18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shepherdstown

“The pizza and service was great. My 6 yr old is done said thatvis the only place to get pizza from for now on. Will definitely be back again.“

“It is a good place to eat and great service. they are sometimes busy and get overrun by orders but other than that it is a great place“

“Great food, fast friendly service. Highly recommended.“

“Sooo gooood. Like the old days!! Best pizza around!!“

“Anthony’s Pizza is truly a standout — the kind of place you walk into once and immediately know you’ll be coming back. The food is consistently delicious, with fresh ingredients, amazing flavor, and that perfect, comforting pizza taste you can only get from a place that really cares.

Sanah and Dan, the owners, are absolutely wonderful. Their warmth, kindness, and genuine love for their restaurant shine through in everything they do. They make you feel like part of the family the moment you walk in the door, and their passion for great food and great service is clear in every visit.

If you’re in the area, Anthony’s Pizza is a must. Amazing owners, amazing food, and a place that’s truly built with heart.“

“Awesome pizza & service“

“Love this place the people who work there are so kind even the delivery people their food is excellent. The best pizza is around the best steak and cheese. I’ve had up here restaurant on the small side, but I think they do a large delivery and a large pick up service the food is excellent“

“We had an absolutely amazing experience on Homecoming Saturday! The entire Potomac Ridge team went above and beyond to ensure everything ran smoothly despite the busy crowd. The kitchen was impressive—getting fresh, delicious food out in less than 10 minutes with smiles all around. I complimented someone from the kitchen, smiling they proudly responded, ‘thank you, breaking records!’ I loved that! As the sun set, the fire pits were lit, and an employee started selling s’mores kits, personally chatting with each group at the fire pits. The heaters under the pavilion were a cozy touch. It all wrapped up with a friendly send-off from the door holder! Such a delightful experience.“

“Just had our favorite Pizza City pizza for lunch...as always, delicious! Today we added the dessert pizza...OMG... it was awesome! Chocolate chip cookie on their amazing crust drizzled with caramel...you gotta try it! The staff at Two Crows Antique Mall is hooked!“

“Holly cow, i know I have given a good review before. But now, after two and a half years, I want to say you guys have such a consistency, komam, your bacon, cheeseburgers sub rocks, the flavor, size very tasty sandwich. Your chicken alfredo with broccoli is the best. I've had. It is fun.
Your pizzas are true napolitana pizza, and everyone behind the line go above and beyond. Thank you so much, the entire staff behind the line with customer service and also preparing your food, great attitudes. I don't have enough words to express how happy I am to have you guys. Ask my selected pizzeria.“

“My family and I called in an order to support our nephew who goes to Wright Denney! They were super busy, yet I could tell they were trying their hardest to keep things under control, despite their crazy circumstances, we got our pizza in about 30 minutes. Staff was super kind, and were trying their hardest to get things out as quick as possible. We love ledos! Their Family football deal is great for my family of 4.“

“Finally made it over to this very tasty place for a Sunday afternoon away from the farm to run some errands too. The amount of variety of food is wonderful. Salad, pasta, veggies like green beans and squash as well as the fresh pizza and the dessert apple pizza as well as pudding on the bar too. We enjoyed the fresh very tasty pizza. I loved the squash/zucchini mixture on the buffet it was a nice option in the middle of January. Definitely will be back! For $12.49 per person it was definitely worth the money. Thank you for posting on FB as this is how I discovered this tasty place.“

“The Fig and Pig Pizza is mind blowing good! The beers are unique and tasty. Definitely worth checking out!“

“I’ve been eating here since I was 16 years old over 40 years now and it is even more special to me now since this is the last place I had lunch with my son before he passed away. I live in Florida now for over 15 years but every time I come home to visit family. I always come here sit in the same booth that Jeff and I sat at for that last lunch over 4 years ago now.“

“im not sure the gentleman's. name that delivered pur pizza today, but he is by far the nicest delivery driver ive met. we had a horrible experience with one delivery driver and this man made up for that today. he deserves a raise and to be recognized for sure. im Sorry I didnt get his name, but our delivery was on S. George Street if that helps. thank you to him!!“

“The only one I'll go to. Always clean, friendly, and efficient“

“My wife and I traveled here, with our autistic son, on February 19 2026. The food was delicious and the owner and his “boss” were terrific hosts. I had the bbq pork sandwich with fries. She had the club sandwich and fries. The first thing I want to say is that for train car food this experience beats Amtrak 10000%!! Ok enough with the jokes, the pork sandwich was well beyond amazing. I’m not much of a bbq sauce person (so if you are beware) but I wanted to give it a try. I thought other than a burger this would be the better choice of a manly dish between the two. The bbq was cooked perfectly and was so tender and flavorful. The sauce didn’t have the typical bbq sauce(baby rays) flavor. I could tell or atleast I think it was homemade. It was the perfect topping to the pork sandwich. My wife’s review on her dish: —delicious, good portions, bacon was crispy, 10 out of 10. Service was fast and friendly. The best part of the food in my opinion was the seasoned house fries. They did not look like typical McDonald’s fries. They were dark brown and slightly(but perfectly) soggy. The seasoning was a flavor of which I had never tasted. It was out of this world. I mentioned my autistic son at the very beginning because he requires lots of accommodations. He never eats normal food. So I have to prepare his food at home. He ate his portion of food at the table and then he asked for ice cream. When the waitress came to the table she said she had vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. It took my son about 10 times changing his mind before he settled on strawberry 🍓 He loved it and it was a healthy portion. Thanks for this enjoyable experience. Having a child with special needs makes it hard to enjoy some of life’s simple things. Something about being in a train car restaurant had him calmer than normal. We are already planning our return trip during the busy season. I can’t say enough about this place but I’m going end it here. ;)“