23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Otsego

“We love Sarpino’s pizza and have for more than a decade!“

“Best Pizza in the area! Worth every penny!!!“

“Extremely clean service was friendly and amazing. Definitely recommend the Philly. Because thats what I had. But my sister had a salad and it was amazing as well. I totally rate this top of the chart for a fast affordable spot for a date night.“

“love this place it’s so good“

“The options did not show employees! The employees at the Davanni's in Rogers are stupendous! Always happy, do a great job on my pizza every week!“

“Their smoked chicken wings and pizza are phenomenal, as well as their service!! Can't wait to try their pasta!! We'll definitely be eating here frequently!!“

“I love the pizza. It's not Domino's or pizza hut that most of us are used to. Frank did a lot of research to start the pizzeria. With Alec's help they made it successful. Zac continues to make great pizzas after the passing of Alec two years ago. I recommend everyone to give it a try. yum yu6“

“Love their pizza, but lately it’s been overcooked with blackened crusts. The chicken salad had fresh ingredients, but the chicken itself was extremely dry. The restaurant is always clean and the staff is friendly, which we appreciate. It’s unfortunate they don’t allow reservations for groups of 15, because you would think large groups bringing in business would be welcomed. Booths are rather small and tend to fit 4 people.“

“Great customer service from the time we arrived. The staff kept the buffet well-stocked, and our special order pizza was served promptly, even on a very busy evening. We had two of our grandchildren with us, and they loved it. I highly recommend!“

“Love this store best location around! Friendly staff and great manager! I always need to stop when I’m in town! Very quick and attentive and well organized! I love watching them make our pizza! You know it’s made fresh and baked with love at home <3“

“They even know when my Co workers are trying to order my child's father who passed away Brandon and my favorite pizza there which is thin crust, chicken bacon ranch with the BBQ and ranch mixed together, best pizza ever. I've accidentally ordered it wrong online and they knew it was me and still made it right, this is an excellent pizza. RIP BRANDON JENNINGS PALMER. We will always miss you, but will never forget you and will honor you every way we can, even getting a pizza named after you. ❤️😇💜💕“

“We love Sammy’s pizza over most others. The atmosphere here is sports bar type and is roomy with plenty of seating. Weird access to the parking lot but if you are familiar with it it’s no big deal. The prices are about the same as most places of the same food types, My wife and I ordered the Sammy’s Italian deluxe allegedly with pepperoni and salami, Thinking a peanut butter sandwich has more meat. Was really disappointed in the 15.00 sandwich.The fries were excellent however, the right size and fried perfectly. Our wait staff were fantastic. Next time I will stick to my regular order - pizza.“

“I remember coming here as a little kid and having my birthday parties here every year! We always had a magician come in back then. Think his name was Bob the magician. Very fond core memories of this place!“

“They catered our company event for 2 days; Great food, Great service, Great staff!!!! If you haven't tried it you definitely need to get over there.“

“Jackolatern Pizza is awesome! Our local Papa Murphys is outstanding! Incredibly good pizza for starters, then the service and cleanliness of the store from top to bottom was satisfying. I like being greeted and treated like we are when we go into our local Papa Murphys. 5 stars“

“oh my gosh the most excellent pizza ever.“

“it's bigger than it looks“

“Great staff and great food!“

“We love our Papa John's! We had a DoorDash Delivery mishap after putting in our online order– and their manager Johnny was so kind as to call us, make us fresh food (the delivery time was pushed back by almost 90 minutes!), and sent a free dessert. We are so appreciative and in awe at their incredible customer service!“

“ABSOLUTELY AMAZING FOOD!!! The pizza and cheesy bread were cooked perfectly — hot, crispy, and loaded with flavor! The top photo shows how beautifully everything was prepared right out of the box, and the bottom was after reheating in my oven just because I like my food extra toasted. I’ve always raved about this place, and they continue to impress every single time. For $35 you’re definitely getting top-quality food, and it’s worth every penny. Their customer service is just as great — super friendly and more than willing to help with anything. Couldn’t be happier! Definitely recommend!“

“It had been a while since I last came to this Papa John’s location, but I decided to give them another try recently when I heard they were under new ownership. My experience was far better than the last time I visited.
The pizza was fantastic! The staff were friendly, efficient, and genuinely seemed to enjoy what they do, which really enhanced the overall dining experience.

If you haven’t been to this Papa John’s in a while, it’s definitely worth a visit. The new owners have revitalized the store, and it’s now a great place for both takeout and dining in.“

“This Pizza Hut is inside Target and is part of their front are with other food as well. The pizza is your typical Pizza Hut single serving pizza. Never had a complaint on this pizza and I know what I am getting and it’s accurate each time. The employees are friendly and work hard to get pizza out! Keep up the good work!“