38 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Oxford

“I love their tacos! I can’t make it more than a week or so without some.“

“Everything was excellent - prices are great and portions are large - very nice job!!!“

“Great food, friendly staff,clean atmosphere,and Joe, the owner, is such a nice guy. Haven't had any bad experiences and we have eaten their food often“

“Five stars is not enough. From the fresh baked bread for the subs to the hand tossed pizza dough, Pizza Garden has been a stable in New Oxford for decades. Never a bad experience here. Food is fresh and delicious and the service is always top notch. Highly recommend.

Wheelchair accessibility: Parking lot level entrance with ADA approved slope ramp into the dinning area. Additionally they have a drive up window for order pickup.“

“We have Gallo’s regularly for dine in / take out. This time we bought a pizza, garlic bread, and a chicken nugget kids meal. All of the food was excellent. The pizza dough is my favorite, clearly made in house. I would definitely recommend if you need some good inexpensive food for the family.“

“Had the best Italian boat here yesterday! Will definitely be back.“

“I was a little worried because I tried to order a pizza for lunch and although the page said open, I couldn’t order before 4:30. I placed an order for 5:15 and meanwhile, numerous local restaurants were closing due to weather. I watched my tracker and thought they might not be in but then suddenly, my pie was in the oven! Ready on time (slightly before) and the pie and parm bites are the freshest I think I ever had. Dough is light and airy and baked perfectly! First of many Dominos orders for this house! So glad to have them in New Oxford!“

“Food was absolutely phenomenal tonight!“

“My family loves everything we have ordered. Pizzas,subs and tonight ziti and stuffed shells. Excellent food generous servings . Thank you so much Sergio and Denise. Delicious!❤️“

“I just found this little shop. The staff is very friendly, and the food is delicious. My family of four enjoyed chicken tenders, fried chicken, and cheeseburger subs. The fries were crisp, and the tenders were perfectly golden brown. We will be eating here again.“

“We've never been disappointed with a single dish, and I'm pretty sure we've tried about everything. Everything is fresh and delicious. So glad to have Blessing in town!“

“Outstanding everything!!!“

“Don’t confuse this location as interchangeable with the east Berlin. The one in York springs is superior. The staff are friendlier, the facilities are cleaner and the food is better. The only complaint I have is they wish they had fountain soda. York springs is still worth the drive.“

“fanatic food for a great price! the subs are on homemade bread and puts subway to shame for the same price.“

“We were visiting PA from Long Island and stopped here. Being from NY I'm always comparing other states pizza. lol Brothers Pizza is AWESOME.“

“really great pizza slices lots of topping to choose from great setting picnic tables outside friendly staff“

“My husband and I order from here at least once a week. They have great food, they are convenient to our location and they meet all our exceptions when it comes to take out orders. My favorite by far is their Philly Cheese Steak Pizza! Oh my gosh...it is so good. If you like the sub you will love the pizza.“

“Highly Recommend! owners are so kind & friendly! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS food! Best pizza/sub shop in Hanover Area.“

“W.York and East Berlin very clean restaurant and also great service. Food is always ready in the time they tell you when you order by phone for pick up. Pleasant to sit and eat in also. Nice customer service always friendly. Delicious food, personally I’ve never been disappointed in any of the food I’ve ordered.“

“Pizza is great. Subs are great. Everything is great. No lie, try them!! We usually go weekly. Love their food!“

“Had my order taken by Faiza, Friendly, polite and got my order the way I wanted it. I am a truck driver and they are accommodating. Brought my food to me while in the door loading for an extended period of time. Service is just what they gave along with HOT food!! Thank you Faiza and Pizza “

“this was the best pizza I've had in years. will definitely be back. The service was great“

“The best cheese stks. And the freshest rolls. Not to mention the sheriff in town loves it too“

“this was the best pizza I've had in years. will definitely be back. The service was great“

“We went in on Monday the Manger sam was amazing she checked on tables making sure everyone was ok. The employees were great and keeping the bar full. The service was great and place was clean.“

“La Bella Italia is our go to for subs, pizzas, Stromboli, salads and more! Food is so fresh and delicious! Staff are so kind and attentive! We highly recommend to our friends and neighbors when asked where we go for local delicious food!“

“First time in for myself and my son. The staff were so very nice and friendly! The pizza was fantastic!! And I'm very very picky about my pizza. This is DEFINITELY a monthly outing for me and my son. LOVED IT, LOVED IT, LOVED IT.
On another note, even the other customers coming in were amazing and helped with the door.“

“The pizza was a nice thin slice. I wish I was in town long enough to go again. The huge, very helpful staff is very knowledgeable about the menu and friendly. The photos seem like it has grown out of a family spot into a thriving business. There is a lot of sports stuff including the little league teams they sponsor. if I live here this would be my pizza joint.

Parking: 40 spots all around the building“

“I used to eat at pizza hut a lot as a kid, but as I got older and moved away, the dine in pizza huts seemed to dry up and shrivel away. On a whim, my wife and I drove to the nearest dine in pizza hut to see if the magic was still there. After an hour drive, this pizza hut met every one of my nostaliga-filled expectations.

The food was absolutely as good as I remembered; I got a pan pepperoni pizza and it was every bit as good as it was when I was a kid. Besides that, the decor looks straight out of the 2010's. That's not to say anything looked old or grungy - it absolutely didn't! - rather, it felt like a well-maintained love letter to pizza hut's heyday, which is exactly what I wanted. Lastly, the service was wonderful. Our server was attentive and kind, which is all you can ask for!

I know that this is probably just a pizza hut for most folks, but, man, they really hit it out of the park for me.“

“Highly recommend! We went for a date night and it was AMAZING seafood Mac and cheese, lasagna, garlic bread, stuffed tater tots and side salads. The seafood Mac and cheese had big shrimp in it. yes tails were still on but common practice of a decent restaurant. the crab in the dish was great! good portion and flavor. lasagna was in a big dish that was made individually not just a cut piece. sauce was great with plenty of cheese. stuffed tater tots are delicious!!! must try!!! The service was top notch! Vivi was attentive, professional, knowledgeable of the menu and other day specials. I witnessed another group not be very pleasant with her and she was very professional and elegant about it. especially when it was the entire encounter for them. She is an asset to have! Definitely recommend. Top notch food and service. I WILL be back and will be back with others! great job!“

“Great food, great staff, great service. Happy this place is in our town.“

“This is our go-to cheap eats family convenience choice. The pizza is always on time, consistent, and the staff is pleasant. Thanks for making dinner easier for us!“

“We were told the delivery would be in 55 minutes & they got it to us in less than 30 minutes ? we love Papa Johns!! Always have always will. Food is always Awesome!! & I don't have to sit in a restaurant to eat it. I know a lot of places deliver now but if you want great pizza fast go with Papa Johns.“

“Their smoking area sucks though.“

“Ordered online for delivery it literally took 20 minutes. Food was fresh and hot. Pan pizza, honey bbq wings cinnamon twist n coke of course. No complaints. I’m a happy customer oh and they delivered to my truck at Utz Factory? driver was on point found my truck fast. Thanks guys! A+.“

“Second time coming in today and everything was incredible! Our server Bryn was incredible! Oriental Chicken Salad, Buffalo Chicken tacos were delicious. We also got the Boardwalk Syle Fried Dough for dessert! Yummy! Can't wait to come back to try more.“

“It was okay, we liked the one at Hershey better for some reason. We ordered the cauliflower bites, pretzel, a sandwich, the steak salad, a burger for the kid and wings. Everything was okay, I expected the bread to be toasted based on the picture but it was plain. We never got the wings so they ended up taking them off the bill...“