19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Martinsburg

“We recently tried Angelo's Brick Oven Pizza for the first time since it's been in the mall. In our opinion, it's hands down the best pizza in the area!! We have stopped in every Friday since for Pizza night! I love that they have curbside because I typically pick up with my toddler and do not have to get her out of the car to pick it up. Thanks for having great service, staff and pizza!!!“

“Amazing amazing food!!! Ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza and sampler appetizer and it was so good! The pizza is phenomenal, delivery was speedy on a Tuesday early afternoon. Thanks pizza shop! I’m excited I tried this place. You definitely have new regular customers :)“

“You can definitely tell a family runs this. I love seeing that dynamic when I get my food. For Kings I’m usually at the Shepherdstown but the Martinsburg Kings never disappoints in their food. Might be just a little better than the Shepherdstown one.“

“Sooo gooood. Like the old days!! Best pizza around!!“

“Friendly staff. Morning of 9/25 my family came in and were helped by Kamari. He was super personable and helped my niece who has an allergy. We were a large party and most of us hadn’t had Blaze before. He explained the menu and answered everyone’s question.“

“Please start going with doordash. I just can't justify the fees on your delivery site anymore. Was going to order a pizza and wings ($32) and between site fees and the driver tip (20% always) it was going to add an additional $18 to my order... I'm sry but I cancelled it....“

“Having lived in Westchester County, New York, for several years, I like to think I’ve developed a pretty good sense of what authentic New York pizza should look and taste like. And let me tell you, Giovanni’s NY Pizza did not disappoint!

What an unexpected gem to discover in the middle of West Virginia! The restaurant is run by a former Marine, and we were personally greeted by the owner, who prepared a fresh pizza right in front of us, complete with a delicious assortment of toppings.

Oh my, was it good! So good, in fact, that we ended up ordering two more pies to take home!

Everything about this pizza reminded me of what I loved about New York pizza. The crust had that perfect crunch on the outside while remaining soft and airy on the inside, with a wonderful hint of olive oil. The tomato sauce was rich, beautifully seasoned, and bursting with flavor, complemented by delicious mozzarella melted to perfection. Every bite was a reminder of how good a properly made New York pizza can be.

And here’s what impressed me even more. When we got home, we reheated the extra pizzas slowly in the oven, taking our time to bring them back to temperature. They hadn’t lost a thing! The crust was still wonderful, the flavors just as vibrant, and the cheese just as delicious. They tasted almost every bit as good as they had fresh out of Giovanni’s oven. Now that’s the sign of a pizza made right!

And the value? Almost unbelievable! Less than ten dollars for two generously sized slices, made fresh to order, and a drink. These days, finding that combination of quality, authenticity, and affordability is a rarity.

Giovanni’s is proof that you don’t have to be in New York to enjoy a fantastic New York-style pizza. Great food, genuine hospitality, and exceptional value. We came in expecting a quick bite and left with two extra pizzas and a new favorite spot.

Absolutely worth a visit, and we’ll definitely be back!“

“Great food and friendly service. Restaurant was very clean. Kris our server was on top of everything. We will definitely go back“

“Great tasting food and service!“

“Finally made it over to this very tasty place for a Sunday afternoon away from the farm to run some errands too. The amount of variety of food is wonderful. Salad, pasta, veggies like green beans and squash as well as the fresh pizza and the dessert apple pizza as well as pudding on the bar too. We enjoyed the fresh very tasty pizza. I loved the squash/zucchini mixture on the buffet it was a nice option in the middle of January. Definitely will be back! For $12.49 per person it was definitely worth the money. Thank you for posting on FB as this is how I discovered this tasty place.“

“This was the best Ledo’s we’ve been to! The food was fresh and delicious. We ordered online and included a slice of carrot cake; when we got there they were out but they kindly gave us a couple cupcakes to make up for it. The staff were so friendly and nice, we’ll be back soon!“

“Amazing bar down to earth. The bar staff are very personal and attentive never letting your glass go empty and DEFINITELY best prices for drinks in town!

They also have pool tables and a patio to go outside and drink. Being a foodie person, their food is amazing with appetizers and entrees. Ps tacos are amazing.

Clean, Safe, amazing vibes and music. Definitely going to be my place of choice to go to.“

“Friendly people, excellent pizza“

“I would recommend but tonight the guy in a jeep liberty was very disrespectful he pulled into my driveway like he owned it. I have dogs in an invisible fence. my pizza you could tell was slid. do better with driver!“

“Robin Robinson (sorry if I misspelt your name) gave amazing service! After a 12-hour drive, I ordered Domino’s and got the cinnamon bread bites. She first came up apologizing about forgetting an icing, and even though I told her not to worry, she went out of her way to come back the icing cups! She didn’t have to, but she did—and it really made my night!!

Meanwhile, I’ve had the opposite experience with Papa John’s in the area, where I had the wrong pizza delivered and raw dough and wasn’t resolved nearly as well. The difference in customer service really stands out. Thank you again, Robin!“

“The food always comes out great at this location. Even though they were completely swamped with customers and their AC unit was down everyone was putting their all in to get the orders out the door. All the employees were very helpful and nice with great work ethic despite the heat. I would give ten stars for just the employees alone but the tasty pizza is a bonus. Thanks for serving food to our community guys!“

“The delivery is awesome my food arrived fresh & hot in a good time for ordered place to my door. The food is great this is one Papa Johns, that definitely nailed it with there pizza, wing's & cheesey jalapeno bacon bread slices. This is my go to Pizza place & already have family members that can on wait & get food from here. Keep up what y'all are doing 👍“

“Got my pizza in a timely fashion and was shocked at how good my pizza looked. I had to take a photo to show how good of a job these guys did. The older gentleman at the front was super nice and i will be back again to order from them. I must say that this pizza blows other local pizza places out of the water in terms of not only price but also in quality. Definitely give them a visit.

⭐️ The pizza i ordered: Crazy crust with Italian sausage, jalapeños, and pineapple. ⭐️“