Nellie's Ice Cream

2034 Marshall Ave, St Paul
(651) 447-7072

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lucio Polosa

Biggest ice cream in town

Zachary Billie

Large portions, great variety of flavors. Decent price. I didn't even finish my cone. Definitely recommend

Joe J

Wow! Great flavors and shareable portions. Must visit.

Edward Adams

Amazing

Rebecca

The vegan chocolate and vanilla are delicious! Thank you for having a vegan option that is not sorbet. Open late. Clearly a community hangout. Definitely stop by

Elsie Redman

Huge portions and delicious.

Charlie Figura

Very big servings! Delicious ice cream and cookies. I wish they had some smaller options on the menu, but definitely a winner.

Anne Reichelt

Massive servings

Sam Adams

The ice cream samdwhich was good, but when I say the portions are huge, they are HUGE and also inconsistent. My portion was big enough as is (I love ice cream it's my favorite food and even I was over it the last couple bites), but my partner probably had two pounds of ice cream in between his sandwhich. My cookie was pretty hard, even after heating up, but I can acknowledge we came late in the day. Ice cream was very good and they had a huge selection which I loved once I made my decisions finally.

The most annoying part and the thing that makes me not really want to go back was the two employees working. They both were young, so I get it, but they were so busy play fighting and play yelling at eachother I couldn't wait to leave. I'd never been before so was a little overwhelmed at all my selections and they seemed relieved they could keep hanging out with eachother. They moved quick and didn't really listen well. Plus the two tables inside were dirty and we would have sat inside had it been a better atmosphere. I'm not a "if you can lean you can clean" but at least make sure the tables are clean before you sit around and play with your coworkers..

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Nichole Borowske

Me and a friend came here specifically to try the ice cream sandwiches and they did not disappoint! You get to choose what kind of cookies, ice cream, and toppings you want. I opted for the sprinkle sugar cookies with lemon bar ice cream and caramel on top. It was super delicious and HUGE!

Parking: They do not have a parking lot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwiches

Jeremy Morin

Holy cow the portions they give you here are crazy. It’s amazing, and they have great flavors! The staff was very nice, and offered samples and helped with orders.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Branden Sletteland

Their small isn't small at all. Bring a friend.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Raspberry Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich, Coconut Ice Cream

Merry Rankin

If you need your “spoil yourself” ice cream fix GO here!! AMPLE portions and delicious offerings. Kudos to the professional and customer-focused staff too. It was SO busy when we stopped by, on a Friday night, and the staff was fabulous, composed and welcoming. A must for your bucket list!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Smith

Delicious ice cream and very quick customer service- this was such a fun spot. Portion sizes are HUGE, though- I was surprised by how much ice cream I got for two scoops!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookie Dough, Mint Chip

Drew Essington

Was rudely told outside the shop that "we're ACTUALLY not open" by a soon-to-be Karen. Soon afterwards the same teenage individual was locked out of the shop. What goes around, comes around. Ha.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...