23 Best American Restaurants in Stillwater

Brick & Bourbon American • $$
215 S Main St, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Chicken and Bacon Mac & Cheese
Smoking Gun Maple Old Fashioned
Bourbon & Maple Crème Brulee
New York New York Sliders
St Louis Rib Mac & Cheese
Roasted Short Rib Ravioli
Black & Blue Mac & Cheese
Cast Iron Mac & Cheese
Montamore Hash Browns
Three Wiseman Burger

“Kristin was friendly, attentive, and efficient. Food was delicious and arrived faster than I would have expected.“

4.8 Superb919 Reviews
Howard's Bar American • $
302 S Main St, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Howard Burger and Fries
Cheeseburger and Fries
Prime Rib Bennie
Reuben Sandwich
Chicken Wings
French Toast
Cheese Curds
Lasagna
Salad

“We had been to this place when it was called Whiteys several times, but this was our first visit since the change in ownership.

First thing I noticed was they kept the fresh squeezed juice... YAY!!!! I enjoy a variety of cocktails, but a screwdriver with fresh OJ is near the top of my list. So big thanks for that.

I was perusing the menu and it didn't take long for me to notice the lasagna w/side salad. I am a lasagna hound and snob, and have tried it at many establishments over the years. This offering was outstanding, perhaps my favorite (not made by my wife, of course).

We will be back.

P. S. we used to boat on the river and visited Stillwater a lot, but not since COVID. Howard's has been on our radar for a while. Hearing more about it at the Wits Reunion show at the Fitzgerald motivated us to get it done.“

4.6 Superb110 Reviews
Leo's Grill & Malt Shop American • $
131 S Main St, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Double Cheeseburger with Waffle Fries
Grilled Cajun Chicken Sandwich
Classic Banana Split
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Sweet Potato Tots
Brownie Sundae
Chocolate Malts
Cowboy Chicken
Malts & Shakes
Turtle Sundae

“Lisa G., Janae was our waitress, too. We were the “3-J’s”: Joe, Junna, and Janae. Janae was swift, attentive, beautiful, and cheerful. She was always right there to refill my water glass. I wonder if she ran track in high school; she was fast!“

4.6 Superb179 Reviews
Mad Capper Saloon & Eatery American • $$
224 S Main St, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Sandwich
Parmesan Truffle Fries
Reuben or Rachel Melt
Ricotta Bruschetta
Stillwater Burger
Southwest Salad
Benedict Burger
Italian Nachos
Fish and Chips
Chicken Wings

“Best meal! We by chance stopped in for supper and a drink this past Friday night and were impressed by what great food we all had. 5 of us ordering different items and all were meals were so fresh and delicious! And service was outstanding! We would definitely recommend the Mad Capper to anyone who is visiting Stillwater!“

4.5 Superb196 Reviews
LoLo American Kitchen and Craft Bar American • $$
233 S Main St, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Alderwood Smoked Sea Salt & Rosemary Fries
Korean Fried Chicken Wings
Bacon Wrapped Hot Dogs
Fried Brussels Sprouts
Smoked Sea Salt Fries
Seared Amish Chicken
Triple Pork Tacos
Mahi Fish Tacos
Chicken Tacos
Korean Tacos

“FABULOUS! My husband and I rarely try new places but this time we decided to go out of the norm. Cannot say enough great things. We sat at the bar and Timmy took care of us. Chef’s kiss 😘 We will be back!“

4.5 Superb153 Reviews
Matchstick Restaurant & Spirits American • $$
232 N, 232 Main St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Wagyu Beef from Snake River Farms Cast Iron Seared Demi-Glace
Matchstick Rotating Whiskey Old Fashioned
Caramelized Brussel Sprouts
Smoked Chicken Wings
Cauliflower Fritters
Smoked Half Chicken
Sea Bass Fish Tacos
Wood Fired Carrots
Grilled Sea Bass
Brisket Philly

“Every single dish we had was phenomenal! We gave compliments to the chef on truly inspired creations. Our favorite may have been the Brussels sprouts, but we truly loved everything we tried. The service was great - friendly, quick, knowledgeable. Thank you to the whole team for making our 20th Anniversary celebration so wonderful.“

4.4 Superb240 Reviews
7

Feller

Feller American • $$
402 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Foragers Crostini
Walleye Fritters
Brussels Sprouts
Feller Burger
Smoked Wings
Bison Steak
The Feller
Stillwater
Carrots

