29 Best Pizza Restaurants in Hagerstown

“Rocky's New York Pizza is a beloved restaurant that offers a 2 slice and drink special for $7. The pizza has a perfect slice size with a crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese. The sauce is not acidic, making it easy on the stomach. This restaurant successfully brings the New York City pizza parlor experience to its customers. Many visitors appreciate the fresh and delicious pizza, making it a go-to spot for lunch.“

“Little Alex's Pizzeria is a local favorite for delicious pizza and tasty cheese curds. The crust on their pizzas is praised for its perfect balance of chewiness and crunchiness. Customers have also been impressed by the helpful and speedy service provided by the staff. The restaurant's owner has demonstrated a genuine care for their loyal customers, responding respectfully to any concerns. In addition to their renowned pizza, Little Alex's offers other tempting menu items. The Cuban panini is a popular choice, featuring high-quality ham and fresh, hand-cut fries. The cheesesteak is also a hit, with customers appreciating the well-balanced filling of steak, cheese, and onions. Diners have commented on the use of fresh, quality ingredients that leave them feeling satisfied rather than sluggish. Overall, Little Alex's Pizzeria has earned a reputation for its delectable food, attentive service, and commitment to customer satisfaction, making it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.“

“Dino's Pizza in Hagerstown is known for being the best in town, with delicious cheese steak, hot ham and cheese, and perfectly cooked fries. Customers love the subs with the perfect amount of mayo and crispy onion rings. The small pizza place offers fantastic pizzas with a crispy crust and no greasy mess. Parking is available on the side of the building, across from the gas station. Dino's Pizza is a must-visit for those craving top-notch pizza and subs in Hagerstown.“

“American Pie Pizzeria is a restaurant that offers delicious and affordable meals. Its pizza, known for its thick crust and generous amount of cheese, is a standout, with especially fresh mushrooms. The calzone is oversized and flavorful. The restaurant is clean and has a friendly owner. The portions are large, and the parmesan cheese is used generously. The wings are also a popular choice and are highly recommended. Overall, it is a great dining option for those who appreciate delicious food in a comfortable environment.“

“Rocky's New York Pizza offers a great dining experience. Food is served hot and timely, and staff is accommodating to dietary restrictions, including gluten-free options. Parking is convenient, with a lot in front and nearby areas. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible and kid-friendly. Despite needing some updating, the pizza is excellent, reminiscent of classic New York-style pies. Additional menu items, such as cheesesteaks and salads, are also highly praised. Whether you dine in or carry out, Rocky's provides a great atmosphere for a quick meal or evening dinner.“

“La Trattoria Pizzeria is a family-friendly restaurant with limited vegetarian options. They offer a variety of dishes, including Margherita Pizza and Caesar salad. Customers praise the delicious food but mention extra charges for additional items. The staff is known for being friendly and efficient, making it a pleasant dining experience.“

“DoughDaddies is a must-visit for pizza lovers. With amazing customer service and generous portions, this spot also offers delicious wings, including the fiery death wing sauce. Affordable prices and a friendly atmosphere make it a top choice for those looking for a tasty and enjoyable dining experience.“

“Pretzel and Pizza Creations offers a cozy atmosphere with friendly service. The Angry Bee pizza and crab dip were highlights, though some dishes could use more seasoning. The pretzel appetizer and omnivore pizza were described as absolutely delicious by one reviewer. Fresh fries, amazing crab dip, and a surprising pretzel bread left another customer impressed. The milkshake was also a hit. With quick kitchen staff and fresh ingredients, this restaurant is worth a visit, especially if passing through Hagerstown.“

“Brothers Pizza Hagerstown is a reliable choice for a delicious meal. The restaurant consistently serves hot and fresh food, with a good service to match. While some meals, like their pizzas, are always on point, others, like their wings, could benefit from a bit more flavor and crispiness. The option to purchase taco shells separately is a nice touch. Overall, Brothers Pizza Hagerstown is a great spot for families and those looking for a quick grab-and-go meal, with accurate delivery and friendly service.“

