32 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middletown

“I went to Tapias On Main with my husband last weekend for the first time and it was exceptional! 5 stars for everything- the rockfish on the special menu was amazing as well as the watermelon mojito! Our server Jenna was very friendly and attentive. I will definitely be recommending this restaurant to our friends.“

“For the second time this week I enjoyed a meal at Middletown Valley Pizzeria. On Tuesday my dad and I tried the meatball subs, and even the smaller 8" version was huge. It was hot, tasty, and arrived quickly after ordering. This evening my husband and I ordered the Margherita pizza for date night, and again, we were impressed. The crust was crisp and the sauce (which they make in house)was delightfully fresh. The price point was reasonable...and reasonably priced restaurants in Middletown is something we could use more of. Give the place a try, they could use the support, and you will like the pizza. We'll definitely be back.“

“We have eaten here every week since 2017. It’s a great neighborhood restaurant with amazing staff and food.“

“Could not believe how patient, charming, and effective they were during the Halloween rush last night. The other pizza place in town is closed for renovations so they really were swamped.

Screen on the wall showed pickup status making communication clear. Smiles on all the faces working so hard were exemplary.“

“Our family orders two times a month. Love the choices for making your own pizza, the pasta and salads. Always easy to order on line, delivery on time and enjoy the savings with coupons.“

“Stopped after a day of soccer games. We ordered two pies to share with our party of 4 - Supreme Italiano and a Margeritha. Pies were huge!!! Freshly made in a wood fire oven. Great service and value!! Spacious indoor and outdoor seating!! Highly recommend!!!“

“Best pizza I’ve had in a long time!!! We also had boneless wings, and they were great also!!!! Highly recommend!!! We need you to open a place in Martinsburg!!“

“Our first time at this restaurant and our server was absolutely outstanding . Her name is Cassandra and she was very welcoming with our 4.5 year old son. Normally we get looks and comments when we go out about him being loud or theatrical but she was SO understanding and supporting . She got him icecream cake and made sure he had such an accepting experience. As parents it melted our heart and we would 10/10 recommend this restaurant as well as her service. Come see her Friday nights for an amazing experience .“

“Whenever I plan a trip south from Boston I figure out how to incorporate the white rabbit into the trip. The pizza is something I have dream about.“

“I was introduced to this pizza truck at the Emmitsburg Farmers Market this past Friday afternoon. I don't like wood fired pizza but I sat next to them for several hours and finally the amazing smells coming from this truck got the better of me. I got the Alfredo 2.0 and it was everything the description said it would be. Absolutely incredible melding of flavors amd a perfect crust. The pizza was perfectly cooked but perhaps best of all was served at a temperature that I could eat almost immediately instead of like most places where pizza is served at the tempersture of molten lava. So happy I tried it and I will be searching them out in the future. Mike of Mike's Farm Market“

“the $7 plus tax tiramusa is a pre made pudding cup basically... so disappointing...and it's partially frozen“

“This food is amazing. who would've thought to dedicate a whole restaurant to pizza and Pretzels...idk but they're a freaking genius. the Calzone's are so good. The pizza and Pretzels are delicious. I love this place.“

“Always have to stop in for a chicken gyro when I'm in town! The best tzatziki ever!!! Great family run business!“

“Awesome food! We ride up from Baltimore just to enjoy the seafood. I highly recommend you try this place.“

“This is our favorite go to restaurant! The subs and pizza are amazing. The garlic knots are the best we ever had. Not only is the food amazing the owner and staff are so friendly & kind! Please support this small local business!!!“

“Great pizza! love the spaghetti! The young man who delivered tonight trouble-shot our address quick and got hot dinner here on time! much thanks on this dreary cold Friday!“

“awesome and kind people and love the service and food is amazing“

“Our high school volleyball team banquet was held at Pistarro’s in the Amalfi room. Donna and the rest of the staff was amazing. They had the room set up beautifully and the food was great. Thank you for making it easy to celebrate our athletes!“

“Hands down, King's has the BEST Sicilian pizza in Frederick County, and even Washington County. We lived in Brunswick for only a few years and still drive back simply to get a Sicilian. It is absolutely worth a drive.

Their spinach pie is AMAZING too. 🥰🥰“

“Great local pizza, first time we were there was in 91' friendly upbeat people. ignore the construction they are open!!“

“There pizza, pasta, subs, and calzones are excellent.“

“The greatest pizza ever awesome pepperonis“

“Have always loved Ledos pizza. I ordered the pizza & was good as usual. I tried the wings for the 1st time & didn't like them. Could be just me bc I like mine a little more done/crispy skin. They weren't good at all. Think I'll stick to the pizza.“

“Great stop for personal pizza. You can customize with different sauces and cheeses. The mini is pretty small but the medium size is a solid portion for a great price. They also have plant based cheese and plant based sausage which is a great option for vegan eaters. Really liked the pesto sauce and the buffalo! Very nice service!“

“A 5 year old's paradise. So much fun“

“Great veggie pizza! The order was done when I arrived and it was delicious“

“Good food and service . The Host was really nice. Enjoyed the outdoors.“

“Best halal fast food in town. I recently moved to this area and ordered food from them. Its finger licking delicious“

“Here’s an update. I firmly believe in second chances, so I ordered again and had no problems. The pizza was delicious! Since then, I’ve continued to order here and there, and I haven’t had any issues at all. In fact, this place has become our go-to pizza spot!

Last time I had pizza from this place. Toppings always fall off, every single time, also only half of the pizza had toppings. I expect more when I pay $50+ on freaking pizza…“

“Bacon cheesesteak sub was on point, slammin.“

“I know they’ve had some recent hurdles in the past with staff and timing, but today we ordered pizza to celebrate my son’s birthday and I was a little hesitant on doing delivery. Not only were the pizzas loaded with toppings and steaming hot, they arrived to my door on-time and with a smile! Way to go, guys!!!“

“Super nice staff, there was an issue with my pizza so they had to remake it when I arrived, but they didn't hesitate to offer a dessert to compensate for the wait!

Parking: Normal amount of parking for a small shopping center“