5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Berkeley Springs

“Mythical Pizza is a restaurant that offers delicious and high-quality food, with excellent service. Their gluten-free crusted pie is a must-try, and their chocolate chip cookies are highly recommended for dessert. The Nightmare on Braxie Street pizza and Parmesan chicken bites are popular menu items. While the chicken bites could use more marinara sauce, the sauce is worth purchasing extra. The restaurant has a unique theme and is a great place to dine in or take out. The owner is friendly and attentive, making it a perfect spot for a return visit.“

“Dexter's Laburgertory offers delicious food in a casual, small-town atmosphere. Their subs, like The Fresh Prince, feature fresh ingredients and unique flavors like bacon pepper jam. Burgers are also a highlight, with friendly service to match. This family-friendly spot even offers a "kids happy hour" and is known for its cleanliness and ease of access. Overall, Dexter's Laburgertory is a great spot for a tasty, laid-back meal.“

“Tony's Butcher Block is a place loved by many for its awesome sandwiches, pepperoni rolls, pizza, ribs, and salads. They also offer delicious chocolate cake and cannolis. Customers enjoy the pit beef sandwiches, hand-cut fries, deer bologna, burgers, and fries. The staff is friendly, helpful, and goes above and beyond to provide great service.“

“Fox's Pizza Den is a local pizza restaurant that has undergone some positive changes under new ownership. The delivery service has been expanded, reaching customers even 10 miles away. Customers praise the delicious subs, such as the Buffalo Chicken and Beef, Cheddar and Bacon. While the Jalapeño Poppers were not well-received, the pizza, including the cheese and Hawaiian varieties, has been consistently impressive.“

“Mountainside Restaurant offers good food, with a standout pizza and fresh salad. The place appeared a bit dirty with dust and dirt. Despite some issues with pricing for extras, the customer service was excellent. Known for quick carryout, the restaurant provides fresh and great food options, making it a welcoming spot for families with kids.“