!“

“Five Stars all around! HOWEVER, the website is very difficult to read and manuever. Black text on a dark background made it very challenging to place an online order.“

“From the moment we decided to have Pizza Market West Newton cater our Christmas party, we knew we made the right choice. This local, family-run business went above and beyond to ensure our event was nothing short of spectacular. The quality and taste of their food were incredible, leaving all our guests raving about the delicious pizzas and the variety of options available. Their attention to detail, prompt service, and warm hospitality added a personal touch that made our celebration even more special. It's not just the mouth-watering food that makes Pizza Market stand out; it's the passion and care they put into every order. We couldn't have asked for a better experience and are grateful to have such a gem in West Newton. Highly recommend to anyone looking to make their event memorable with fantastic food and service!“

“We came to this spot for a meeting. we heard about this restaurant from quite a few people. Well, it was very successful. we were warmly welcomed by the staff and we felt very good. The food was just great. We had a great time and we will visit this place again. we highly recommend this place.“

“This location seems to have been revamped with a new staff, the pizza I got was exceptional. Previously this used to be the worst Domino's location I've ever been to, but they've really turned things around. Glad I gave this place a second chance“

“Cupcakes are the best! Great selections!“

“#SweetTomatoes 🍅 🍅 🍅 has been a favorite staple food in my family, and it is like #homesweethome!
I can always trust #SweetTomatoes to serve delicious and mouthwatering artisan pizza.
#SweetTomatoes scrumptious sauce perfectly complements their pizza toppings.
One of my favorites is mushroom, pepperoni, black olives, artichokes, and garlic pizza pie.
No one does pizza better!
Their service is efficient, and the atmosphere is a slice of Americana hometown neighborhood vibe.
#SweetTomatoes most definitely
epitomizes well-made and delectable pizza in #Boston.
#SweetTomatoes is my FAVORITE #pizza.
I highly recommend you make #SweetTomatoes your favorite pizza place, too!“

“Old school pizza place with the best subs. I'm very picky, however, the owner is absolutely wonderful. I come in with a certain amount of money that I have and he always makes the best food. It's worth a gamble. Try it. He's quick!“

“Otto just hosted an event for us and from start to finish they were professional. All the pizza’s were a hit but the most popular was the bacon, potato and chive. Yummy! My fav was their pepperoni! Highly recommend Otto if you’re looking for the best pizza!“

“Great pizza! Came here based on a recommendation and our family gives two thumbs up! Will definitely be returning often.“

“great pizza hot rolls and dipping oil. kid friendly excellent service“

“Mida is a great restaurant. Food is interesting and delicious. Team service is amazing. Atmosphere vibrant (a little noisy for me but rather have the energy than silence). Great for a date or special occasion or just for fun. A good addition to Newtonville.“