Sadie's Ice Cream Parlor
1891 Cadotte Avenue, Mackinac Island
(906) 847-3331
Customers' Favorites
Whipped Cream & Cherry
Mackinac Island Fudge
Banana Split
Oreo Sundae
Waffle Cone
Menu
Photos
+47 photos
+46 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Sadie‘s ice Cream Parlor was quite the treat. It’s really expensive but everything is on the island. The restaurant is cute. I got the chocolate chip croffle. It is a croissant pressed in a waffle iron. I’ve never heard of it before so it’s definitely unique. The line is always really long, but it moves really fast.
Mackinac island is picturesque and post card perfect and Sadie's ice cream parlour adds to the list. We tried the Root beer float and icre cream hot cake fudge cup (massive portion)
The vanilla ice cream on it was gooey and nice but the overall sprinkles, portion of ice cream to cake was a bit too much! (Can be shared between 3-5 people) Overhyped and over-rated place but good for one time visit to experience the old world ice cream parlour charm.
Root beer...
The vanilla ice cream on it was gooey and nice but the overall sprinkles, portion of ice cream to cake was a bit too much! (Can be shared between 3-5 people) Overhyped and over-rated place but good for one time visit to experience the old world ice cream parlour charm.
Root beer...
Came here in 2025. Had a brownie sundae and a root beer. The sundae and root beer were delicious, but the price ($23) was pure highway robbery. Sadly, that describes just about everything on this tourist trap island. Would come here again, but only on someone else's tab...
You May Also Like
Grand Hotel Main Dining Room -
![]()
Fine Dining, New American, Vegetarian
Grand Coffee and Provisions - 7798 W Bluff Rd
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea