McAllister Inn
$$ • Bars, Vegan, VegetarianAbout McAllister Inn
McAllister Inn Reviews
200 ratings
Share your opinion about McAllister Inn
Knew we were getting in late called ahead and they were able to email me the door code which was super helpful. Room was clean, bed was comfortable, picnic table out back with a spot to hang waders and put boots. Had laundry, no vending at this time which is fine. Great little spot, definitely would stay here again on my next trip through the area.
We were just passing through but stayed here for a night and it was a cozy and clean room. Seemless check in. Would stay here again!
Nice place to stay, quiet and clean. The room also has a door to a patio so you can enjoy your morning coffee. It is just down the road to the lake. It also has laundry facilities. The only drawback was the check-in was contactless, however I never received the email with my room number and door code. Instructions on the office door said to text or call. The text went unanswered. When I called, it went to voicemail. They have a secondary number to the Sportsman Lodge, the sister...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
| Sunday | 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM |
McAllister Inn offers a welcoming and clean environment with a small-town feel, close to Yellowstone National Park. Guests appreciate the spacious rooms featuring high wood ceilings, a larger refrigerator, microwave, and thoughtful space for bags, clothes, and towels. While the rooms are comfortable and recently upgraded, some visitors noted that the freezer in the fridge was not functional, which was disappointing for those needing to freeze gel packs. The inn has a remote key system that may remind visitors of Bates Motel at dusk, but the rooms are pleasant and well-designed. Guests enjoy sitting on the covered patio, especially during rainy weather, and find the place conveniently situated with no nearby food options, so bringing breakfast or other supplies is recommended.
The inn’s restaurant, McAllister Inn & Steakhouse, is highly praised for its delicious food, friendly service, and good value. Highlights include a filet mignon that is flavorful and tender, chicken wings tossed in bourbon bacon sauce, and a meatloaf that many find exceptional, full of wonderful flavors and texture. The wine selection, curated by the owner, is well-liked, and the bar offers tempting drinks like the huckleberry martini. The steakhouse also features popular dishes such as fried green beans and tenderloin cooked medium, which guests describe as juicy and easy to cut. Visitors look forward to trying the burnt ends on future visits.
Overall, McAllister Inn provides a clean, comfortable stay with a charming atmosphere and a restaurant that impresses with its quality food and friendly staff. It's a great choice for travelers seeking a cozy place near Yellowstone, with some minor amenities improvements suggested, like a functional freezer and more nearby food options.