10 Best Italian Restaurants in Hagerstown

“Dolce - Eastern European Restaurant & Pizza is a hidden gem that offers an exceptional dining experience. The restaurant is praised for its excellent food and outstanding service. The menu features a variety of delectable options, including the popular Chicken Carbonara and Shrimps with pasta and Alfredo Sauce. The pizza is also highly recommended, with customers raving about the great taste and quality. The restaurant's warm and welcoming atmosphere, along with the kind and attentive staff, create an enjoyable ambiance for diners. The house bread, cannoli, and tiramisu are also highlights, with the bread described as having a perfect crisp exterior and moist texture. Overall, Dolce - Eastern European Restaurant & Pizza is a must-try destination for those seeking a delightful and memorable dining experience.“

“Café Roma Ristorante is a wonderful addition to the neighborhood, offering yummy food and great service. Their luncheon specials are reasonably priced and include a soup or salad, with delicious soups and salads to choose from. This authentic Italian restaurant is also a great venue for events, providing exceptional service and care. The menu features fantastic dishes, including thin and delicious pizza and the best fried calamari in the area. The restaurant's team, led by the owner, goes above and beyond to ensure a smooth and memorable experience.“

“The Olive Garden Italian Restaurant offers a consistently enjoyable dining experience. Customers are immediately acknowledged by the friendly hostess and promptly seated. The restaurant maintains a clean and well-staffed environment, with attentive servers like Crystal and Alia providing excellent service. The menu features classic Italian dishes, such as Shrimp Scampi and the Tour of Italy, which are praised for their exceptional taste and quality. The pricing is reasonable, and the overall operation runs smoothly, with the manager taking great pride in the restaurant's success. This particular Olive Garden location is known to be one of the top-performing in the nation, and the positive reviews reflect the hard work and dedication of the entire staff.“

“Rocky's New York Pizza is a beloved restaurant that offers a 2 slice and drink special for $7. The pizza has a perfect slice size with a crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese. The sauce is not acidic, making it easy on the stomach. This restaurant successfully brings the New York City pizza parlor experience to its customers. Many visitors appreciate the fresh and delicious pizza, making it a go-to spot for lunch.“

“Castello's Pizzeria & Tex Mex is a great option for those seeking delicious and hot takeout meals. The menu offers a broad selection, from loaded fries and cheesesteaks to shrimp fra diavolo and unique taco pizza. The service is prompt, friendly, and accommodating to all tastes. The owner works tirelessly to provide fair prices and excellent food, making it an excellent choice for a local business to support.“

“Brothers Italian Restaurant offers a variety of dishes, including the popular 9.99 special featuring a half sub, fries, and a drink. The pizza steak is a customer favorite. The seating arrangement can be a bit unusual, but the outdoor seating is a nice option on pleasant days. The food quality is generally good, though some dishes may lack flavor. The staff, such as Robin, are described as attentive and friendly, and the Chicken Alfredo and Chicken Vodka Pasta are highly recommended.“

“El Castillo Pizzeria & Tex-Mex offers a large menu with a unique blend of Italian and Tex-Mex dishes. Visitors praise the huge portions, fast and friendly service, and a variety of options. The Sicilian pizza is highly recommended and memorable. While some find the food to be just okay, the service consistently stands out as prompt and welcoming. Popular items include loaded fries, wings, and loaded nachos. Despite occasional fluctuations in flavor, the overall experience is positive, making it a great spot for family dining and takeout.“

“Ledo Pizza is a restaurant that offers pizza and other food items. The pizza has been described as great and tasty. However, there have been issues with sandwich orders, so it may be best to stick with pizza when visiting. The restaurant is pricier than some alternatives, but still considered reasonably priced. The service is generally good and the restaurant is convenient for those living in the area. Ledo Pizza has ample parking and is a suitable option for watching sports events. However, it may not be the top choice for everyone, as some customers prefer other pizza places.“

“Kings New York Pizza offers a delightful dining experience, with its hot, cheesy pizzas and delectable desserts. The crust is perfectly browned, and the delivery service is excellent, with friendly drivers. While the pizza may not always be consistent, the restaurant is a popular choice for those seeking a taste of New York-style cuisine. Customers praise the generous portions and flavorful toppings, making it a go-to spot for both dine-in and delivery options.“

“Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria in Hagerstown offers a full menu beyond just pizza. The super Italian sub is highly recommended, packed with delicious fillings. While the food is excellent, some visitors noted the lacking customer service, mentioning impatience and difficulty in communication with staff.“