Carleo Italian Pizza

Italian, Pizza

101 Silo Hill Rd #5, Emmitsburg
(301) 447-1999


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Carleo Italian Pizza

I could not decide between pizza and a sub so I ordered both. The pizza was a great buy for $2 a slice. Yeasty crust, just enough sauce and great cheese. Had I stopped by Mon-Fri 11-3 I could have had 2 slices and a soda for $5. That is just one of several lunch specials. The meatball sub was just OK. The roll was soft, not crunchy and I don't think the meatballs simmered in the sauce. Plenty of mozzarella on top. The small sub was mighty big, especially after that full review

Staff is friendly and the subs were great. My only problem is I like things cleaned very well. I think the lower walls/tile need fixed up and it grosses me out to see an employee on their phone while preparing food. Your cell phone is dirty, just like mine is right now. Please don't put on your gloves to work preparing food and then text/talk on the phone. You wear gloves for sanitation and using your phone is not sanitary.

I love Carleo's Pizza! I think their sauce is the best in town! Subs are great and salads are good. The only thing I did not think is all that great is the meat they use in the lasagna-I certainly recommend overall if you are looking for Italian food in Emmitsburg.

More Reviews(49)


Monday 10:30AM - 10PM
Tuesday 10:30AM - 10PM
Wednesday 10:30AM - 10PM
Thursday 10:30AM - 10PM
Friday 10:30AM - 11PM
Saturday 10:30AM - 10PM
Sunday 11AM - 10PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.