16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cumberland

“This place has some of the best food in the area. Their pizza and cannolis are my favorite! The service is outstanding! The staff are always going above and beyond making every visit exceptional! The portions are huge and the prices are very reasonable unlike other overrated Italian restaurants in our area. I really hope this place stays around for a long time! Thanks for the cannolis!“

“Our food was hot and the toppings was plentiful. They were getting busy by the time we were getting ready to leave. We waited for them to get done, when our server came to our table and ask if we would like to pay at the table. This was very nice and thoughtful of her. We will be back.“

“I must tell everybody about this bartender on Labor Day, September 1. We wanted cocktails and lunch, and this was the only place that we found open. The bartender was as sweet as could be. She got our pizza and drink orders correct to the T without writing it all down. And the customers started coming in, and coming, and coming. But here's the amazing part: By HERSELF, she waited all of the tables, delivered all of the food and drinks, cleared the tables, and rang up the tabs...for 50+ people including families and kids!!! Some of them inside, some of them outside. And she never lost her cool, never kept us waiting for our food or drink refills! She did finally receive some relief when another waitress arrived. We didn't catch the bartender's name, but she deserves the biggest raise ever.“

“good pizza“

“This restaurant was recommended to us by a co-worker. We went away for the weekend and stopped here for supper one evening. Excellent food and service. Also a nice atmosphere. The chicken parm is a 10/10.“

“I have enjoyed Hartley's pizza, and wedgies for a long time. I recently ordered delivery, and was pleasantly surprised that they now accept cards for payment as well as cash. The food arrived quickly and was fresh and delicious.“

“wonderful food. very pleasant atmosphere. Great service. highly recommend.“

“Always friendly! My favorite is the cheese steak...made perfectly and they have no problem creating it my way.“

“We love Fox's. We used to have one here in Hagerstown but it closed. Now we have to go far away to enjoy their pizza. Any time there is a chance to have Fox's Pizza we always bay it. Delicious ? this location is super hard to find. I missed it three times. It is located on a gas station/ liquor store like place.

Parking: Plenty of parking“

“what a fantastic place to visit, to the point I made this my hometown bar. alot of my friends have decided to make this a new home. great food, great fun, great staff, great owners. This place is the one to invite you to the next level of service...“

“It the pizza I’ve been craving from my childhood! It’s exactly as Fox’s Pizza should be!“

“Come stop on by to try some of their renowned high quality foods. Although like any restaurant high-volume times may cause for slightly longer wait times the majority of time your food should be ready within 20 to 25 minutes after the initial order and out hot and ready. the welcoming knowledgeable and experienced staff will help you find your favorite bite to eat. Guaranteed best pizza delivery in the Cumberland Maryland area.“

“Edit: I called and talked to them about last night's order. They replaced the incorrect items with the right ones. Excellent service and food.

Ordered pasta with red sauce and Italian sausage. It arrived with cheese also. Ordered NY crust, lite sauce, extra cheese and bacon, received hand tossed pepperoni.“

“My husband and I stopped here 20 minutes before close. The staff were helpful and courteous. They took the time to make our food fresh and hot! They allowed us to enjoy our meal without feeling rushed. Service was top notch at the end of the day. Highly recommend. Would eat here regularly if we lived closer.“

“Love the pizza and wings. Of course I really like crunchy, well done wings so all I have to do is ask and they are great. I prefer this store over the one in Cumberland, I don't have to wait on the phone as long.

Wheelchair accessibility: This store is Wheelchair accessible.“

“This place went downhill. I ordered two pizzas to be delivered. It came after 1h20m and the pizza was hardly lukewarm. I tried calling back and I was almost there before they answered. took the pizzas back and they tried to argue with me. Wasted nearly 2 hours as I still had to figure out dinner.“