20 Best Italian Restaurants in Frederick

“Stopped after a day of soccer games. We ordered two pies to share with our party of 4 - Supreme Italiano and a Margeritha. Pies were huge!!! Freshly made in a wood fire oven. Great service and value!! Spacious indoor and outdoor seating!! Highly recommend!!!“

“First time there, the food was delicious. Best we've had in years. The arancini were crispy and hot with a delicious tomato sauce. I had shrimp arrabbiata. Fantastic. Andrea had the mushroom ravioli. That was an earthy, tasty treat pack with mushrooms. Love the cafe style. Will go back as often as we can.“

“I had an amazing experience at this restaurant ( I think my favorite restaurant ) yesterday . I had to change the time of my reservation while already at the restaurant due to late arrival of the others in my group. They graciously switched the reservation . Enrico was very helpful with a few other concerns I had about my group. The bartender was friendly and made an amazing drink while I waited for my company to arrive . Our waiter Marcello was wonderful and the food was melt in your mouth delicious ! They also have gluten free pasta and pizza dough in case someone in your group is gluten free. Can’t say enough about this restaurant that makes you feel like you are part of the family !“

“The real one.“

“This is a new restaurant that is still working out the kinks. There was some confusion at the host/hostess stand about who was being seated where. Service was decent for a new place but still it was a little slow. The food was quite good. One of us had Chicken Marsala which was very good but it didn't have a traditional marsala sauce. Whatever it was, it was tasty. The other had Veal Parm. It was also quite good but the pasta sauce had an unusual flavor that was slightly off-putting We would be happy to return and try some other dishes but for one factor: Fox News on the TV in the bar. Watch it at home if you like but don't make me watch it.“

“Our high school volleyball team banquet was held at Pistarro’s in the Amalfi room. Donna and the rest of the staff was amazing. They had the room set up beautifully and the food was great. Thank you for making it easy to celebrate our athletes!“

“The best foods!!! Happy time !“

“Always wonderful! We love coming here!“

“First time there this afternoon with my family and we left feeling wonderful because of how genuinely kind the guy working the front was. Pizza was great and so was the steak and cheese but honestly it just feels so good these days to be treated so nice like family.“

“IMHO every restaurant needs 3 to be rated 5 stars, Good food, good service and a good price. Olive Garden achieves all 3. Great service! Super friendly and accommodating staff, fantastic food at a great price. The Sausage and Peppers was amazing! So full of flavor and just the right amount of spice/heat. Sad we only experience this on the last day it will be on the menu. I hope they bring it back.“

“Jonathan from Toppings Pizza Company delivered our order promptly and provided excellent service. This was our first time ordering from here, and we’ll definitely be coming back for more. The pizza was absolutely delicious—fresh, flavorful, and exceeded our expectations!“

“I’ve never had a bad meal from this place. And the staff is so super friendly every time I go in. My favorite sandwich there is the blackened chicken sandwich, it is absolutely amazing. You don’t get that real thick chicken breast they actually either pound it or cut it in half so it’s much thinner and it’s so much nicer to eat that way and the flavor for the blackened chicken is incredible. Their pizza taste great and my coworker loves their salads. If you haven’t been you need to go they even do a lunch buffet Monday through Friday.“

“Excellent food with a fabulous staff.“

“Thank you Roz and staff for a lovely lunch on Sunday...“

“My all time favorite pizza has been Ledo. I love the crust, the sauce, the cheese… their toppings are always great. I’ve tried two different locations in Gaithersburg. This location in Frederick, is the best Ledo Pizza I’ve ever had. We like our pizza well done and they didn’t burn it. It has always been fresh and hot when we pick it up. Best Ledo Location Ever!“

“Delicious food ordered meat lovers pizza on my way to NY and dropped for a bit. Pizza was deliciously made and served by the staff. Will stop by again when I am globetrotting.“

“Good service, fabulous pizza and wings.“

“Best fish counter of any grocery store in the area. Very well organized, super clean, and very enticing displays. There is always a large whole fish, spectacular lobster tails, oysters or pikes of sea scallops, etc. couldn’t resist loading up on king salmon on the latest trip; it was delicious, pan fried with butter and rosemary. Staff is always very well informed about their products and helpful about cooking ideas.“

“Nice place I've been to two of them already two different locations the food is good people are very friendly the atmosphere is nice the only does a great job of hiring is staff and preparing the food my wife and I would definitely go back again and we have“

“Great selection - there's something for everyone in my household when everyone wants something different. Everything tastes great and they have exceptional customer service! Always pleased.“