28 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newark

“Whitney was great and very attentive.“

“We stop in once a week. Sometimes we eat there and sometimes we call and pick up. The atmosphere is fabulous. If we ever do have to wait for our food, it’s totally worth it. If my husband and I are together we sit and have wine while we wait. They are all very friendly! If we get take out, we always get extra so we can have leftovers, which are always delicious. We reheat the pizza in the toaster oven, it’s amazing. We also love the desserts there! It’s just a great spot and we love it! I’ve never once been disappointed with any of their service or food.“

“The gluten free pizza is delicious and safe for those with even the most gluten sensitivity! Highly recommend!“

“Going to Tony's is always a wonderful experience. The owners and staff are amazingly warm and friendly. And of course, the food is mouth watering delicious; the very best around.“

“Can't believe I've never reviewed one of my favorite restaurants.

Pizza is outstanding here, but my favorite thing is the smiley chicken sandwich. It's the greatest chicken sandwich in all of the land. The chips absolutely rule too.“

“It was really good thanks!“

“The best pizza! Grandma's pizza & Bruschetta pizza are our favorites!!“

“First time trying this place and it was amazing! We had a friendly, attentive server. He checked in with us many times, refilling our drinks and chatting with us. The garlic bread, salad and Pizza was absolutely amazing!! Can’t wait to go back again.“

“Love this place go all the time get all the spaghetti dishes the staff great friendly people love it“

“Best pizza & customer service in town! We love it!“

“Great food and atmosphere!!“

“We stopped at lunch to get a slice of pizza and a meatball sandwich. The pizza was good - nothing to make it stand out from many other places, but definitely worth getting again . The meatball sandwich was smaller than most places but was also less expensive and came with fries. Overall, a much better deal. I wish they had a lunch deal that included two slices of pizza and a soda, but alas, a special that is common to many places does not exist here. The eating area is spacious and comfortable.“

“amazing pizza would return to area just for this pizza“

“My very first time here. But when I tell you the pizza is good. It’s good! I got two slices of cheese and these slices are huge!! Good food for awesome value! Awesome atmosphere, and clean. Very pleasant customer service. I will be returning“

“stoll as good as it was 20 years ago when I was eating it for study fuel!“

“Outstanding dining experience. Delicious food & wonderful atmosphere.“

“Great food and drinks. Amazing service“

“First time ordering from here . Ordered delivery . Came in a timely manner . Ordered a square 16x16 Chicken Alfredo Pizza and Broccoli bites .LET ME TELL YOU !Next time I will definitely order 2 .They were pillowy soft on the inside , not breaded all crazy . The ranch on the side was a great addition as well .Now for the pizza …. BABY !It was everything a chicken Alfredo pizza should be . The only difference is , next time , I will definitely add some veggies and make it a little well done . It was juicy and full of cheese and chicken . The chicken was perfectly cooked and cut up .Safe to say , I take food VERY seriously . Based off this experience, I look forward to ordering again and exploring the menu . Thank you Troy’s for the delicious dinner !“

“K es muy muy bueno“

“It was around 10:00 pm at night after a card show and my friend and I were hungry. We called to order even though they closed at 10:30 pm. They happily took our order and told us about 20 minutes. The food was hot and fresh, but it tasted like a frozen pizza you would just heat up but with more toppings. Overall it was good for what we needed. We also ordered the old bay wings and they were very good. Overall check this place out.“

“Great double cheeseburgers and fries! Friendly atmosphere and owners!!“

“This is probably our favorite takeout spot. The prices are so reasonable, and the food is always great. I don't think I've ever had a bad experience here, and we've ordered here for several years. That's pretty amazing when I think about it. The cashiers are always pleasant. The order is always on time, and well-packaged

Message to the owners and staff: I think you are doing everything right, and I hope you never change. ☺️“

“Nice neighborhood pizza joint. Definitely changed hands in the last few years (no updates to the interior, 90s throwback vibe). Pizza was hot and the crust was tasty. It’s a chill, seat yourself kinda place otherwise take out or delivery works too.

*The menu lists beer options however none is available.

Vegetarian options: Lots of Veggie-Friendly options in all sections.“

“Second time ordering from here, food is fresh pizza is very good, and buffalo wings were good ,excellent service great customer service.“

“There aren’t many places to choose from where one may get and eat a Cobb salad in the dining room at 9 PM. This is one and it was good. The salad was large, fresh, and included generous portions of grilled chicken breast and gargonzola cheese. It really didn’t even need the salad dressing which was offered to me. I’m happy I stopped here and didn’t subject myself to the readily available disaster called fast food.“

“Recently had my engagement party here with family and friends. The owners and staff were extremely helpful and accomadating of our party. We had salad, pasta, and pizza - all of the food and beer was great! Happy to have had them as a part of my fiance and I special day.“

“On thanksgiving eve 2024, at 11:11 p.m., your manager, who is a young, black, well-spoken, and highly professional took good care of me at this store and I just want to give him praise he deserves and hopefully other guest can go in and have a great interaction with him like I did as well as hoping corporate acknowledges his worth; because you have a great asset to the company right there. Kudos to you young man. I hope you enjoy your Thanksgiving with your family, enjoy your mom's food, and enjoy watching some football despite being an Eagles fan. You're awesome!“

“I've always had good food here and the service has been good, although, I've only ever done the take out. I have not dined in.

Wheelchair accessibility: Although they have a handicap entrance, it's not well marked and you need to walk further than the regular staired entrance to get to it from the main parking area. During the pandemic they had a couple parking spots reserved to curbside which were near the handicap entrance, but i would not say were wheelchair friendly in regards to the space needed. I don't know if they are an area you can park in longer term now (say if dining in). You need to drive around the building to get to them. If the front is side A, this would be side D as you drive around the building to the right.“