5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Rothesay

“Vitos Rothesay for the win! My dinner never came cheap! but that was exactly what I was shooting for :) for a whopping $110.00 I and my partner in crime, have had enough food to eat at the restaurant, just ate more and there's enough again to feed us tomorrow.....I almost feel like we ripped them off. It was just how I remembered having it years ago from the uptown location, Peter and Nick would sit in the table in the corner, my son and I would visit every time we were in town. We ate the same thing, (spinach lasagne) which is a hidden gem on the menu, and they sat in the same spot. You could tell those guys were proud of their recipes, and they would often offer us a dessert on the house. Fond memories of that place, those people and that food brings me back every time :) Vitos is one of those nostalgic moment places where every bite brings you back to "how is used to be" and I'm so thankful they are still here, still serving up some of the best food New Brunswick has to offer, and the service is always top-notch ❤ I'm glad we spent the money we did and had the experience we wanted ❤ thank you to the family at Vitos, you guys still have it, and your families recipes will always feed the hunger of many souls in NB. Thank you 💞“

“We stumbled upon Pomodori Pizza while exploring Rothesay a few days ago and it turned out to be a real highlight of our trip. My husband ordered the margherita and said it was one of the best he'd had in years, with a proper thin crust and fresh basil. The staff were so friendly and welcoming, making us feel right at home even though we were just passing through. If you're visiting the Isle of Bute, do yourself a favour and make time for lunch here - you won't regret it.“

“I have been trying to find a good pizza place since I moved here a couple months ago. Pizza Shack is the 6th place I have tried and I finally found my place. It was delicious, hot, loaded with toppings and cheese. My search is over and will be a regular at this place.“

“New menu is great! This is our second visit - first time was with the old menu and we weren't huge fans, but we will definitely be back to test more from the new menu.“

“I unfortunately did not catch her name, but the young lady working on Sunday, Oct 5 at about 2pm is an absolute STAR! 🌟 I was celebrating a very special day and she could not have been more friendly and congratulatory. An absolute gem of an employee and ambassador for Papa John’s Pizza! And the pizza was just as awesome as I hoped for as well, including the extra garlic dipping sauces and pepperoncinis! Thank you SO much, this location is the standard & should be very proud!“