4.4
Superb
115 Reviews
3426 East West Maple Road, Commerce · 4.72 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Corned Beef or Pastrami
- Corned Beef Hash
- Matzo Ball Soup
- Chicken Soup
“I have no longer slept on Siegel's Deli. I took my mom there with me today. It does not reach the same heights as Stage does, let's get that out of the way right out front. Now, that might sound like a condemning comment, but I can assure you that it is not. We were very impressed with what we had, and our experience as a whole. My mom got the Elliot (corned beef on rye with cole slaw and Russian dressing with new dill pickles) and I got the Club sandwich. Both of us had water as beverages. That club sandwich I had, while certainly not cheap, was excellent. Very good off-the-bone turkey, crispy/tasty bacon, lots of lettuce and lovely tomato, on correctly toasted bread. The only thing I changed was that I added more mayo because of the sheer *size* of the thing...this sandwich was *HUGE*!!! I ate it all, and I was not just satisfied, but happy with it. As well: they really made this thing look absolutely beautiful on the plate. Impressively so. So they definitely score points here. They *also* score points with that corned beef sandwich, too. All of the elements are there, but none of them are up at the level of Stage. Having said that? This is still a very good second tier corned beef sandwich!!! The Sy Ginsberg corned beef was just as good as the one that I'd made earlier in the week. Very good quality there! The rye bread was good, too. The Russian dressing was pretty good, but lacked a bit of something. The new dill pickles were decent, but definitely not up to the level of Stage's...far too mushy and less crispy. Good, but not great flavor. The cole slaw element is the one that really gets noticed: it's just sort of there...it's not *bad*, but it doesn't really bring anything significant to the table, either. Again: decent second tier corned beef sandwich. There's another thing, though: that decent second tier corned beef sandwich has a *lot* more corned beef on there than you get at Stage, by close to four ounces, I think (Stage does 7 ounces on their Extra Cut, this one is 2/3 of a pound). As well, the sandwich comes in at $17 compared to $22 at Stage. There is a very palpable value statement being made: while the quality is slightly under that of Stage, you do get a *lot* more bang for your buck, and that cannot be overlooked or undervalued. You're getting a heckuva good deal on your corned beef sandwich here, considering that it is, indeed, quite good. Maybe the third best I've had. I am very happy with this give-and-take. We liked the place itself, too: clean, not snobby or trying to be too upscale, but welcoming all the same. The service by all young folks was darned great! We enjoyed every interaction we had with each of them...they're quite kind, and even let me try a bite of chicken salad before I ordered, just in case that's what I might want. It turned out not to be, but what a lovely move by them! Service was extremely good. I can absolutely promise that we (and I, myself) shall be going back there.”