22 Best Italian Restaurants near New Oxford

Gallo Pizza & Italian Restaurant Italian • $
6415 York Rd, New Oxford

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Italian Wedding Soup
Cheeseburger Sub
Personal Pizza
Stuffed Shells
Onion Rings
House Salad
White Pizza
Baked Ziti

“We have ordered their pizza several times and it's always consistently delicious!!!! It's a very nice place to sit down and have dinner and the owners are very nice people. So happy we have this right around the corner from us!!!!“

4.5 Superb49 Reviews
Little Italy IV Pizza • $
27 Stoney Point Rd, New Oxford

Customers` Favorites

Two Large Cheese Pizzas Special
Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Stuffed Meat Pizza
Regular Stromboli
Jalapeno Poppers
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Zucchini
Steak Pizza

“Honestly, the best pizza I had in a long time! And these cheese frie...sooo good. My favorite, gooey gold.The lady taking our order was awesome. You order upfront, and pay before you go. She was awesome, gave us suggestions on our food. Got us a box before I even had a chance to ask. On top of all that, they were busy, but she still had time for us.Parking: There's two spots out front, but a whole lot out back“

4.5 Superb34 Reviews
Pizza Joe's Pizza • $$
6415 York Rd, New Oxford

“We have ordered their pizza several times and it's always consistently delicious!!!! It's a very nice place to sit down and have dinner and the owners are very nice people. So happy we have this right around the corner from us!!!!“

4.2 Good12 Reviews
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
105 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak Garden Special
Super Italian Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Cheeseburger
French Fries
Pizza Burger
Meatball Sub
Onion Rings

“Man I can't say enough wonderful things here about this pizza shop. Everytime I go in I forget to take pictures off the masterpieces on the secret menu the cook makes so that I can make everyone else jealous. So often I see couples who return weekly or more it warms my heart to know the local support a small business gets. Clearly they must do well by how many people the owners know by name!A Must Stop family owned restaurant.“

4.1 Good33 Reviews
La Bella Italia Restaurant Italian • $
445 N Queen St, Littlestown - 8.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Alfredo
Buffalo Wing
Pizza

“Delicious food! I recently ordered their new Roberto Pasta (pictured) it was so good. The sweet sausage and sauce were perfect! All their other food is always on point whether you choose one of their subs, pizza, or dinner options! Highly recommend.“

4.7 Superb65 Reviews
Olivia's Mediterranean • $$
3015 Baltimore Pike, Gettysburg - 8.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic and Herb Pork Chops
Stuffed Grape Leaves
Turkish Shish Kebab
Eggplant Parmigiana
Bruschetta Kalamata
French Onion Soup
Chicken Bellagio
Tuxedo Cheesecake
Bread and Hummus
Stuffed Peppers

“My husband and I travel from Chambersburg just to enjoy a terrific meal here several times a year. Whether it's the seared tuna, thick center-cut pork chops, authentic gyro or a burger, we have never been disappointed and always leave with a full and satisfied tummy ? They truly know how to make a hearty and very delicious soup or bisque... it's like a meal in-of-itself. They have awesome desserts, and their hummus is hands down the best I've ever had anywhere...my husband agrees, and usually, he hates the stuff ?“

4.6 Superb76 Reviews
Firepit Rotisserie & Grill Greek • $
1154 W Elm Ave, Hanover - 4.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Shawarma Bowl
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Three Skewer Combo
Classic Hummus
3 Skewer Combo
Beef Shawarma
Chicken Kabob
Classic Gyro
Cheese Pizza
Greek Salad

“This is a very nice place with amazing service. Our waiter, Craig, was attentive, polite, and friendly. The owner, Paula, greeted us and told us a little about this family run business. I had the chicken skewers, and they were delicious. My SIL had pizza and loved it. When we went in, there was a sign saying they were short-handed and to please be patient. I didn't think the wait for service or food was bad at all, so they were surely doing a good job of keeping up on things. I would recommend checking them out!“

4.5 Superb87 Reviews
Brother's Pizza Pizza • $
14 W Hanover St, Gettysburg - 5.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Cheese Pizza
Cheese Curds
White Pizza
Onion Rings
Pizza Slice
Cannoli
Wings
Sub

“I can not say enough how absolutely delicious the cheesesteak and Italian subs were that we bought today! The staff was friendly, the service was quick and the restaurant was clean and not run down. I didn't think to take pics because I anticipated it to be the same as every other sub shop. Stop in and give them a try!“

