50 Best Italian Restaurants near Millersville

“IYKYN…there’s nothing like the unique taste of a Ledo’s pizza! The sauce is amazing and the toppings are tasty and fresh. The crust is thin and crispy, and of course, square. I ordered takeout and it was ready for pickup when I arrived. Fantastic in every way.“

“The food is absolutely amazing….pricey but worth it! Better than Little Italy quality.“

“it was the highlight of my day to come to Carrabba's with my wife. We were nearby and always come to Carrabba's for our favorite dish. Fettuccine Carrabba! It's the best and the people that work here in Pasadena are the sweetest most accommodating out of all of them. I love the atmosphere, the cleanliness, the service and the food. The manager "Ben" is fantastic too!“

“A consistently wonderful restaurant and dining experience. Great menu with mainstays and new and seasonal offerings. Excellent bar and libations. Friendly and gracious serving staff.“

“Went for the first time yesterday and I don’t know why I waited so long?!?! It’s only because I didn’t know about them! My new fav spot!!! Happy hour is the best! Portions are huge and you feel the love in every bite. The staff was so friendly and welcoming. We had Annie at the bar and she was amazing! Can’t wait to go back!“

“Great customer service, quick service good food“

“This is a local Italian market and deli. We come here after for authentic Italian both over the counter as well as pre-made dishes to take home and cook. Either way, you can't go wrong if you in the mood for Italian. I highly recommend this spot for Great Italian food!“

“No one will say from the ambiance that this place is not fine dining. The cuisine they have, the ambiance, the staff, the music—I could go on and on about it.“

“we love this place!! 5 stars all day every day!“

“Amazing food! Hand made pasta! What?! Hidden gem in Edgewater. Will be a regular.“

“Many thanks to Pasticcio Fresh Italian Kitchen for working with St. Mary’s Lacrosse for their Christmas game. Pasticcio made it easy to feed over 130 people today.“

“Great food, fantastic service! A hidden gem!“

“Never disappointed. Food always very good.“

“We tried Italia’s based off recommendations and we are so satisfied. The pizza was fantastic!! The gluten-free was great for my husband. I’m new to the area and prefer local vs chain restaurants for pizza. Totally recommend this for pizza. I can’t wait to dine in for other dishes!“

“We had a large group and we took over the entire place and they were as nice as can be very accommodating..food great service great we tried cleaning up because we were so many and the man said he'd take care of, so very nice wonderful place.“

“I’ve been coming here for years—back before the name change—and it’s still one of my top pizza picks. They’re generous with cheese and toppings, and the flavor never misses. The white pizza is my go-to, and the thin crust is key (grew up on NJ/PHL/NY pizza, so this matters).

Their Greek salad is probably my favorite salad around here—I would literally drink the dressing 😂. And tonight I finally tried the cream of crab soup… easily one of the best I’ve ever had, and better than the dozens I’ve tried across the area and the other regions of the country I’ve lived in that have blue crab. Packed with crab meat and so much flavor. My 6-year-old even polished off a whole bowl and said, “This is going to make them rich.” Honestly, can’t argue with that lmao.“

“I came in last night after work with my husband and our friend. We decided to sit at the bar, watch the game and have some food and drinks. I'm writing this review because we had the best service we ever had at Olive Garden, hands-down and definitely top service overall. Ryan B. was our bartender/ server. He was attentive and incredibly friendly. He made sure we had anything we needed. Amazing experience last night!“

“Italian Chicken Cheesesteak is the best!“

“I had such a great experience thanks to my server, Kelsey G! She was super friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect from start to finish. You can tell she genuinely cares about her guests — she checked in at the right times, kept a smile the whole time, and made great recommendations. Her positive energy really made the visit enjoyable. Definitely one of the best servers I’ve had — thank you, Kelsey!“

“Anthony’s NY Pizza & Pasta House was truly a 10/10 dining experience. From the warm welcome at the door to the attentive service throughout the meal, everything was exceptional. We started with a Caesar salad and complimentary freshly baked bread with butter, which set the tone perfectly. We ordered the white pizza and the filet mignon, and both were outstanding. The pizza was cooked to perfection—the crust alone was incredible—and the flavor was on point. The wine selection was also excellent and paired well with the meal.

