Restaurants near Tisbury

“Excellent food and service. One of my favorites on Marthas Vineyard.”

“the #9 chicken breast avocado and pesto sandwich was absolutely delicious, the only thing better was the amazing service from Natalie and her crew. definitely such a friendly and welcoming environment. wish I had more time so that I could try more.”

“Mocha Mott's is a wonderful coffee shop with friendly and interesting customers and staff. The coffee is as great as you will find anywhere in the world. The treats are delicious, the bagels are fresh and the soups are all made from scratch. The music is also very very good.”

“Best joint in town for pizza and subs!”

“Super thin crust pizza. Dough and all the ratios are just right.”

“My favorite spot for sandwiches and pastries on the island! I’ve been coming here for years, and both the service and food have been consistently excellent. The portions are generous, so I usually have leftovers for a second meal. The last thing I had was a linguiça sandwich with plantains — it was so good that I finally went out of my way to write a review :) They’re also very accommodating toward gluten sensitivity.”

“By far the best desserts on Martha's Vineyard! My family and I have been on Martha's Vineyard for a week now and I have gone to Sweet Bites every day lol Amazing coffee, great dessert treats and the cheese bread!!! don't get me started. YUM!! You have to try the Cheese Cake. It is by far the best I have ever had! I will be taking some back with me on the ferry!”

“seaweed salad, sushi, and sashimi delicious we eat here often never disappoints”

“It was delicious �, we loved the flavor choices !!! So yummy !”

“I’m a hater and I hate to admit when places live up to the hype. But The Black Dog certainly surpasses its reputation.

I got the Spicy Woofer and the reason I have no picture to attach is because I practically swallowed it whole. I’m forever adding slightly cooked spinach to my breakfast sandwiches. The bacon was perfectly crispy (I love when the fat is cooked out). The clam chowder was also great. The chocolate chip cookie? Gorgeous. Spectacular. Perfection.”

“The food was good overall. A bit smaller sizing to the pizzas than I am typically used too but they make up for it with the toppings. Everything tasted great, would definitely go back!”

“Water Street is one of the best places you can eat on the Cape! The food is beyond belief and the atmosphere is like having an upscale dinner at your best friends house. Absolutely perfect!”

“One of our favorite stops in Oak Bluffs. The food and coffee are amazing. We are obsessed with their egg and cheese sandwiches!”

“One of the best food experiences I’ve had.”

“Good coffee and Breakfast”

“The food, service and wine list”

“To DIE for! Fresh snd delicious! Super service and worth every penny…in one week visited twice!! Ohh lala! 💗”

“Service, food, wine and ambiance was great. Highly recommend mussels, baked cod and duck confee. Thank you for a wonderful dinner.”

“Everything…great service, atmosphere, food, and staff! A++”

“There is something uniquely special about this place. The food is incredible, healthy and consistently fresh and delicious. The menu has a wide variety of choices and all of them are fantastic. Do not hesitate to try this place if you haven't already. You will NOT be disappointed. To the owners: Thank you for offering the community a wide variety of healthy options that all taste great! You guys rock!!! Keep up the great work.”

“As a strict creature of habit, it took me a while to start visiting the “new place in vineyard haven” but I am very glad I did. I usually don’t write reviews, but Catboat Coffee is an amazing place to stop in VH. The location is super convenient and parking is never an issue. The staff is always kind, even with strange requests or questions. I have never eaten Lebanese food, thus it has taken me a long time to branch out and ask about new foods and then try them. Catboats staff always has given me good recommendations when I ask. I have now eaten nearly everything on the menu, and I cannot complain about anything. The food is delicious, healthy, and filling portions. For the quality and quantity, the prices are amazing. Their packaging is eco friendly and they give a discount if you bring your own cup, which is very appealing to me. Eco-conscious businesses deserve more light. I have tried things I never thought I would and haven’t regretted a second of it. The staff and hospitality is the nicest part of this establishment by far. I work nights and often come in the morning/midafternoon very tired and they’re always patient and kind with me when I’m a little slower than the morning rush. Catboat has an atmosphere where you feel like you’re with friends or family. The coffee is amazing and their specialty drinks are not only creative but delicious. To top it all off, you can accumulate points rewards which is always a plus. This place is amazing and a great addition to the Tisbury marketplace. Cannot wait to see what winter and next summer bring.”

“Five stars all the way! Had chicken & apple quesadilla. The thing was HUGE and so, so, so yummy! Definitely coming back. Support this crew. The town only lets them operate F - SN.”

“Nomans is one of our go to places for lunch when we are on the Vineyard!”

“Absolutely amazing food! We came back twice … ceviche unbelievable taste and value, fig and prosciutto pizza, apple crisp - super yummy. Brown sugar steak tips and braised lamb shank the next time - so wonderful we couldn’t order a pizza to take home as planned. Great place with lots of locals and bartenders that can make drinks not on the menu!”

“Breakfast sandwiches were epic. They were the best we have ever had. Huge sandwich with fresh scrambled eggs. Coffee was really good too! Hidden gem”

“When you find a gem, you face a choice: keep it secret or share it with the world, risking you may never get a table again. Romeo’s is the gem of the Falmouth culinary scene. The menu changes daily based on Chef Tommy’s inspirations and market finds. We started with arancini that felt like a comforting hug, followed by fried oysters that tasted like drinking the ocean, and eggplant fries so good they made us wonder: when did eggplant ever taste like this? Plate after plate, the flavors told the story of a chef who cooks with artistry and passion. A special touch: Chef Tommy’s mother, Barbara, warmly present in the restaurant, made the whole experience feel even more personal. TJ, our waiter, was fantastic — knowledgeable, attentive, and full of energy. This is tapas-style dining, so the two of us ordered six plates. Honestly, we wished we had invited another couple so we could have tried the entire menu. Next time, we will. Romeo’s is not just dinner — it’s a memory in the making.”

“Out running errands and came in for my first time at the recommendation of my client. Friendly customer service. Had a couple customers when I arrived but more came - overall a pretty comfy feel. Just finished a very tasty southern style beef birria burrito. Will return at a later date to try one of their yummy sounding smoothies/shakes and paninis.”

“Great atmosphere friendly welcoming staff and love all your all the seafood 🦞 hugs to fluffy dog that hangs on the porch take out this year was very good come here every year”

“The oysters were delicious…all local…and the presentation was fantastic! Definitely recommend if in Edgartown! We even took the shells (asked of course) because the were so pretty!”

“Best bevs! Ethan the bartender is heaps of fun!”