4.6 Superb31 Reviews
Rocco's Pizza Pizza • $
301 Main St, York Springs - 10.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Hoagiewith French Fries
Mushroom Personal Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Supreme Pizza

“Great community based local spot. We've been going here for 10 years. FOOD is ALWAYS GOOD! You name it: pizzas, subs, sandwiches, calzones, salads, strobolis, pastas, everything is fresh & tasty. Service is always top-notch. Staff are always friendly & welcoming. Atmosphere wise it's not a fancy place, more homey. Rocco's gives off a Cheers/"Everyone Knows Your Name" kind of vibe.“

4.5 Superb37 Reviews
Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
4 S 6th St, McSherrystown - 4.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak Sub
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
French Fries
Wings

“Love seeing a place that is well ran. Immediately get fast service and good food. Been coming here since I was little but now as an adult seem like it’s ran very well! Always a super nice girl up front and pizza is always made right. Never floppy and always has flavor. Tried a cheesesteak from here for the first time the other day. Was super impressed. Definitely keep this spot in ur mind if u want good pizza around hanover!“

4.5 Superb30 Reviews
Trattoria Pizza Pizza • $
220 E King St, Littlestown - 8.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Chesapeake
Cheeseburger Sub
Cheese Fries
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread
Shrimp Salad
Italian Food
French Fries
Crab Cakes

“The pizza here is excellent. The cheese steaks are better. And my favorite meal is the salmon with lump crab meat. If you like fish you gotta try it. It's so good. I gave 5 stars because this place deserves it. Now the pasta meals are hot or miss. Anything with noodle I personally believe. My mom and dad recently tried the pasta and didn't like it either. Lacks flavor. Their other meals are very good.“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
Vinny's Italian Market & Catering Caterers • $$
1 Center Square, Hanover - 5.8 miles

“Visited here yesterday and I fell in love with the whole place. The whole vibe is amazing. The food is reasonably priced and is really really good. Very friendly staff. Such a cute store. Definitely recommend visiting here. (I al currently eating my leftovers from yesterday lol. super yummy!!)“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
Come a Casa Italian • $
2131 Baltimore Pike, Hanover - 9.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken on Strawberry Spinach Salad
Philly Cheese Steak
Seafood Medley
Garlic Bread
Chef's Salad
Seafood Sub
Lasagna
Burrito

“Today was my first visit. My server was very friendly. The atmosphere was pleasant. I thought the cream of crab soup tasted great, perfect texture. My only complaint is I asked if the meatballs were homemade or bought frozen. I was told homemade. They were definitely a factory made meatball. I believe it was the language barrier that caused the confusion.I would come back again.“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
10 Wilson Ave, Hanover - 3.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Tie Mousse Cake Chocolate Cake Dark Chocolate Cheesecake and Creamy Custard with Icing
Chicken & Gnocchi a Creamy Soup Made with Roasted Chicken Italian Dumplings and Spinach
Chicken Parmigiana a Classic with Our Homemade Marinara and a Side of Spaghetti
Minestrone Fresh Vegetables Beans and Pasta in a Light Tomato Broth
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Stuffed Tortellini Chicken Alfredo
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Create Your Own Pasta
Spinach-Artichoke Dip
Eggplant Parmigiana

“I’ve gone here hundreds of time and never disappoints. The last time I was there I ordered tort Alfredo and it had mounds of cheese but was lacking the Alfredo sauce. I’m not sure how you exactly forget the sauce but not the cheese that’s melted on top. Only issue I’ve ever had tho, just happened to be a disappointing one. And I unfortunately ordered take out so there was nothing I could do“

4.1 Good99 Reviews
Brother's Pizza Pizza • $
1101 York St, Hanover - 6.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Meatball Hot Sub
Cheese Steak Sub
French Fries
Special Pizza
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings
Chef Salad
White Pizza

“So fast, so polite, and exactly the best pizza shops you can imagine. Mozzarella sticks, Cheesesteak subs, all you imagine the best would be, they make it just that way. Young staff is overly polite and high energy and fast! I recommend big tips because they are worth it! That's up to you, but you won't be disappointed. They've NEVER made a mistake on our family of 5s many, many orders! AAA+++Parking: Easy peasy!“

4 Good36 Reviews
Rocco's Pizza Pizza • $
500 W King St, East Berlin - 6.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breaded Mozzarella Sticks
French Fries
Cheese Pizza
Stromboli