I would highly recommend Anthony’s to anyone looking for high-quality food and great service. I’ll definitely be returning!“

“Quality matters !!! Ordered for the first time tonight. Amazing and fresh !!! Highly recommend !!!“

“Wonderful, wonderful experience! Not only did we have a good experience on Thursday night with our basketball team, but when we called again on Friday they remembered us. Commented on how well behaved our school was. We ended up ordering 15 pizzas for Friday night, they gave us 20 bucks off and carried all 15 pizzas to the car for us. We will definitely be back! Bayview Seahawks thank you.“

“Local fresh Italian dishes w Monday pizza Specials $5 off. Nightly board specials w homemade sauces, pastas w seafood, chicken, meat. Nice clean atmosphere w self serve free drink refills+ fresh brewed tea. Sister restaurant to original Bella Italia in Annapolis.“

“Wonderful experience recommend tom.“

“Hands-down best pizza in town!!!“

“Three Brothers is hands down our favorite Italian restaurant in the area! The lasagna is absolutely phenomenal—rich, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. Honestly, everything we’ve tried from their menu has been amazing. We order from them on DoorDash several times a month, and they never disappoint. Highly recommend this place to anyone craving delicious, authentic Italian food!“

“Try the calamari and cherry limeade“

“Mamma Lucia's delivers the goods. I'm sure their pizzas are great. I'm sure their take out menu as a whole is great. But, go on in. Order your food. Sit down. Because something cooked with care and love is coming your way. The staff is great, too! everyone from the order station to the fine ladies and gentlemen working the kitchen. If you care to watch them in action (which you can). everybody is hustling. it's just great. I've been there over and over during the years, and I'll keep showing up in the future. Love them!“

“Was in the area and was told this is the pizza place of all places. All my friends know I take my pizza pretty seriously. Met with the owner (helluva great guy) and it is a pizza worth a 12hr drive.“

“Great food good service and atmosphere“

“I am picky when it comes to salads but they have the best and most fresh salad from any other restaurant I’ve been to. I just buy the house salad and use the house dressing and li e it so much. I wish I had a pic to share but next time I’m there I will take one and update my review. Service is always great. Alex is always so helpful and welding when I go in there so is everyone else.“

“I wish I could give 3.5 stars in this review because I liked this restaurant enough that I would try it again, but the food we tried was "fine" but not great. For lunch, I ordered the Mozzarella Caprese. It was generous, but I found it a little bland, probably because of the olive oil used. (Some olive oil is delicious practically on its own.) My husband had a Sausage Roll, which he also thought was a little bland. But we both enjoyed the space, with the fountain in the middle. When we were there (Sunday for lunch) it was relatively quiet. We ordered at the counter then chose a table near the fountain and just relaxed. We had been driving for hours and this break was just what we needed. I also checked out what they had for sale in the market, but found it all a little expensive, so did not buy anything. I would try the pizza next time because it looked good. I would certainly give this restaurant another try.“

“Best menu around the Pasadena area“

“We had delivery at our motel. Wish we were staying longer because we would definitely order again. The Buffalo jumbo Wings and Chicken Quesadilla were delicious. Delivery prompt.“

“Great fresh salads and delicious calzones“

“This place has some really good pizza. They have some creative specialties as well which id definitely recommend. Whether youre just in the mood for a simple pepperoni or feeling something different, I highly recommend Squisito. Its become one if my favorite local pizza shops and I frequent this place for its great food. The service is good, they're generally pretty quick and the prices are alright, but i wouldnt call it cheap- considering everything else in the world is expensive now, it cant be helped. I generally get takeout, so I can't speak to the atmosphere, but definitely give it a try sometime. If you’re on the fence about it, I can vouch for this place and say its worth trying.“

“Romilo’s is such a gem in the community! Their happy hour and game day specials are hard to beat, with delicious wings, pizza, and plenty of other favorites to enjoy. It’s always a welcoming spot to gather with friends. A big shoutout to Jenn, the manager, who goes above and beyond—her warmth and genuine care for customers makes every visit even better. Highly recommend!“

“10+ Wow! Excellent service from our server Isabell. The interior is beautiful and extremely clean, food was excellent and the entire staff was attentive and super supportive. It is great to see a well run restaurant and superb service in Edgewater, MD or the entire state. The Manager, Luke, is definitely on his game as is the entire team. Super courteous. To the owner and the Ledo Corporate team, not sure what you’re paying this crew, but they deserve a raise. Keep up the quality and service. We will definitely frequent Ledo Edgewater.“

“Food is great. The young female at the counter that took my order was like a robot. She had no personality and seemed a lil scary, like horror movieish. She wasn't rude or anything just them deep cold glassy eyes. White female, glasses and blonde hair.
But pizza was delicious.“

“Pizza was tasty. Crust was crunchy. One of the best pizzas I had since moving to Maryland. The wait was about 10-12 minutes for the pizza. Service was great for it to be only 1 staff that was doing the front and waiting on tables in the back.“

“As a transplanted New Yorker, finding great pizza can be a challenge. But, Little Carmine’s has their pizza DOWN PAT! Highly recommend ☺️☺️“

“Great food, quiet hideaway 😊“

“If you pick up your food instead of delivery, this place is top-notch. The staff are friendly and quick, and the food is consistent every time. My family loves the cheese pizza and the original Stromboli — golden brown outside, cheesy and saucy inside. It’s become our Friday-night tradition. Highly recommend the garlic dipping sauce, too!“

“First time ordering today got the chicken quesadilla very very good“

“I wouldn’t normally order a pasta dish from a pizza and sub shop, but I’m glad I gave it a try. The shrimp alfredo was a massive portion, delicious and came with a yummy side salad and bread for a little over $20. The italian dressing was top notch too. So good and such a good deal. Even my almost one year old loved it 🙂“

“This is probably going to be our go-to pizza place now that we've moved to Pasadena. The wings are decent and pizza is great. Gave it 4 starts on food because there's never enough dough in the middle of the pie, meaning when you go to grab a slice, the middle just collapses in your hand. But since we prefer a nice thin floppy pizza, it's not the biggest deal breaker.Service is good and good delivery service when you're feeling lazy.“

“I don't normally share things like this but a pizza party for my students today was amazing thanks to our Severna Park Pizza Boli's. A group of my 2nd graders saved 50 "Bird Bucks" each for a pizza party. We called Papa John's because they open at 10:30 and we needed 3 cheese pizzas delivered by their 11:00 lunchtime. AFTER Papa John's 25% SCHOOL DISCOUNT those 3 pizzas would have cost $39.71. A $2.95 delivery fee was included in that total but $39.71 AFTER a 25% discount for 3 pizzas?!? Although they didn't open until 11:00, I then called our SP Pizza Boli's around 10:45 to see if I could place an order anyway. There was no answer BUT a nice gentleman there ended up calling my phone back at 10:50 so I could place our order early. The pizza was hot and fresh, arrived quickly, and was half the price of Papa John's. I won't be calling Papa John's again for any of our parties. Thank you Severna Park Pizza Boli's! � �“

“Got food here for the first time & it was pretty good. You get a decent amount for the price too. The person I interacted with was very polite & friendly. * We ordered- Chana Masala; great amount & not over spiced as far as heat, I also loved the buttered naan :)

My partner got a Bacon cheeseburger & let me know it was pretty good & that made some decent fries with it.

We'll likely be back to support this small business :)“

“The service was great! My food came out in a timly manor and my cup was always full! The food was wonderful! I had a bbq chicken pizza and side salad. The house dressing was so good, i had to buy one for the house! The kiddos loved it too. Little Tim lived his chicken tenders and fries! 10/10 recommend!!“

“I ate here for lunch. What a wonderful place. The food was great and the staff was awesome. I haven't had pizza this good since I was in Italy.“