Cole's Hearth Room
$$$ • American
Hours:
3749 Hwy Bb, Palmyra
(573) 773-2056
About Cole's Hearth Room
Customers' Favorites
Cole's Hearth Room Reviews
Share your opinion about Cole's Hearth Room
My husband and I are on an anniversary trip from Iowa, so this was our first time to Cole's, and we had Kristy B as our waitress. She was absolutely WONDERFUL! So fun to talk to and laugh with and made our time there such an amazing experience. And the food was to die for. I had the chicken, my husband the steak. I would honestly drive the 3 hours back just for this restaurant. It was truly one of a kind all the way around. (Thanks again, Kristy, you rock!)
If you know me, you know I LOVE my food, I love to cook, and im pretty darn good at it. So for my birthday, Stacie Brooks Armstrong took me to Cole's Hearth Room in Palmyra. I had no idea this place existed until a few weeks ago. All I can say is WOW....from the cocktails to desert everything was incredibly on point! Ive never had anyone make a better creme brulee than mine, until tonight! Superbly impressed! Thank you so much Stacie for a great evening!
We had the most amazing time tonight, celebrating our Anniversary. Our waitress was Kristy and she was a hoot! She had us laughing so hard we were crying. It was an amazing meal as always! Thank you Kristy for being you and reading our table the way you did, it made our experience at Cole’s the BEST we’ve ever had!!!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 5 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 5 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 5 - 9PM |
| Friday | 5 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 10PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in Palmyra Also Viewed
Cole's Hearth Room offers an exceptional dining experience with flavorful pork belly appetizers, perfectly cooked steaks, and a great selection of cocktails. The cozy restaurant is located inside an unassuming building, but its lively atmosphere makes it a charming spot to dine. Visitors praise the smoked old fashioned for its smoothness and the toasted ravioli as a very good appetizer. The seafood scampi has been described as the best pasta dish ever, and the lemon raspberry cheesecake provides a perfect ending. Many guests find the service attentive and the environment welcoming, making it a favorite spot for a memorable meal. The restaurant is highly recommended for those seeking quality food and a warm, lively atmosphere.
The restaurant has recently received positive reviews, with customers describing the ambiance as beautiful and the service as friendly and attentive. The cocktails are praised as tasty and creative, and the wine list is respectable. The steaks, including the Surf and Turf filet and the Urban Cowboy, are noted for their great flavor and tenderness. The truffle frites, in particular, are described as the best fries the customers have ever had. Overall, the restaurant is recommended for those seeking an elegant setting, exceptional pasta, and a memorable dining experience.