11 Best Italian Restaurants near Allendale

“Good food & service. Reasonable prices“

“Peppinos Express has the best flavor pizza. They have the old school pizza oven, which is why their pizza tastes better than any other Peps in the area. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, too. Highly recommend for those pizza nighy Fridays!“

“There are a lot of pizza places in Allendale. In my opinion, little Caesars and hungry Howies taste like pre-warmed cardboard. We have always had good pizza from Jets and the service has always been good. I would say they’re one of the better fast food pizza places in Allendale.“

“All employees wearing masks. Friendly, good customer service“

“10/10 recommend solely for their customer service. I called in with an odd order (kids with allergies), and not only did the gentleman who took my order handle me with patience, HE told ME he would use a clean pizza cutter to prevent possible allergy contamination before I could ask. The kids with allergies aren’t mine, my kids have no allergies, it’s not second nature for me to ask quickly, and the fact that he took my allergy request so seriously, really spoke volumes. The cherry on top was how eager and willing he was to show me my odd pie when I came to pick up, making sure it was to my liking. The kids loved it and the moving help was successfully fed!“

“Great tasting food, cozy, friendly atmosphere.“

“Unbelievably good, coming from a first time customer. Everything is house made, and it shows in the taste and quality. Built my own pizza with the scratch made sausage, couldn’t have been better. The meatball sub was one of the best, if not best, sandwich I’ve ever had. Meatballs were homemade, fresh, phenomenal bread and house made sauce. I’ve worked in restaurants the past 18 years, I don’t write reviews often, this place made me stop in my tracks. My only complaint… I need one closer to my house! Easiest recommendation I can make, try it all.“

“My wife went back home to visit her family in Michigan for a couple days and while there she went out for dinner with her college friends to celebrate having our first daughter. She was expecting a great night out with her friends however the staff wouldn’t serve her drinks because they “couldn’t verify she was of age” even though she showed them her ID of 24 years of age. This ruined her night out with friends and forced them to go somewhere else to have an enjoyable night out. Very disappointing with how the staff handled this situation.“

“Everything is delicious here-sandwiches, salads, pasta. Unique dishes and so tasty! The manager is great too-always out and about, checking on everyone, helping out. A great experience!“

“OMIGOSH. The best pizza and a community favorite. Their garlic bites are a family favorite; covered with Parmesan cheese and garlic butter, they are scrumptious! The pizza is one of our favorites in West Michigan.Owned by a Jenison Alumni makes it even better. Truly a community staple.No place to eat inside Palermo's, but that doesn't even affect the 5-star eating for us.(Seasonally, there is a delicious ice cream shop next door with tables outside (Frosty Treat; another delicious community staple).)“

“First time trying Marco's. It was a great tasting pizza! Keep up the good work and great pizza. Will definitely be getting again!“