Amy J's Pasty
1000 N Lincoln Dr, Hancock
(906) 482-2253
Customers' Favorites
Veggie Pasty
Steak Pasty
Beef Pasty
Perfect
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I have to constantly fight with myself over who is better amy Jay’s, Krupps, or Lawrys. Each one of them make the pasties different but what makes it so awesome for me is biased because I’m literally two blocks away from this little mom and Pop store. The way they shaved the meat and vegetables and the spices they use in that crust. I absolutely love this place and their bakery their cookies. Oh my God slightly pricey but oh my God my only complain about this...
We stopped at Amy J's late in the day, hoping to grab some pasties for our hungry teens and we were delighted that she had enough for all of us still! The pasties and chocolate chip cookies were delicious. It was the perfect warm, filling treat after a busy day in the UP. Thanks Amy J's!
You May Also Like
Gino’s Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge - 800 Quincy St
![]()
Italian, Cocktail Bar, Vegetarian
The Forge | Food Smith - 787 Market St UNIT 3
![]()
Barbeque, Food Trucks
We make the drive up to the UP from central Wisconsin at least once a year and a stop at Amy J's is a must. The pasties are great but as a certified cookie connoisseur, the cookies are what I care about.