17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carolina Beach

“As a native New Yorker that's lived in North Carolina for the last 6 years I'm overjoyed to have found Fentoni's Pizza!
Tim (the owner) is also a native New Yorker, & certainly knows what he's doing!
THE BEST (NOT IN N.Y.) PIZZA IVE EATEN HERE!!!
Thank you!“

“The pizza needs more sauce! It’s dry! Crispy is one thing but don’t like dry. I’m Italian ! So we ordered a side of sauce . Got less than a quarter cup n was charged. Come on ! N yes we are local with a rental n our rentals ask us for recommendations.“

“we ordered a large pie garlic knots and salad and were very pleased. the garlic knots are massive and the pizza was full of flavor. one of the only places in ten days of eating out that has fresh greens in the salad so props for that“

“I want to shoutout to the crew on the night of 5/2/2026. For those of us who have once worked in service jobs or continue to. We know first hand what Saturday nights are like.

We arrived from a 6 hour drive and nothing was open so we landed on dominoes. Sure enough we wait and get our order and it was actually the wrong order (by mistake, we are at a hotel there is multiple people placing orders, genuine mishap that could happen to anyone) I called to let them know, and the individual on the phone called the driver, they all connected realized what happened, and they launched into problem solving. Fired up the order and delivered.

We couldn’t just give the order back and unfortunately we were not going to eat the order because it was just not compatible with our party. We went to the front desk and asked them if anyone was hungry on the team and handed over the food.

Shortly after the food shows up, hot, ready.

This is how customers service is done. No one in life is perfect 100% of the time, but when something goes wrong owning it and correcting it, is the right way.

Not only was it the right way, but everyone involved was kind. I know the cooks in the pizza line were probably like ‘why are we repeating this’ but as someone who understands how life works and that businesses do not have to do this but when they do it makes you appreciate them.

This is a shoutout and just an appreciation for the Saturday staff when literally no other businesses are opened and their handling the hunger needs of the people.

Ps I only have photos of the wrong order because our party pretty much inhaled our order upon arrival lol“

“Vinny’s is our go to for pizza on the island. Kori and her team are always on point!“

“This is the best Pizza joint in Wilmington hands down. They use the best Italian ingredients, their cheeses are delicious. The meats are so flavorful. This pizza tastes different than all the other pizzas in town. You can actually taste the quality. The staff are wonderful. So kind and helpful, they know us by name!!!! Love this place! It’s my “go to” for pizza! Try it you’ll like it, take a tip from me!!!! Tootles!!!!!“

“My Absolute favorite place for lunch or dinner! They have the best staff and the food is consistently phenomenal! I am super picky and they have the BEST cheese & pineapple pizza with ranch!“

“I have tried the pizza, pasta, & subs. They were all great! The desserts are awesome too.“

“Great food, customer service and clean environment.“

“The staff are always very friendly and helpful. The items used to make their pizzas are fresh and the restaurant is clean and well maintained. The pizzas are always made to perfection and taste delicious when baked!

Vegetarian options: They do have a wonderful variety of veggies so anyone could always make a veggie pizza of their choice.“

“Michaelangelo’s is a fan favorite at our house when it comes to pizza.🍕 The dough tastes amazing and is coupled with their fresh ingredients. Friendly staff make the experience wonderful whether you’re eating a slice at the restaurant or grabbing pizza to go home.“

“Absolutely love their pickle pizza (Dee’s pickle pizza) and their lasagna! I’ve never been disappointed with any of their pizzas!“

“The pizza is good but the Nachos are really good. This place is one of the only places I've ever been that layers the nachos. They use two types of cheese and the toppings are plentiful. We get the veggie nachos and add chicken. 1 order is more then enough for two people and will keep you picking for an hour. Great game day choice.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“This was a cool experience, the pizza chef talked to my son and he loved it while we waited. Food was fresh and very tasty. All the flavors were there. Unlike some Domino's, this location is doing it right. While we were on a weekend away, and I didn't take pictures, we ordered 2 pizzas, 5 Mac And cheese, 2 orders of wings, and the lava's. It was all very flavorful. And you can't get that everywhere. When we come back here, we will be eating Domino's from this location again! And all the staff and pizza chefs were very kind, and full of energy. Positive energy. That's what went into my food and I appreciate it.“

“It was 1230 a m when I ordered on the app and the food was cooked as if it were there first order of the day . You can tell when someone cares about there job weather it's shoveling poop or making pizzas they did it to the best of their ability. The pertty lady cooking and working the counter was nice fast and on point not to mention pizza garlic and cinnamon twist were excellent good job momma!!! ??

Parking: Up front easy cheesy right off college Rd easily accessible from road in and out

Wheelchair accessibility: Parking right in front of door“

“Outstanding service, outstanding pizza, outstanding manager John. My absolute favorite Papa Johns.“