17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cumberland

“Always a good choice, 5 star review, that was seven years ago. Now 2026, Lack of sauce, lack of toppings, lack of cheese, 1/3 is crust now. Not worth $17 for a medium pizza. What happened? 😔 Ordered a bambino deluxe tonight worth it excellent job addressing this! Back to 5 star.“

“This place has some of the best food in the area. Their pizza and cannolis are my favorite! The service is outstanding! The staff are always going above and beyond making every visit exceptional! The portions are huge and the prices are very reasonable unlike other overrated Italian restaurants in our area. I really hope this place stays around for a long time! Thanks for the cannolis!“

“​If you're looking for a low-key local spot in Cumberland with solid comfort food and a laid-back vibe, Uncle Jack’s definitely hits the spot. It’s the kind of neighborhood pub where you can immediately relax, grab a cold drink, and count on fast, friendly service from the staff.
​The food menu covers all the classic pub favorites, but the hand-tossed pizza and strombolis are where they really shine—the crust has a great crunch and they don't skimp on the toppings. Whether you're stopping in to catch a game, grabbing a quick bite with friends, or taking advantage of their late-night takeout options, it’s a reliable local staple that always delivers a warm, welcoming experience.“

“My friend and I ate at Puccinis a few weeks ago, and it was absolutely awesome. I highly recommend the Chicken Parmesan and the Mediterranean French Onion Soup -- both were delicious and full of flavor. The Bruschetta Burger with homemade potato chips is definitely a favorite, too! The Red Velvet Cake is to die for, and they make a mean Bloody Mary. While our waitress could have been a bit more inviting, the overall experience was very enjoyable. We've eaten here before and will definitely be returning. The ambiance of the restaurant was really nice -- comfortable and inviting, making it a great place to relax and enjoy a meal.“

“First time coming to Lefty’s and my husband and I were not disappointed. Great food and very clean and friendly“

“good pizza“

“wonderful food. very pleasant atmosphere. Great service. highly recommend.“

“Great pizza with a perfectly cooked crust and fresh, flavorful toppings. On top of that, the people were incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Definitely coming back. 🍕😊“

“I have enjoyed Hartley's pizza, and wedgies for a long time. I recently ordered delivery, and was pleasantly surprised that they now accept cards for payment as well as cash. The food arrived quickly and was fresh and delicious.“

“what a fantastic place to visit, to the point I made this my hometown bar. alot of my friends have decided to make this a new home. great food, great fun, great staff, great owners. This place is the one to invite you to the next level of service...“

“We love Fox's. We used to have one here in Hagerstown but it closed. Now we have to go far away to enjoy their pizza. Any time there is a chance to have Fox's Pizza we always bay it. Delicious ? this location is super hard to find. I missed it three times. It is located on a gas station/ liquor store like place.

Parking: Plenty of parking“

“I’m very picky about my Alfredo sauce. This has to be the best I’ve eaten anywhere and that’s saying a lot. My husband grew up in Cumberland & he made it a point to come in & eat. Loved the bar area & the entire set up & atmosphere. A must stop when in Cumberland.“

“Yo, these guys are the bomb. Not only does everyone there seem to genuinely enjoy their job, which in the food service industry is rare. But the food? 🔥🔥 Absolutely fire. I hadn't had domino's in almost 13 years and will absolutely be going back.

Even had a issue on my order due to the app glitching out (not due to them) and they fixed it on spot.

Give these dudes a raise they're killing it.“

“Fast delivery, really like the online deals 😊“

“Love the pizza and wings. Of course I really like crunchy, well done wings so all I have to do is ask and they are great. I prefer this store over the one in Cumberland, I don't have to wait on the phone as long.

Wheelchair accessibility: This store is Wheelchair accessible.“

“Got a Big Daddy from Fox’s Pizza Den today—so cheesy, so delicious, probably the best pizza we’ve had in a while! 🍕💛“

“Really great pizza here. We ordered pepperoni and the works pizza. Isn't there a Gianni's in Frostburg? Anyway, the pepperoni was top notch. All the ingredients were exactly what they should be and great tasting! The Works or Deluxe pizza was very tasty too and a super good deal ! I think it was $18 for a large? Wow! Can't beat that! Great price plus great taste! Super! When I bit into the deluxe pizza, it took me back to a favorite pizza place my father used to take me to in Baltimore, circa 1975 as a kid. Definitely one of my top picks in Cumberland.“