34 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Oxford

“I love their tacos! I can’t make it more than a week or so without some.“

“Everything was excellent - prices are great and portions are large - very nice job!!!“

“We enjoyed a lovely lunch here after a busy day of shopping at the local antique shops. My wife and I enjoyed our Cheese Steaks, mine was a Cheese Steak Hoagie that was just great . Our waitress was wonderful as were the cooks here. They make their own bread!“

“we love out pizza joes, best pizza in grove city, good menu selection and have had their pizza for decades and it never disappoints.“

“Great food, friendly staff,clean atmosphere,and Joe, the owner, is such a nice guy. Haven't had any bad experiences and we have eaten their food often“

“Love this place Great Italian boat Friendly service“

“I was a little worried because I tried to order a pizza for lunch and although the page said open, I couldn’t order before 4:30. I placed an order for 5:15 and meanwhile, numerous local restaurants were closing due to weather. I watched my tracker and thought they might not be in but then suddenly, my pie was in the oven! Ready on time (slightly before) and the pie and parm bites are the freshest I think I ever had. Dough is light and airy and baked perfectly! First of many Dominos orders for this house! So glad to have them in New Oxford!“

“We recently discovered Oak, just a half mile from our home, and it’s truly a hidden gem in an area with limited dining options. From the moment we walked in, the experience was exceptional. Our bartender, Zach, was welcoming, knowledgeable, and offered fantastic recommendations—including the Steak and Eggs for brunch, which exceeded all expectations. The steak was cooked to perfection and paired beautifully with the eggs—a dish I had never tried before but will definitely be ordering again. My husband enjoyed the BLT Eggs Benedict, which was equally impressive. The thick-cut bacon, perfectly poached eggs, and flavorful hollandaise made for an unforgettable dish. The service throughout our visit was outstanding, and when asked for recommendations, Zach confidently told us that everything on the menu is great—and from what we tasted, we absolutely believe it. If we could give Oak a 10 out of 10, we would. For anyone in the area or just passing through, we highly recommend stopping by. Oak is a standout dining experience, and we’ll definitely be returning soon!“

“Had the chance to try this little gem yesterday and I was very impressed by the prompt service and quality of the food. The cheesesteak had great flavor and the Old World Style pizza was incredible. Sergio and his team are producing top notch eats with quality ingredients served hot and fresh. I will be returning to south Hanover frequently for one reason. Stop in and check them out.“

“i moved to dillsburg recently , and ordered from rocco 3 times now ! every time the pizza was delicious , customer service was great and fast. this last time i ordered 7 pizzas on a saturday and they had them all done in 30 min from time i called! will deff be my one and only pizza shop when ordering from home ! love seeing small company pizza shop doing great! as a small company my self i love to support the same in my areas“

“Highly Recommend! owners are so kind & friendly! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS food! Best pizza/sub shop in Hanover Area.“

“My husband and I order from here at least once a week. They have great food, they are convenient to our location and they meet all our exceptions when it comes to take out orders. My favorite by far is their Philly Cheese Steak Pizza! Oh my gosh...it is so good. If you like the sub you will love the pizza.“

“We've never been disappointed with a single dish, and I'm pretty sure we've tried about everything. Everything is fresh and delicious. So glad to have Blessing in town!“

“W.York and East Berlin very clean restaurant and also great service. Food is always ready in the time they tell you when you order by phone for pick up. Pleasant to sit and eat in also. Nice customer service always friendly. Delicious food, personally I’ve never been disappointed in any of the food I’ve ordered.“

“Outstanding everything!!!“

“Real GOOD pizza made by real NICE people. True to the "New York style" our large meatlover was delicious and filling!!“

“Please open a location closer to Maryland. We will always make a stop to Giovanni's! Even if we are an hour and a half away. The pizza is phenomenal and eggplant fries are amazing. The best thing they have is their staff though. Everyone is so kind and welcoming. Excited for the new menu options. We will be back for the new burgers!“

“Highly Recommend! owners are so kind & friendly! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS food! Best pizza/sub shop in Hanover Area.“

“this was the best pizza I've had in years. will definitely be back. The service was great“

“this was the best pizza I've had in years. will definitely be back. The service was great“

“Usually get thin crust Because they charge xtra for there original pan Which is ridiculous Do not like the taste of the hand tossed“

“Sorry to everyone in Hanover who claims to have the best cheesecake in town. But Genovas in south has taken that title with avengance!!! There bread is to die for the meat second to none!!! Everybody should give this place a try you won't be disappointed.“

“Pizza is great. Subs are great. Everything is great. No lie, try them!! We usually go weekly. Love their food!“

“The best cheese stks. And the freshest rolls. Not to mention the sheriff in town loves it too“

“Had my order taken by Faiza, Friendly, polite and got my order the way I wanted it. I am a truck driver and they are accommodating. Brought my food to me while in the door loading for an extended period of time. Service is just what they gave along with HOT food!! Thank you Faiza and Pizza “

“I was recently at La Bella Italia on two separate occasions. Antonia was our server both times. She was very helpful and courteous and delivered remarkably good customer service. The entire atmosphere was great and the food was fantastic. I highly recommend this experience Karen and Harry“

“We went in on Monday the Manger sam was amazing she checked on tables making sure everyone was ok. The employees were great and keeping the bar full. The service was great and place was clean.“

“We stopped in this weekend for our first visit, and it definitely won’t be our last! The atmosphere was great, the service was friendly and attentive, and the Lobster Pescatore was absolutely incredible! Please make that a regular rotating menu item — it was fantastic!“

“So this is a mixed review. I am older and a "wing eating pro". Divino's wings are among the best in the area. Ample size, well seasoned, cooked just right. Their "cheesesteaks, not so much. I received a very excellent roll with very little "hamburger" no discernible cheese and little onion flakes. It is almost as if it was sent out without the preparation process being finished. It certainly was not noticed by the server. I should have sent it bask. My bad! 2 STARS...The servers, except for that, were very professional and cordial. I also tried the Stromboli on a different visit - and it was excellent. I asked for extra mozzarella - and I GOT it. Ok, let's boost this rating up a notch and 1/2. Try it for your self and let us know. Bon Appetite ! (PS - I detest giving bad reviews)“

“First time in for myself and my son. The staff were so very nice and friendly! The pizza was fantastic!! And I'm very very picky about my pizza. This is DEFINITELY a monthly outing for me and my son. LOVED IT, LOVED IT, LOVED IT.
On another note, even the other customers coming in were amazing and helped with the door.“

“The only Pizza Hut you can eat inside at in the area. I haven’t had Pizza Hut in 15 years and that first bite of hot, cheesy, crispy, Pan pizza goodness transported me back to my childhood. A lot changes in life but thank goodness you can still eat inside Pizza Hut and get a tasty Pan pizza.“

“Best food in Hanover! The ownership is amazing as well!“

“Awesome great atmosphere,“

“I ordered through the app, upon delivery a error was made and I didn’t get my full
Order. I contacted the store , and spoke to Trevor ! Trevor apologized for the mistake and remade my missing pizza and had it delivered to me in a timely fashion! I love this papa John’s and their employees ! The delivery drivers are always very nice as well! And Thank you so much Trevor for the help!“