“I feel blessed to live within walking distance. I’m never going to move. The Mediterranean meals are really nutritious and delicious. The house yogurt and desserts are so yummy.Everything I’ve ordered was cooked to perfection. Their pizza looks amazingly just as good as it tastes.? Don’t tell anyone ?“
“This is truly a wonderful family restaurant. The pasta is the best, the sauce excellent, the quantities generous. So is the owner, a very nice, unpretentious funny guy who cares about his guests and what he feeds them. Everything on the menu looks scrumptious. Highly recommended.“
“First time trying. We will be back. It is apparent they are using good ingredients. Ceasar salad with chicken was very good. They make the dressing in house. The pizza was very great. Good crust, good sauce, good cheese. We will be back. I want to try the meatballs next and the mussels.“
“Great selection of slices for lunch if you need to just grab a quick bite. Take out pizzas are hot and selection of toppings is huge. Sauce is home made and tastes it! Their sausage is excellent and their sweet peppers are the real thing. Enjoy!“
“Have been going here for years. The homemade sandwich rolls are absolutely amazing. Pizza is on point with my favorite NYC neighborhood pizzeria. The inside is pretty much no frills but the food is very good. Grab a booth and bring your family or swing by at lunchtime for a quick bite. PS. Try the garlic knots!!“
“Excellent pizza! Didn't want to judge too quickly so decided to wait until we ordered again. This time, it was just as good and the service was just as helpful and friendly. I am gluten free, (not celiac) so we gave theirs a shot along with the regular ones we ordered. All I can say is WOW! I have tried so many places in the area hoping to find a GF crust that resembles 'real' pizza, and Stone Mill has figured it out! I asked if it was cauliflower crust or a blend, and the person answering the phone happily gave us the ingredients of what it is made from, without sounding annoyed at the time it took to explain. The crust is great, not pre-made and thankfully not cauliflower. It's not paper thin and came out well done with that charred look and wood fire taste like original crust has. But most importantly, it was delicious. It's not a tiny little 10" crust, or a personal size - it's the same size as all the others. (I was so excited when I saw it I dove right in without taking a picture!) The whole experience, from the politeness when ordering on the phone, to the finished products were great. It's amazing how many places make it sound like they are doing you the favor when they take an order. Great pizza and great service. This is the only place we will order from going forward.“