“Trout Benedict was amazing. Farm fresh eggs with golden yolks. Trout patty crisp on the outside. Homemade Hollandaise. Perfection.“

4.2 Good96 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
1725 Market Dr, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Bucket of Carbonated Caffeine Drink
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Double Cheeseburger
Butterburger
Cod Sandwich
Hot Fudge
Baskets
Soup

“I’m enthusiastic to report that this Culvers was amazing! The food was absolutely divine! There were a decent amount of food options available! The staff was amicable and so delightful! The wait time was not terribly long. (Although past times I’ve been here, the wait has been long. The drive through typically takes a while😅) There was plenty of seating options available and the place was kept fairly clean! My dining experience at Culver’s was top notch! I will definitely be coming back to this Culver’s on a regular basis!I totally recommend coming here! There was also a lot of parking!“

3.9 Good133 Reviews
The Main Cafe Cafe • $
108 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Triple Berry French Toast with Scrambled Eggs and Bacon
Country Fried Steak and Eggs Hashbrowns and Pancake
Hamburger and Fries
Blueberry Pancakes
Two French Toast
Farmers Omelet
Eggs Benedict
Cheese Omelet
Denver Omelet
Hash Browns

“great service, food was ready quickly, and the food was delicious. price point was definitely good as well.“

4.6 Superb119 Reviews
Freight House American • $$
305 Water St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Giant Bavarian Pretzel with Pepperjack Cheese Sauce
Wisconsin Beer Battered Cheese Curds
Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich
The Freight House Cheeseburger
Parmesan Truffle Fries
Freight House Burger
Pulled Chicken Nachos
Wings or Tenders
Walleye Sandwich
Fish and Chips

“The Freight House is enough of an experience in itself to make the food sort of play second fiddle. It's all good and quite value priced. Super kid and whole gang friendly, pets welcome on the large patio. Staff friendly and accommodating. Try the Chicken Wild Rice soup. It's the best in the city.“

3.8 Good162 Reviews
Domaćin Restaurant & Wine Bar New American • $$$
102 2nd St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Beef Tenderloin Right and Risotto Left
Margherita Flatbread
Castelvetrano Olives
Meat and Cheese Plate
Wine Lovers' Plate
Wine Cheese Plate
Shrimp and Grits
Cheese Board
Duck Breast
Panna Cotta

“One of the best restaurants on the east side of the twin cities, if you love wine with awesome food,this owner along with the staff, which is key, know how to serve the two together to have an unforgettable dinner. The wine shop has some phenomenal choices of wines you will not find anywhere else. Stillwater’s Domacin is a destination ❤️🍷🥂❤️“

4.7 Superb105 Reviews
Phil's Tara Hideaway Bar • $$$
15021 60th St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Brussels Sprouts with Balsamic Reduction
Seared Duck with Potato Gnocchi
Mediterranean Pork Chop
Tara Steak Gorgonzola
Kids Chicken Fingers
Fettuccine Alfredo
Athenian Potatoes
Soup of the Day
Grilled Octopus
Greek Platter

“Why have we waited so long to come back here?! Food and service were impeccable. If you are craving some awesome Greek food and a cozy environment, Phil’s Tara Hideaway is the spot. We will be back very soon!“

4.6 Superb165 Reviews
Ziggy's On Main, Live Music, Great Food & Drink Sports Bar • $
132 S Main St, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Cheese
Cheese Curds
Chicken Wings
Steak Bites
Nachos

“The best burger I ever had! I wanted the jalapeño but wasn’t sure about putting the waitress said yes but gave it to me on the side by the time I was done that jam was all over my burger. I highly recommend this place“

4.6 Superb98 Reviews
Meister's Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
901 4th St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
French Fries Half Order
Fries and Mushroompuffs
Sauerkraut or Coleslaw
21 Popcorn Shrimp
Basket of Fries
Miester Burger
Steak Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Cheese Curds

“Great food, super staff and fun place!“

4.6 Superb86 Reviews
Sal's Angus Grill Bar & Grill • $$
12010 Keystone Ave N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Petite Medallions with Baked Potato and Green Beans
Kids Chicken Strips with Fries and a Treat
Chicken Fettuccine with Bread Stick
Prime Rib Loaded Baked Potato
Bacon Cheeseburger with Fries
Bacon Cheese Burger and Fries
Sweet and Sour Chicken Wings
Salmon with Mashed Potatoes
Sal's Spaghetti & Meatballs
Stuffed Chicken Breast

