Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon
$ • Pizza
Hours:
2007 State Hwy K, O'Fallon
(636) 272-2223
About Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon
Customers' Favorites
Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon Reviews
Share your opinion about Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon
Every time we order the pizza is absolutely perfect. I feel like I’m so close to Chicago I can see Wrigley Field out my windows … Tonight’s pizza (Original) was out of this world Puuuurrrfffeeeccttt !
We get Nancy’s often, but tonight was special. We got a thin crust and an original stuffed Chicago-style deep dish. The crusts and toppings were absolutely perfect!!! My husband is from Chicago and this reminded him of home! We HIGHLY recommend!
There is a lady that works there and does an Amazing job I believe her name is Kari.
She is a very hard and awesome woman.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in O'Fallon Also Viewed
Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon offers authentic Chicago-style pizza, with many customers describing it as the closest they can get without visiting Chicago. Visitors often plan a wait of around 30 minutes, which is considered a sign of genuine Chicago pizza quality. The deep dish is highly praised, with one customer mentioning it as the best they've had, even better than some in Chicago itself. The restaurant’s small space makes waiting a bit inconvenient, but the delicious pizza more than makes up for it.
Several reviews highlight the friendly and helpful staff, especially noting an employee who prepared the best pizza and provided excellent service. The owner is appreciated for going above and beyond, even making food for a company lunch when they were not open, and offering discounts during holidays, making the experience even more enjoyable. The pricing is considered reasonable, with a large group able to enjoy quality pizza at a great price.
There are some issues with website coupons and discounts, leading to frustration for some customers. However, the staff has shown willingness to resolve problems and improve the experience. Overall, Nancy's Pizza O'Fallon is praised for its authentic Chicago deep dish pizza, friendly staff, and good value, making it a popular choice for pizza lovers craving true Chicago-style pies.