Procolino's Pizza

$ • Pizza, Italian

711 Washington Ave #9, Chestertown
(410) 778-5900


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Procolino's Pizza

I've been to New York and Italy, among other cities, and tried pizza all over the place. This is the best pizza I've ever had. From this unassuming strip-mall restaurant's oven comes crunchy, chewy, garlicky, tomato-ey, cheesy goodness like I've never had anywhere else, all with nothing but smiles from the pizza pros making and serving it. Procolino is a reason to come to Chestertown all by itself. Get off the main drag and get in here--it will be the best meal you have in town, full review
Cool place. Owner is very nice. Drink refills are awkward. They should really put the soda machine where the public can get their own drinks. They do charge for refills but they have it to us my fam of 5 on the house. I appreciate the gesture but I'd pay more I order to get the drink faster. Anyone with children would understand what I mean. The steak sub was really good along with the pizza and mozzarella sticks. The portion for the mozzarella sticks were lame though. Again full review

Eating a slice of heaven right now, indoor dining. The smell hit me hard when I stood by the cash register. Oregano, garlic, cheese, grilling beef, OMG. This place is AMAZING. Didn't hurt to get to chat with a woman who has been coming here since childhood. She was glowing with all the memories. Try the tiramisu if you have any room left after an amazing entree.

More Reviews(159)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 10AM - 9PM
Wednesday 10AM - 9PM
Thursday 10AM - 9PM
Friday 10AM - 9PM
Saturday 10AM - 9PM
Sunday 10AM - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.