“Dolce - Eastern European Restaurant & Pizza is a hidden gem that offers an exceptional dining experience. The restaurant is praised for its excellent food and outstanding service. The menu features a variety of delectable options, including the popular Chicken Carbonara and Shrimps with pasta and Alfredo Sauce. The pizza is also highly recommended, with customers raving about the great taste and quality. The restaurant's warm and welcoming atmosphere, along with the kind and attentive staff, create an enjoyable ambiance for diners. The house bread, cannoli, and tiramisu are also highlights, with the bread described as having a perfect crisp exterior and moist texture. Overall, Dolce - Eastern European Restaurant & Pizza is a must-try destination for those seeking a delightful and memorable dining experience.“

“Café Roma Ristorante is a wonderful addition to the neighborhood, offering yummy food and great service. Their luncheon specials are reasonably priced and include a soup or salad, with delicious soups and salads to choose from. This authentic Italian restaurant is also a great venue for events, providing exceptional service and care. The menu features fantastic dishes, including thin and delicious pizza and the best fried calamari in the area. The restaurant's team, led by the owner, goes above and beyond to ensure a smooth and memorable experience.“

“Castello's Pizzeria & Tex Mex is a great option for those seeking delicious and hot takeout meals. The menu offers a broad selection, from loaded fries and cheesesteaks to shrimp fra diavolo and unique taco pizza. The service is prompt, friendly, and accommodating to all tastes. The owner works tirelessly to provide fair prices and excellent food, making it an excellent choice for a local business to support.“

“Brothers Pizza City Park is a highly recommended spot for delicious food and excellent service. The staff is friendly and delivers to reasonable prices. The menu features homemade pastas, dishes, and combos like chicken and fries, chicken fajitas, and steak and cheese, all made to perfection.“

“Ledo Pizza is a restaurant that offers pizza and other food items. The pizza has been described as great and tasty. However, there have been issues with sandwich orders, so it may be best to stick with pizza when visiting. The restaurant is pricier than some alternatives, but still considered reasonably priced. The service is generally good and the restaurant is convenient for those living in the area. Ledo Pizza has ample parking and is a suitable option for watching sports events. However, it may not be the top choice for everyone, as some customers prefer other pizza places.“

“Domino's Pizza offers great service and excellent pizza. Customers appreciate the friendly and hardworking staff, like Delaney and Rhett, who deliver on time with a smile. The cheesy bread is a must-try, and the overall experience is fantastic. Affordable prices and quick delivery make it a go-to choice for a satisfying meal.“

“Kings New York Pizza offers a delightful dining experience, with its hot, cheesy pizzas and delectable desserts. The crust is perfectly browned, and the delivery service is excellent, with friendly drivers. While the pizza may not always be consistent, the restaurant is a popular choice for those seeking a taste of New York-style cuisine. Customers praise the generous portions and flavorful toppings, making it a go-to spot for both dine-in and delivery options.“

“Domino's Pizza is a reliable restaurant that offers superior service, as evidenced by the excellent delivery driver who went above and beyond to provide customers with extra items. The restaurant is accommodating to customers with dietary restrictions and allergies, making adjustments to suit individual needs. They also have wheelchair accessibility and are kid-friendly. However, there have been instances where customers have experienced poor customer service, including a driver who forgot to provide the correct change.“

“Café del Sol - Hagerstown East is a restaurant that offers a unique menu with various food options. A customer chose to dine here after a Google search for a Cuban sandwich, which was satisfying but did not compare to those they had in Florida. The truffle fries were not distinguished from the regular fries, with only a light coating of truffle oil and tiny truffle flakes. The Bao Sliders were a highlight of the meal, with perfectly marinated and tender pork inside a soft and light Bao bun. The fresh cucumber and veggies complemented the dish well. The Caesar Salad Wrap had tender and grilled chicken but lacked Caesar dressing. The Cuban Panini had high-quality ham, tender and juicy pulled pork, and pickles that were just right, but it was lacking seasoning and mustard. The service was good, but the server was also the bartender, causing a delay in getting the check due to the busy bar. The atmosphere of the restaurant was nice, and the place was clean and well-decorated. The restaurant has a parking lot with free on-site parking and other parking lots nearby. The menu has a variety of delicious-sounding food, and it is recommended to try the Bao Sliders. The food was not the best the customers had ever had, but it was still fantastic. The potential is there, and they plan to return and try other things on the menu. The sweet tea was above average, and the Berry Agua Fresca was alright, although a little tart. The pizza that another customer's wife ordered was delicious. However, the crab panini was mediocre, and the customer was unsure if it even had crab in it. Overall, the restaurant offers a unique menu with various food options, and it is worth trying out.“

