13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Gettysburg

“My husband and I came in for 2 Sicilian slices(well done and crispy, like we like it), mozzarella sticks and 2 drinks. We are locals to Gettysburg. WOW! Our food was delish, portion size was more than we expected. We will be back, our new Gettysburg go-to pizza!!!“

“Plenty of parking. Outside tables. Family friendly atmosphere.“

“Excellent! Best place for pizza in Gettysburg, hands down. We also really love that they have the most amazing choices for those on a gluten free diet in our family. Fantastic! (Only one small suggestion: Please consider providing real plates, even if they're just cheap plastic for dine in guests. Or if you can't, better quality paper plates would be, well - better! Any pizza of substance - and yours certainly is - needs a heftier plate than the thin ones currently provided).
Highly recommend this place! 👌“

“if you like Italian food this is the place! Will return as often as possible.“

“Highly Recommend! owners are so kind & friendly! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS food! Best pizza/sub shop in Hanover Area.“

“Really good pizza for as busy as they were. The chicken wings were a little over done and the place is noisy due to the crowd screaming into their phones. Just walk in order your food find a seat and wait til they call your number. If ya want good pizza, give this place a try.“

“Best food in Gettysburg! We ate here on a Friday evening whilst on vacation. More than pleasantly surprised! Looking forward to eating here again when we're in town.“

“I just picked up a pizza at Blessing. I ordered through DoorDash for pick up. App said 18-25 minutes. Within 5 minutes of placing the order, I got the notification that it was ready 🤔. Picked up my pizza and it was cold and undercooked. I love Blessing pizza. Hoping it was just an off night 🤷🏼‍♀️“

“The pizza crust and sauce are out of this world!“

“My bartender was Bailee she was very friendly and courteous. She kept my drinks flowing and continued to check in with me.“

“We had a party of 16, accomodated within 45 minutes on a saturday night. We had several pizzas, lasagna, gluten free entrees, chicken franchaise, and some seafood pasta options. Our server was incredibly personable and made sure that our orders were perfect. Everything was delicious and served hot and at the same time!“

“my first time ordering from them and even though the food was good I wasn't too impressed. I accidentally typed in the wrong phone number so I had no idea that I did that and nobody text me that my food was on his way and it was taking a while so I checked and my food was sitting outside on my porch cold because nobody bother to knock on my door to tell me that it was here. And when I opened up my food my garlic dipping sauce that I ordered was not included in my package. Again good food just no dipping sauce nobody told me that my food was sitting outside“

“I just want to start by saying London was so helpful and kind regarding my delivery order. I was worried about it not being picked up and she took it upon herself to call me back to tell me it would be on its way momentarily. She didn’t have to do that, but she didn’t want me to keep needing to call and worrying if it was picked up or not. She was extremely kind from the moment she picked up the phone. I don’t even know how the food is yet as I’m waiting for it now- but this alone deserved its own review. Keep being an amazing human 💜 thank you London!“