17 Best Italian Restaurants near Fayetteville

Giacomo's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
107 Mont Alto Rd, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

4 Meatballs Appetizer Platter
Crabby Fries with Cheese
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Muscles in Wine Sauce
Loaded Cheese Fries
Jack's Crabby Fries
Cheese Pizza Slice
Garlic Bread Stick
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Chicken Antipasto

“We get takeout at least a couple times a week- so I don’t think I have to say too much more than that ? we like to patronize local businesses, my husband loves their sandwiches, the staff are always very nice on the phone, never curt or rude. As long as they are here we will keep patronizing - very tasty “

4.7 Superb36 Reviews
Maria & Sal's Pizzaria Pizza • $
4550 Lincoln Way E, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Meatball Parmesan Sub
Hand Up French Fries
Onion Ring Basket
Cheese Steak Wrap
Cheese Steak Sub
Mozzarella Sticks
Boardwalk Fries
Pepperoni Pizza

“Insanely delicious pizza loaded with toppings. Never under or over cooked.Salads are made with ice burg lettuce, but always very fresh and loaded with toppings. Wings are awesome, fries not bad. Meat used for cheesesteaks is very tender and flavorful.Service is good, although we always get take-out. Food always hot and fresh.Prices are reasonable for the quality. Sub prices are a little high I think, considering there are lots of places to get subs in the area.Owners are extremely nice and appreciative of their customers.“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
The original Arturos II & Mexican Grill Italian • $$
10503 S Mountain Rd, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Mushrooms
Garlic Bread

“My husband and I get pizza from Arturo's on South Mountain on Friday's once in awhile. We LOVE the pizza, and always order ours with black olives and mushrooms. In addition to the pizza being delicious, Arturo and his staff are so friendly. They always take the time to talk and smile. It's a great place to go. Check it out.“

4.7 Superb13 Reviews
La Bella Italia Restaurant & Pizzería Italian • $
6418 Chambersburg Rd, Fayetteville

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Homemade Bread Available
Chicken Cheesesteak Sub
Stuffed Meat Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
Cheesesteak Hoagie
Chicken Wings
Boneless Wings
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheeseburger

“The food was ok. We had subs..... but they didn't listen to the order. It was all messed up. Stuff we said to add was not added at all. One was completely different. I didn't have anything but meat in it. Was cheese steak subs. The, when I got there It took the young guy 15 minutes before even asking me what I needed. And there was no one there but one other customer, and he was done.Kid kept checking his phone 4 times before i got taken care of.And I saw our order sitting on top of the one machine.Ordered here because Tommy's subs are on the small size.Well, I will just order Tommy's in Gettysburg for now on.Place used to be way way better than this.Disappointed ?“

3.6 Good79 Reviews
Rosalie's Grill Italian • $
1901 Scotland Ave, Chambersburg - 5.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Caesar Salad
Italian Sub
Salads

“Foods to try:-Three Weddings Italian Soup-Appetizer Platter (has an assortment of fried goodies)-Walnut Petso Meal (won't disappoint)-Ceasar Salad (Fresher than Julius himself)Great food, great waitress staff (excellent attitude), great everything, causing me to I tip 20%. {Which I only do when waitress/tor and restaurant truly earns it.} The food was so hot & fresh, and worth the money. The Italian restaurant besides Benny's that serves pesto pasta. But you're getting a lot more for your money here. They have the appetizer platter which in here in the image for two people, which is almost gone because it was so good. If you love Italian like I do, than this is the place.“

4.5 Superb59 Reviews
Mario's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
831 Wayne Ave, Chambersburg - 5.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Bruschetta
Crab Soup

“The reason I have high cholesterol JK ?'Tis a rarity to find petso, especially tortellini in PA. This place serves it for under $20 bucks. It's a win-win.The place has that ole Italian family-everyone-is-welcome-vibe. Great for kids and entertaining large groups, especially in the summertime.Minor Critiques: the soup could be better & the bread could be bigger to match the entree size.“

4.5 Superb46 Reviews
Pizza Man Pizza • $
201 N Seneca St, Shippensburg - 9.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheese Fries with Ranch
Chicken Cheese Steak
Cheese Steak Special
Super Cheese Steak
Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
Meat Lovers
Italian Sub
Onion Rings
Tiramisu

“We had a pepperoni and a vegetable pizza. They were both very good. I noticed the unique way of cooking the pizza they had. First oven was used to brown up the bottom of the pie, then the second oven was used to finish the top of the pizza. It made for a very delicious pizza pie when cooked that way ??!“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Jasmine & Angelo's Pizza Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
Coffey Ave, Chambersburg - 7.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheesesteak Wrap
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Bread
Chef Salad
Wings

“Easily one of the best pizza shops in the area! The food is fresh, tastes great, staff are friendly, and the restaurant is clean. Business offers the ability to eat in, take out, delivery, and even have a drive through window!! All orders are made fresh on the spot so there is a little bit of wait if you don't call your order in ahead of time. My most recent trip I ordered two slices of pizza and a drink. Pizza was cooked just how a like it - a little crunch to the crust, perfect amount of cheese, a sauce that has a little bit of tang, and slices that have almost zero "flop". This place has jumped to the top of my "go to" pizza place! Business offers multiple lunch specials so I would recommend checking them out for lunch.“

