Pizza Restaurants near Berkeley Springs

Mythical Pizza Pizza • $
1855 Valley Rd Suite #200, Berkeley Springs

Customers` Favorites

E T the Extra-Toppings Supreme Craft Pizza
Black Olives Mushrooms Pizza
Nightmare on Braxie Street
The Mothman Strikes Back
Mothman's Pepperoni Roll
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Fresh Mozzarella
Honey Sriracha
Chopped Garlic
Garlic Oil

“We rent a cabin in the area and wanted a quick and easy dinner on our first night. This place hit the spot! We had three different kinds of pizza. They were their special deep dish, cheese and pep with regular crust, and stuffed crust with cheese, pep, and sausage! They were all great. It was easy to order online, for a text message, and they were ready to be picked up.“

4.5 Superb114 Reviews
Dexter's Laburgertory Pizza • $
398 S Washington St Unit B, Berkeley Springs

Customers` Favorites

Open Faced Roast Beef
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Tenders
Onion Rings

“This place is amazing!! The food was incredible, the people who worked there were soooo nice and friendly, the atmosphere was great, the inside is so beautiful and there is the newer touchscreen version of "jukebox" u can pay n play songs n they have a pool table.... It was absolutely awesome. We also bought some ice cream, I got 1 scoop in a waffle cone n let me tell u 1 scoop is all u need! She packed the waffle cone full, I literally ate half n had 2 ask for a cup 2 put it in 2 save for after eating.... My husband got a milkshake which was pretty good size, he didn't even finish his. The burger was huge n soooo good!! The amount of food u get is huge in my opinion and the prices r well worth the amount u get plus the taste! Hands down loved it!!! Will definitely b back that's for sure!!!“

4.3 Superb102 Reviews
Tony's Butcher Block Pizza • $$
2880 Valley Rd, Berkeley Springs

“Awesome pit beef sandwiches and perfectly spiced hot handcut fries! It would be nice if something "greener" could be used instead of single use plastic containers, like wrapping the sandwiches in butcher paper or cardboard to go boxes.“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews
Fox's Pizza Den Pizza • $
1644 Valley Rd, Berkeley Springs

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Bread Sticks
Wedge Fries
Meat Pizza
Big Daddy

“I haven’t ordered from Foxes in quite some time. Only because when I did my pizza was always burnt. I ordered a cheese and Hawaiian pizza tonight and they both looked and tasted amazing! I was impressed! I definitely will be ordering from them again!“

3.1 Average48 Reviews
Mountainside Restaurant Italian • $
91 Sugar Hollow Rd, Berkeley Springs

“Food was good. My wife loved the pizza. Her salad was fresh. But place seemed a bit dirty. Lotta dust and dirt on window ledges by table and under tables. A lot of construction work going on in the area that could explain the dust. Our server was great.“

2.3 Poor21 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
224 W Main St, Hancock

Customers` Favorites

Oven-Baked Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie
Backyard BBQ Chicken Pizza
Thin Crust 3 Topping Pizza
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Hawaiian Chicken Pizza
Breaded Boneless Wings
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Cinnabon Mini Rolls
Meat Lovers Pizza

“Stopped in for a quick take home pizza after a long day of traveling. I didn't order ahead, just stopped in, placed and order and waited. Kiera took our order and had it back to us in a quick fashion. Pizza is good, hadn't had Pizza Hut in years. Would stop in again.“

2.8 Average46 Reviews
Little Caesars Pizza Pizza •
434 E Main St, Hancock

“They were extremely understaffed. Their fore I'm truly unable to give a proper review. Gata say food was hot and good and the many ppl who were waiting we're amazingly polite and calm.Parking: Large and was a refueling station for big rigs.Wheelchair accessibility: Was at a convenience store location. So was a long ramp and I believe 2 Short wheel access points.“

2.7 Average23 Reviews

Enjoy More Tastes In Berkeley Springs

map Map