“Pizza Hut has undergone changes, but its delicious food remains the same. The restaurant no longer offers dine-in service, but excels at delivery and take-out. While the breadsticks were a bit disappointing due to a lack of sauce and bland taste, the parking is ample and conveniently located near South High School. The restaurant is kid-friendly, with highchairs and booster seats available, and hosts parties and events.“

“Okay, I normally like Domino's. Ordered three pizza's, two with extra mushrooms. They put on very few mushrooms and they were all piled in the center on both pizzas, I had them make the pizzas again. On the 2nd round, they put an excellent number of mushrooms all over, it was beautiful. However, they forgot the steak on one pizza, so I had to wait again while they made another pizza. 45 minutes from start to finish and I finally got the correct pizzas. The only reason I didn't give them a 2 or 3 stars is because they were incredibly apologetic.“

“Cafe Del Sol offers great food and a peaceful atmosphere, complete with 80's and classic rock music. The menu features a variety of dishes, and the staff is friendly and accommodating, even catering to food allergies. The restaurant's decor is nicely done, and the prices are reasonable, making it a great value for a nice lunch. Try their cheesesteak sandwich and pizza for a delicious meal.“

“Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria in Hagerstown offers a full menu beyond just pizza. The super Italian sub is highly recommended, packed with delicious fillings. While the food is excellent, some visitors noted the lacking customer service, mentioning impatience and difficulty in communication with staff.“

“BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse is a great spot for a meal or sports watch. The staff is always friendly and efficient, serving food quickly and with a smile. The menu offers a variety of options, including salads, soups, burgers, and wings. The dry rub wings and Tetanka BBQ are popular choices, and the draft beers, including BJ's own brews like Jeremiah Red and Tetanka Stout, are a nice bonus. Pizookies are a sweet treat to end the meal. Overall, BJ's is a great choice for a timely and satisfying lunch or dinner.“

“Brother's Pizza Express is a restaurant that never disappoints. Located conveniently nearby, it has become a frequent dining spot for many. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, with the pizza being a standout. Other popular choices include the taco bowl, steak quesadillas, and steak & cheese. The crab fries are a must-try, as they are loaded with real crab, melted cheese, and remain crispy even after a 20-minute drive. The staff is friendly, making it a great place for takeout. The pizza, steak & cheese, and crab fries are highly recommended.“

“El Castillo Pizzeria & Tex-Mex offers a large menu with a unique blend of Italian and Tex-Mex dishes. Visitors praise the huge portions, fast and friendly service, and a variety of options. The Sicilian pizza is highly recommended and memorable. While some find the food to be just okay, the service consistently stands out as prompt and welcoming. Popular items include loaded fries, wings, and loaded nachos. Despite occasional fluctuations in flavor, the overall experience is positive, making it a great spot for family dining and takeout.“

“Papa John's Pizza offers a pleasant dining experience with timely delivery and friendly service. The delivery team, including drivers like Patrick, are courteous and punctual. The food is consistently hot and delicious, fully cooked to perfection. While occasional issues may arise with third-party delivery services, the restaurant's staff, such as Shane and the manager, are responsive and work to resolve the situation promptly. Overall, Papa John's Pizza is a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.“

“Brothers Italian Restaurant offers a variety of dishes, including the popular 9.99 special featuring a half sub, fries, and a drink. The pizza steak is a customer favorite. The seating arrangement can be a bit unusual, but the outdoor seating is a nice option on pleasant days. The food quality is generally good, though some dishes may lack flavor. The staff, such as Robin, are described as attentive and friendly, and the Chicken Alfredo and Chicken Vodka Pasta are highly recommended.“

“Pizza Hut is a popular pizzeria known for its excellent pizza, refreshing customer service, and great deals. The restaurant offers a range of options, including the Veggie Lovers pizza, which is well-liked by customers. While the prices are relatively great, the quality of the food is not sacrificed. The Pizza Hut app is easy to use and the rewards program is a nice addition. However, some customers have experienced issues with the preparation of certain menu items, such as the cheesy breadsticks not being cut properly. Overall, Pizza Hut is a reliable and budget-friendly choice for those seeking a satisfying pizza experience.“