4.6 Superb20 Reviews
Caretti's Pizza and Ristorante Pizza • $
2625 Philadelphia Ave, Chambersburg - 6.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Wedding Soup
Meat Lovers Pizza
Breaded Mushrooms
Chocolate Cannoli
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Rolls
Bone-In Wings 10
Small Stromboli
Sicilian Pizza
Honey BBQ Wings

“Always enjoy going to Caretti's on Philadelphia Ave. in Chambersburg. The service is always good and the food is terrific. I had their half sub special with fries and a drink. Four of us ate for under $40, not too many times that happens anymore. A great place for pizzas or subs.“

4.4 Superb39 Reviews
Nacho's Pizza Pizza • $
5006 Buchanan Trail E, Waynesboro - 10.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

New York-Style Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza

“To go order of Salmon Salad was fantastic with sliced avocado and tomatoes. The only thing was they didn't include the plastic wear and napkins to eat the salad on the go. They have friendly staff who were apologetic. I will go again and eat there sometime.“

4.6 Superb16 Reviews
Caretti's Pizza and Italian restaurant Pizza • $
1710 Lincoln Way E, Chambersburg - 3.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Medium Pizza
Cheesesteak
Italian

“The main takeaway here needs to be food, and frankly it's where go for pizza and subs more than anywhere else in Chambersburg. They get hopping pretty regularly, and everyone behind the counter always looks up and says hello with positive energy and pure gratitude.UPDATE 3/21/24 - Went in for the first time in a while and they completely overhauled the inside. It's fantastic. Great job guys!“

4.2 Good65 Reviews
Pizza 'n Stuff Restaurante Pizza • $
85 W King St, Shippensburg - 9.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Cheesecake
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheeseburger Sub
Nachos Grande
Loaded Fries
Cheese Pizza
Briana Wrap
Italian Sub
Meat Pizza

“This restaurant has exquisite dishes for your palate, the entire menu is delicious, very good service, very friendly and very clean. I love the food here. I highly recommend it. I am sure it is one of the most delicious meals I have enjoyed in Chambersburg pencilvania. You will be surprised by everything you see. your palate can taste ?And the food is very cheap, quite economical and it's worth it, enjoy itYou too have an incredible experienceKid-friendliness: CompletelyWheelchair accessibility: Yeah“

4.1 Good34 Reviews
Pat & Carla's I Italian • $
600 Lincoln Way E, Chambersburg - 5.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tenders & Fries
Small Regulor Stromboli
Pat & Carla's Soup
Chicken Primavera
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Alfredo
Soup of the Day
French Fries
Cheese Pizza
Italian Sub

“Typically we come here frequently on Mondays. This time when we visited service was quick but the waiter was inexperienced or did not care about his job. We were given no napkins with our food. Overall they were a little busy but Napkins are something that all customers need. The food was excellent but the service was worse than expected and left much to be desired.“

4.1 Good55 Reviews
Pat & Carla's III Italian • $
920 S Main St, Chambersburg - 6.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

New York Style Pepperoni Pizza
Pat & Carla’S Alfredo Pasta
Meat Lovers Stromboli
Pasta with Meat Sauce
Meat Lovers Pizza
Wing Dings & Fries
French Fries
Deluxe Pizza
Onion Rings
Greek Salad

“I've gotten delivery from Pat and Carla's III many times and have always been pleased. The food arrives in a timely manner, is hot and fresh, portions are generous and each time, the delivery driver is polite. Keep up the great service!!“

4 Good48 Reviews
Ledo Pizza Pizza • $
1300 Lincoln Way E, Chambersburg - 4.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Black Olives and Pineapple Pizza
Lunch Deal - Meatball Sub Fries & Drink
Hawaiian Pizza
Cheesesteak
Ledo Sauce
Wings

“Visiting from North Carolina and had to stop for a cheesesteak and pizza. Stopped in 11/25 at 5pm and costumer service was fantastic. Friendly and quick. Pizza was great. And got the meadows cheesecake. Wonderful. Also met a guy who has been a regular since 1950s in Maryland and Pennsylvania. SO YOU KNOW ITS GOOD.“

3.9 Good53 Reviews
Italian Village Restaurant & Pizza Italian • $
5267 Philadelphia Ave, Chambersburg - 6.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Puttanesca
Lasagna
Pizza
Sauce
Fries
Wings

“Food is always delicious, their fries are the BEST!! I love the stuffed shells, Kelsi's Salad and their pepperoni & mushroom pizza. The homemade cock tail sauce is the best tasting we've ever had!! We've stopped multiple times for just the cocktail sauce to go lol! More on the pricey side compared to other pizza places in the area, but that doesn't stop us from coming back!!“

3.9 Good56 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
990 Norland Ave &, Walker Rd, Chambersburg - 4.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
All You Can Eat Salad and Spaghetti
Stuffed Shells with Shrimp Alfredo
Olive Garden Pasta E Fagioli
Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Chocolate Brownie Lasagna
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Crispy Chicken Fritta
Create Your Own Pasta
Salad and Breadsticks

“I absolutely love, Olive Garden! Salads and bread sticks are always great! Food is always good and I love my Chicken Alfredo! And the alcoholic drinks are delicious as well! It is clean, nice staff, and to me, if there is a wait, it is worth it!“

3.8 Good88 Reviews
Loading...

Taste More In Fayetteville

map Map