Fentoni's Pizza
$ • Pizza, ItalianAbout Fentoni's Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Cheesesteak with Onions and Peppers
Pepperoni Pizza in Cardboard Box
NY Pizza and Garlic Knots
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
NY Cheese Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Calzone
Fentoni's Pizza Reviews
241 ratings
Share your opinion about Fentoni's Pizza
Ordered two pizzas to go while in town on vacation - Tuesday night.
Food was ready approximately 15-20 minutes after ordering - so it was super fast at dinner time.
Both pizzas were good and the NY style slices were plenty for 5 adults + 2 kids - we even had pieces leftover.
We'd order from here again if we are visiting another time.
Food was ready approximately 15-20 minutes after ordering - so it was super fast at dinner time.
Both pizzas were good and the NY style slices were plenty for 5 adults + 2 kids - we even had pieces leftover.
We'd order from here again if we are visiting another time.
The pizza was delicious! The staff was friendly and the portions are huge!
Eat there twice in a week , there pepperoni pizza was really good, Friday night an Saturday night, expect to wait, but it's worth the wait .
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
Fentoni's Pizza in Carolina Beach is a popular restaurant known for its friendly service and delicious food. They are famous for their authentic NY-style Neapolitan pizza, made with top-quality flour and tomatoes, giving it a great taste. The pizza has a crisp crust with tasty, meaty, and cheesy toppings. The large pizzas are generously sized and a good value. The restaurant is located near the boardwalk, with wheelchair accessibility via a ramp at the front, although the signage could be clearer.
Customers say the pizza is the "best they've ever had." The menu includes cheese, pepperoni, Buffalo chicken, and Hawaiian pizzas, all enjoyed by guests. The garlic knots are highly recommended, with a perfect crust and homemade-tasting ranch. The wings are also praised for their amazing flavor and extra sauce. Many note that the pizza is very much like genuine NYC pizza, with a crispy crust that has a good bite and flavorful sauce and toppings. Slices are affordable, costing less than $5.
The restaurant also features a large flat-screen TV playing cartoon movies, especially entertaining for kids. The staff is friendly and helpful. Some customers mentioned that the table cleaning could be improved between guests, but overall, they have a positive experience at Fentoni's Pizza. A suggestion from visitors is to add a Margarita pizza to the menu.