Nancy's
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
142 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-4240
About Nancy's
Nancy's Reviews
The strawberry shake was great. However, the cheeseburgers are just not good. They are the pre-made patties and unappealing. If you're there for ice cream, you'll more than likely be pleased. Save your food money and eat anywhere else.
Wow, outstanding customer service. Kuddos to the two employees tonight. They saw two kiddos that wanted ice cream tonight a half hour after they were closed. Well the gentleman working cleaning and doing closing procedures opened and let the kiddos get their ice cream. Amazing customer service
I spent over $20 buying my grandson and I hot dogs and fries.. I won't go back..
Menu
People in New Buffalo Also Viewed
Nancy's is a must-visit restaurant that serves exceptional food and drinks. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring quick service even when the restaurant is busy. While prices are decent, the unique ice cream flavors are a highlight. The strawberry milkshake is a standout item, with many considering it the best they've ever had. Nancy's is also known for its ice cream, snow cones, and hot dogs, making it a quaint spot in a cool little lake town. There is a cute outdoor eating area with umbrellas for shade. Despite the occasional wait, the line moves quickly, and the atmosphere remains friendly and inviting. Customers enjoyed the Chicago style hotdog, the cheeseburger, chili dog, mozzarella sticks, fried pickles, and strawberry shakes. The food variety is typical fast food hot dog style but pretty good. The chicken sandwich is the best that has ever been had.