22 Best Italian Restaurants near Williamsport

“Dear Sir/Madam, I am writing to express my satisfaction with the dining experience I recently had at Marcos restaurant and to provide a positive review. My husband and I have recently switched to dining at Marcos because of the exceptional service and quality of food we have received. We have found the staff to be friendly and kind, and the food is simply amazing. In particular, we love the bread option with olive dipping which is simply delicious. We recently ordered carry-out from Marcos and something remarkable happened. Our 5-year-old daughter, who is typically a picky eater, tried the pizza and kept eating more slices. This is a huge accomplishment for us, as she rarely eats pizza. We are thrilled that she enjoyed the cheese style pizza so much and we are grateful that Marcos has made a meal that our daughter enjoys. Overall, we are extremely pleased with our experiences at Marcos and we will continue to dine there in the future. Thank you again for providing such a wonderful dining experience. Sincerely, Armstrong“

“Great pizza and calzones. cant say much about the Atmosphere as i dont stay and eat. you can tell they put care into there work. 100% make sure to get there Ranch Dressing will not let you down. Food 10 Service 10 Price 10 'I would have the price at a 8 but cant hate on them inflation fault'“

“The best pizzeria in the area in my opinion. I’m originally from NJ so I’m definitely picky about pizzerias. Everything is fresh and flavorful. My family & I have tried the pizza, wings, crab fries, chicken parm subs, lasagna dinners, & salads and it just seems to get better every time. The staff are always kind & helpful which makes it even better.“

“first time there and we loved it, the cabbage rolls and the house salad dressing are so delicious and the buffalo chicken pizza, super yummy,we will be back for sure!!! thank you for the donuts dessert... 😋😋😋😋😋 ❤️❤️❤️“

“A Slice of Italy Sprinkled with Stardust here in Hagerstown! The food and the soundtrack is Perfetto! The velvety croon of Frank Sinatra wraps around you like a warm blanket. His timeless melodies weave through the clinking of glasses and the happy murmur of conversation, adding a touch of old-world glamour to your meal. You half expect Dean Martin to stroll in any moment, offering a wink and a toast. But the true magic, amici miei, lies in the food. Each dish is a testament to the heart and soul of Italian cooking. And the best part? My wallet barely felt a pinch! The prices are reasonable, the deliciousness won’t break the bank. We will be back again for more.“

“First time eating here, picked up and it was delicious!“

“Newly renovated Olive Garden. Very beautiful inside. I typically stick to the chicken alfredo. The steaks have never been great. The wife loves the soups and the ravioli. I try not to, but I usually eat a large portion of the salad. The breadsticks are one of the few "breads" I do not eat at a restaurant. The fried mozzarella is a great appetizer. Service was what it should be. Food is what you expect. It's a nice, safe bet.“

“We really enjoyed our cheesesteaks. Service and atmosphere, outstanding. French fries were hot and crispy! Cheesesteak, delicious. Will be back to try pizza next week!“

“always excellent food, highly recommend.“

“Every time I would log on to DoorDash, Il Nonno would show as a suggestion based on my past orders. I have to say… I am SO happy that I took a chance and ordered delivery from them.

It is so difficult to find really good New York style pizza in the Washington County area. Il Nonno is the closest that I have found! It tastes great, and the crust is spectacular as well.
As far as the subs- they were just as tasty!
I love the sub rolls that they use. They are perfectly toasted on the outside, and soft and chewy on the inside. Exactly how I like mine!

I am unable to rate/comment on the atmosphere or service, as I have never been to the restaurant in person.
However- from the time that I placed my order, and the order being delivered… it was less than 45 minutes. I assume that service is top notch as well for me to have gotten my order as quickly as I did.

I am beyond pleased with everything that I got from Il Nonno, and I now consider this restaurant my go-to when it comes to ordering pizza and subs!“

“muy buena atencion y los platos exquisitos lo recomiendo“

“Great customer service! Maurice is so kind and accommodating! Food was delicious! It was our first visit, but we will definitely be back!!“

“New to the area and decided to get carry out for Fathers Day Dinner. Food was delicious! We had zucchini fries, a large New York style Pepperoni pizza and Tiramisu.
Can’t wait to try other items on their menu!
Will definitely come back here!“

“We had a great experience today for lunch. There were 12 of us and we were seated almost immediately. The service was excellent. The restaurant was very clean. The food was delicious and the portions were huge. Thanks so much for your Smailes and your hospitality. We drove 4 hours to see family today.“

“great service great food and a great price highly recommend.“

“Finally made it over to this very tasty place for a Sunday afternoon away from the farm to run some errands too. The amount of variety of food is wonderful. Salad, pasta, veggies like green beans and squash as well as the fresh pizza and the dessert apple pizza as well as pudding on the bar too. We enjoyed the fresh very tasty pizza. I loved the squash/zucchini mixture on the buffet it was a nice option in the middle of January. Definitely will be back! For $12.49 per person it was definitely worth the money. Thank you for posting on FB as this is how I discovered this tasty place.“

“It's something about the house Italian dressing and the Antipasto Salad!!! Awesome staff and great food!!! #madewithlove“

“always excellent food, highly recommend.“

“Today was my first time here. The service was awesome! Food was so amazing! I tried everything everyone ordered at the table. The garlic bread with cheese had so much flavor, the pizza was the best we've had yet, bacon cheese fries were out of this world, calzone was so cheesey and the bread oh so good, steak and cheese sub was oh so tasty. The vanilla gelato imported from Italy is a must have. Wow, you could even taste the vanilla bean. Thank you for awesome food, service, and atmosphere!“

“I arrived about 3 pm: There was a guy, who was at the frontline- very nice, who established a direct customer friendly approach with me immediately! He didn’t appear nervous but moved expeditiously in getting my order that waiting carry out, while the female workers- looked a bit perplexed! I’m so glad he appeared from out of no where! He asked me, if I’d been helped- and he knew what do immediately!!“

“When I decide to have an Italian meal, I go to Fratellis. I love the manicotti, but I'm not too sure how long the restaurant will stay open. They are in dire need of help and has Help Wanted sign on door. When I visited couple days ago, July 2, there was only 1 person working.. I'm not sure if he's the owner, but the gentleman was all by himself: cook waiter, cashier, answered phone, probably dishwasher and custodisn. So support restaurant as much as possible. If you know anyone looking for a job, send him/her to Fratelli's.They need the help.

Parking: Plenty of parking including handicap“

“Now let me tell you something. This is the best pizza, better ingredients, better pizza, herbo G. Love it, great service, decent nice staff, good prices good food, small business, lit, activities, cheese good, crust good, vibes good. Alway get pizza and wings for the homies, they also help out the mosque in the area too which is awesome. Aldi is close by, as well which is nice. Good job team thank you“