17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Elkton

“Nice place, nice food, great costumer Service! It was our first time at that store and it was a great experience! The female manager was very nice and helpful she recommended us to try their best dishes and we really liked all of them! Totally recommend it“

“Great food. great service. probably the best Italian cuisine I've had in the area.“

“Had a great supper tonight with my Sweetie 💙 Always a pleasure to see the nice folks at Dominick's Pizza. The food is delicious. Staff are always friendly 🤠 Even with the Friday night rush the wait is worth it‼️“

“Good pizza! Also nice that’s it’s a family run business where everyone contributes. Very nice folks.“

“I am giving it four stars went to the bathroom there wasn't any toilet paper no hot water and if u try to turn it to hot the whole faucet moves ok over looked that got a bagel with cream cheese and a slice of pumpkin roll bagel was good toasted the way I liked and had the right amount of cream cheese the pumpkin roll however that was a no for me looks good but when I took a piece it was stale like it's been there a couple days the icing wasn't that good either now I know why it was only 1.00 will go there for the food but not the bakery stuff not if everything is stale the way that pumpkin roll was but there is always next time“

“Very very DISAPPOINTING ☹️ They are good for basic Italian specialties and usually never had a problem. I am a regular customer and spend a good amount of money with them. Today was different. ordered the supposedly homemade baked penne pasta. it came sloshed in an oversized round container with only half the cheese on top and it was very runny. A monkey could have done better 😒🐒 Plenty of other places to get basic Italian 😒😒😒 I called to let them know about this and they didn't even offer to make it right 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️“

“It’s as delicious as it looks.“

“We tried the Street Corn (elotes) tonight on a whim after seeing their highway sign. It was delicious. We will definitely be back to try the Birria Tacos.“

“El mejor lugar para disfrutar pizza o tacos“

“Delicious Italian hoagies!“

“People that give one star are definitely holding a grudge about something personal. I have ordered several times and so have my family members and NEVER have had a complaint well i had one i wanted the rice pudding but it wasn't in the menu anymore lol. The food is fantastic and huge portions .. it's is so fresh that the other places are not even an option anymore.. The biggest factor in my 5 star is the price, even someone on a small budget could afford to eat here and have plenty of left- overs. If you have an issue with someone that has nothing to do with their business talk it out or just be done with that person dont effect their livelihood for satisfaction...not only do you hurt their business you hurt yourself..... Karma, it comes for everyone!
UPDATE...ok writing review made me hungry so I ordered dinner...just had my first uh oh..
None of my sides were in the orderthe chocolate sauce was missing from my dough balls and only a dab of powder sugar on my funnel fries that was literally covering 4 fries. I called and after i gave address n complaint she asked if i wanted to talk to manager however it's dinner time and they are busy. I really expected acall back afterwards though... didn't happeen..leaving 5 stars cause the food i got ,, the Stromboli was a 10 star.“

“I enjoyed eating here again, was awhile since I last dined in, glad it’s open now. I live about 25 minutes away from my closest Seasons, nice to eat the food fresh again, was delicious 😋“

“I have ordered at this Dominos pizza location in Elkton multiple times in the actual store to carry our and I have ordered delivery 2 times to my home nearby this location. The food has pretty much always been very good and I really like the various different options of crust to choose from when ordering a pizza. I usually get the New York style as it is the preference of my family and myself. However, this last time I ordered delivery from here I decided to give their hand-tossed crust a try. I decided to choose hand-tossed as I noticed on the menu it mentioned that the hand-tossed crust as a garlic buttery flavor. I actually really liked the the hand-tossed crust and the light flavor of garlic and butter was very good, not too powerful where it took over the taste of the entire pizza overall. The only part of our order that I was slightly disappointed about was the chicken Caesar salad that I ordered. The photo shown of the chicken Caesar salad online on the Dominoes website showed a much more enticing salad. But once I received it , I was very unimpressed with the look of the salad because I immediately couldn't help but notice that what I received and the photo of this salad on the website were two completely different salads. In fact, the salad was not a fresh salad in which they prepare in the store like the other pizza places that I normally order from. The salad I received was like one of those type of pre made salads like you can find at Walmart in the produce section. They are in a clear plastic bowl with every ingredient separated in the container and it is sealed with clear plastic in order to keep it as fresh as possible. However, the $6.99 price of the salad considering the low quality on my opinion, was a couple of dollars too much. I actually just put the Caesar salad in my fridge to either eat later on or send with my daughter to school for lunch the next day. Upon seeing it and expecting something quite a bit different going by the photo of the chicken Caeser on the website, I just no longer had much of a taste for it....so I just ate a slice of pizza and one of their delicious cookie brownies for dessert. We always order atleast one order of these warm cookie brownies and sometimes even two orders to have thru the next day as well. They definitely do a lovely job on these tasty and warm brownies and I really like how an order of these includes“

“The place is dirty. Looks like no one has vacuumed in weeks. Some tables were dirty. Old pizza under my table.Bathroom was filthy. Paper towel holder barely hanging on wall.“

“Great drinks, good food, fabulous staff. The crowd always rocks! Supports local live music! Ride the Goat loves playing this venue!“

“Great drinks, good food, fabulous staff. The crowd always rocks! Supports local live music! Ride the Goat loves playing this venue!“

“I was so excited to move to Maryland and find out Nick and Joe's were still in business. N &J was the spot to hit if you went to the Castle Mall.
I have decided to redo my previous review because I never read the reviews before and it looks as if someone is out to sabotage N&J REVIEWS. That is not fair because this is somebodys family who has worked hard for over 50 years. The one thing I will agree with is the girl who answers the phone ,sure does not like her job, she is rude and doesn't like for you to ask questions about anything. I've only ordered delivery because of a car accident so I can't speak on the establishment atmosphere itself. I know back in the day we loved going in because they would speak Italian and we would bring our friend who spoke Italian and the things they would say that they didn't know we could here were crazy stories we loved to eavesdropin. They also loved beautiful woman who they would also speak about but in a great way.
I can tell by reading the reviews and comments that have been on here lately are being made from someone that has a grudge against them and are having people that I'm sure never been there to put bad reviews up. I would ask people to go there themselves and form your own opinion. I've had things not up to par but nothing to do with the taste and quality of the food. I would not being going there for 50 yeara if the food tasted the way the reviews said. I hope in the future people leave an honest review because even if you don't have your own business karma will get you another way . Good luck in the future Nick and Joes ... maybe just critique a few things and maybe have the phone person who is the first representative of your business go to a customer service training course on line because her attitude could already set somebody's 2mind to having a bad experience so then they look at every point of service with not so rose colored glassesI wish your nothing but the best and I just ordered your 2 medium pizza specials one with jalapenos... face 5 star for atmosphere because I'm not going to give bad stars for something idk about
.“