“We are so glad we decided to call in a pizza order today, we have always wanted to try Rocco's and boy what we have been missing ! We ordered the Sicilian Special and it looked amazing being pulled out of the oven, it weighs a ton So ...... we just enjoyed a slice and let me say that it is AWESOME ! Crust had a crunch and the edges baked to perfection. The toppings were bountiful and full of flavor We Love It The ladies working were very friendly and welcoming, made me feel at home. We are looking forward to giving their Cheesesteaks a try, especially with homemade bread .... Thank You Always Support our Local Business“

4 Good39 Reviews
Giovanni's Pizza & Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
646 Blooming Grove Rd, Hanover - 8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Pizza by the Slice
Regular Stromboli
Hawaiian Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Fries
Cheese Pizza
Italian Sub
Pretzel Boli
Everything

“We’ve gotten food from Giovanni’s on Blooming Grove Road more times than I can remember. Our favorite is their simple cheese Sicilian which we sometimes add bacon to. They absolutely cover the pizza in bacon without going overboard. Their traditional round pizza is delicious as well as their stromboli, cheesesteak or cheeseburger subs, their onion rings motz sticks and cheese fries are amazing too! We’ve never once been disappointed with our meals. And I personally believe they have the best pizza sauce around. We always get extra to dip our onions rings and pizza crust into! The wait time is always consistent unless of course it’s a busier time of day. Staff is always very friendly over the phone and in person.Parking: There is plenty of parking and outside seating for the warmer months.“

4 Good53 Reviews
New Alfredo's Pizza II & Ristorante Pizza • $
435 W Eisenhower Dr, Hanover - 4.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan Sub
lg Pepperoni Pizza
Loved the Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Special Pizza
Italian Sub
French Fries
White Pizza
Alfredo

“I've enjoyed their lunch specials many times. I've had their pizza & their hot subs. All of it has been very tasty. Good food, fresh bread, & reasonable prices. My daughter just moved back to town & was with me this time. Now, she is also a fan.“

3.9 Good39 Reviews
Jerry & Sal’s Pizza Pizza • $
1155 Carlisle St, Hanover - 4.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Cheese Steak Salad
Antipasto Salad
Cheesesteak Sub
Pepperoni Bites
Sicilian Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Cheese Steak
Min Cannoli
White Pizza

“Not sure about the food because all I order is pizza. They make the best New York Pizza I've had in Central PA. Highly recommend for pizza. I cannot speak for their other entrees because I've never tried them. I did get a steak sub for a friend who said it was excellent.“

3.9 Good46 Reviews
Genova's To Go Pizza • $
1412 Baltimore St, Hanover - 8.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese and Bacon Fries
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Large Cheese Pizza
Meat Lover's Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
The Italian Sub
Cheese Steak
Stromboli
Pizza Sub

“Best pizza place in Hanover in terms of the basics: bread, cheese, pepperoni, seasoning. I don't get a lot of meat so I can't comment on the other toppings. Tomatoe basil is delicious too. Mozzarella sticks, wraps, all the subs from cheesesteak to turkey sub are delicious. Homemade bread for subs too. It is a little more expensive than other places in town, but you'll see why when you eat the food. Definitely an occasional go to for me.“

3.9 Good57 Reviews
Sal's Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
1234 Baltimore St, Hanover - 7.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Cheese & Green Pepper
Italian Cold Cut
Cheeseburger Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Stuffed Shells
Baked Ziti
Pizza Sub
Meatball
Special
Ravioli

“First time ever having Sals! Pizza was flavorful. Got a large Sicilian. Extremely doughy in the middle, opened up and could tell immediately cheese and Pepperonis weren't done. It's a large area, so I'm not surprised the middle was undercooked, but it was enough to where I had to throw it my oven and try and get that bottom toasted. Amazing flavor. I Will try and order again.“

3.8 Good41 Reviews
Divino Pizzeria Italian Eatery Pizza • $
612 Frederick St, Hanover - 5.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fingers
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Caesar Salad
Crab Pretzel
Crabby Fries
Onion Rings
French Fries
Cheese Pizza
Ham Calzone

“*update* we finally gave them a second chance today at lunch time. This was our first time here in the new building. It’s very nice inside. We got take out, it was done quickly and it was hot and delicious. So I updated it to a 5 star from a 4 star. They seem to really have stepped it up since entering their new building. The parking is Also nice. We will definitely be back ?Eating in the food is amazing, we’ve had many of their subs, their pizza tons of times, the mozzarella sticks, French fries, chicken tenders. All very good. Their make your own pizza is also great! I just would not recommend getting take out. Every time we get take out the food is very, very, very cold when we get it (at least in the evenings).“

3.6 Good97 Reviews
Loading...
map Map