4 Best American Restaurants in Rangeley

“440pm 9/27/25. We asked to sit on the deck. A lady handed us menus and told us to go seat ourselves. Waited for over 20 minutes for a waitress (of which 2 of them saw us). No one came to greet or serve us. So we left, but not after we handed the menus back to the hostess and explained out situation. She didn't seem too concerned.“

“Thank you Portage Tap House for helping make a very special lady’s birthday dinner a great one! Amazing service, great drinks, and even better food - can’t ask for better! Thank you!“

“I love the new watering hole in Rangeley!! Very upscale and classy. Tapas are excellent and there are many choices offered to share. Cocktails are amazing, especially the Bourbon Sour. The banquets in the back are very cosy. It really is a Corner Bar.“

“Years ago Sarge's was a dive and we'd stay away. We're back in Rangeley for the weekend and gave it a try. So happy we did. The Ruben is out of this world, perfectly toasted and the dressing was super creamy. The coleslaw was perfect too, not too sweet but juicy enough and not overwhelmed by an old cabbage taste. I also tried the French onion soup, it's better than mine, which is hard to beat. We're only here a few days but will definitely go back. Service was friendly, very attentive and we left right at closing and they were still allowing people in. No attitude or mutters. A great turn around from years ago.“