“We came to Stillwater for a nighttime get away and stumbled upon Sal’s. We were seated immediately, greeted by our waitress, Penny with a smile and great conversation! The menus had great variety and was delicious! This place is worth the trip for us and we WILL be back! Thanks Penny for your awesome service that made our visit that much better!“

4.4 Superb132 Reviews
Danny's Kitchen + Bar American • $$
13600 N Hudson Blvd, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Beef and Bleu Cheese Fettuccine
Cheeseburger

“Very pleased with Danny’s. Have heard about it for years and finally tried it. Excellent food! Music outside every third Saturday. Great views of Stoneridge golf course.“

4.2 Good113 Reviews
Cozzie's Tavern & Grill Bar • $$
11154 60th St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Brussels Sprouts
Chicken Wings 12 Piece
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Apple Walnut Salad
Classic Patty Melt
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pot Roast Sliders
Burgers and Fries
Chicken Pot Pie
Walleye Fingers

“Stopped on a Thursday afternoon to see PT on the patio. The female singer performing was amazing. My wife and I had a couple happy hour apps including wings, nachos and cheese burger sliders. Everything was awesome! Only got a pic of the wings tho. We love this bar and look forward to returning again and again!“

4.2 Good123 Reviews
Brian's Bar & Grill Bar • $
219 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Double Half Pound Burger
Burger Wings and a Salad
Wings Cheese Bread
Stillwater Burger
Mushroom & Swiss
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Chicken Tacos
Cheeseburger
Tater Tots

“Let's not let minors drink and then boot them out at closing time without knowing if they are getting home safe.“

4.1 Good87 Reviews
The Tilted Tiki Tropical Bar & Restaurant Cocktail Bar • $$
324 Main St S, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Tropical Pineapple Beyond Burger
Tropical Pineapple Cheeseburger
Beyond Beeft Tilted Tacos
Tropical Tiki Tofu Kabobs
Friki Tiki Cheese Curds
Kahuru Coconut Shrimp
Coconut Shrimp Tacos
Pineapple Fried Rice
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Tilted Spam Sliders

“Great service. loved the music by The Mockingbirds! We will be back in July when they play again! Thank you!“

4.1 Good141 Reviews
Joseph's Family Restaurant Family • $
14608 60th St N, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Beer Batter Walleye Sandwich
All American Egg Breakfast
Quarter Pound Hamburger
Buttermilk Pancakes
Lumberjack Burger
Reuben Sandwich
Broasted Chicken
Rhubarb Delight
Steak and Eggs
Glass of Wine

“Good food and quiet. No loud music. Good pie. Good service too.“

4 Good159 Reviews
Perkins Restaurant & Bakery Bakery • $
2050 W Frontage Rd, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Big Country Sunrise Skillet
Country Fried Steak
Breakfast Potatoes
Skillet Breakfast
Garden Salad
Onion Rings
French Toast
Hash Browns
Patty Melt
Blueberry

“The hostess brought us right back to a booth and our server, Thuy was right there to offer coffee and water. Her attention, smile and service was amazing. Time from walking in the door to hot, good food on the table was about 20 minutes. We’re so happy we left Keys cafe down the road where we were pointed to a booth to sit in and then ignored for 15 minutes; no greeting of “I’ll be right with you” or anything for 15 minutes with several servers in the section.“

3.9 Good117 Reviews
No Neck Tony's Bar • $
231 Myrtle St E, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Tito's on Tap & Fresh Squeezed Margarita
Loaded Bloody Mary
Heggies Pizza

“We had a fantastic time at No Neck Tony’s! I reached out to Jessica, the manager, to see if they could recreate my wedding’s signature cocktail as a surprise for my husband while we celebrated our 10-year anniversary. She was incredibly kind and even went out of her way to buy an ingredient they didn’t have on hand. The other cocktails were also excellent and the Halloween decor truly stole the show! If you're a Halloween lover like me, this place is an absolute must in October!“

3.8 Good86 Reviews
Portside Gastropubs • $$
317 Main St S, Stillwater

“Love Portside! Had our wedding reception there and everyone was wonderful. Perfect atmosphere. Even better when the night club kicked off. Those bartenders/bar back work their butts off! Cameron is a gem 💎 I might be biased. 🥰“

3.1 Average67 Reviews

You May Also Like