19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Surf City

“The new manager, Brandi, is excited about new changes being made! I ordered the Land Lover's Pizza and added tomatoes. The ingredients were so fresh that the flavors really popped!!! I would have preferred the sausage thinner sliced, but who can please everyone ??. This was my first time there, and it won't be my last! Really can't wait to try the new dessert pies they are creating. Sorry I didn't catch the young man's name who made the pie! Great job!!! By the way, I'm not a pizza fan at heart, but I might change my mind.“

“My family and I (6 total) were on Vacation and went here for dinner Thursday Night 10/17/24. We had the sweetest waitress- young brunette girl who we loved!! She was very attentive to our needs, and we absolutely loved that she would joke around with us- had us laughing!! The entire staff was great!! Would 100% recommend this place!!“

“We’ve been here before and usually have had a good experience. We didn’t have a bad experience today but our server Reese did mess up what we originally ordered. I had ordered an Italian sub and asked for a small; hubby got a large. Hubby got his large sub and I too received a large. I didn’t wanna make a fuss and return it. We ordered chicken tenders after we had already placed our original order, my husband pointed to the chicken tenders underneath “appetizer” and we received a child’s chicken tenders with two chicken strips and french fries instead. I had already ordered French fries with our original order and then decided afterward I wanted just an order of chicken tenders for my one year old. Normally wouldn’t make a big deal out of things like this but Reese had already made a mistake by giving me a large Italian sub when I wanted a small and then gave me an order of child’s chicken tenders after we requested just chicken tenders from appetizer section. And Reese did ask if we wanted the chicken tenders removed when husband brought it up and he did apologize for the misunderstanding. We ended up paying for something we didn’t ask for and that’s a bit frustrating. Other than that, food is good and the service is always great here. We do enjoy Max’s pizza!“

“Excellent NY-style Pizza! My extended family and I ordered 2 large "classic" style pizzas to-go recently (1 cheese, 1 pepperoni). It was the best NY-style pizza that I have had in NC. The foldable crust was crisp with great chew. The sauce was flavorful and NOT sweet. There was a good amount of cheese. We were born and raised in Manhattan (NYC) and really enjoyed the pizzas from Michaelangelo's - highly recommend! Also, the workers were very nice and friendly.“

“I like to give positive reviews of small restaurants but can only share my experience. Just left without getting my order. We ordered a pizza bread, garlic knots and a calzone. My wife got her pizza bread (which was burnt) pretty quick then came the garlic knots. 4 other orders came to people that came in after us so my wife asked an employee walking by. She said she'd check but never came back to let us know anything. My wife finished eating (she eats slow) and we were tired of waiting so she got a refund for the calzone and I got ice cream down the street for dinner. it's also extremely hot inside the restaurant, ac must be broken.“

“We LOVE this place !!

You've got to try the famous Three Pigs Pizza made with local BBQ Pulked Pork, locally made BBQ sauce, Bacon & Ham .... it's a mouth FULL of deliciousness !!

I also love spinach, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella.

Lunch specials are GREAT !!

Awesome beer selections too !!

Please tell Adam or Tiffany I sent you :)

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“We ordered takeout while on vacation. The food was great and the staff were very friendly.
Our order was ready within 15 minutes of calling.

It may seem pricey, but it is worth it for the quality of ingredients you are getting. I also thought the serving size of each pizza was appropriate for the price we paid.

If you are in the mood for some pizza I recommend giving them a call!“

“Only place we order pizza from. If you're one of the many transplants from the north (like me) this pizza is comparable. I know that's a bold statement, but the guy who owns the place is from Brooklyn, he knows what he's doing.“

“Kayla was awesome!!! We were literally moving in to our new home in Snead’s Ferry and she delivered to us. She was quick, professional and SO friendly! She welcomed us to Snead’s Ferry with the biggest smile!! Papa John’s is lucky to have her!! Thanks Kayla!! Pizza was great too lol“

“Best pizza outside of Long Island! Staff prompt and friendly. The fried calamari melts in your mouth.“

“I like that it's cost affordable, and it has the right amount of space and the cheese melts perfectly..“

“I like that it's cost affordable, and it has the right amount of space and the cheese melts perfectly..“

“We’ve had food delivered several times. Food is always hot and fresh. Delivery is quick.“

“i have called for delivery of pizza and more ,, first of all ..the people who answered the phones are RUDE!!! ,MORONS..it took15 minutes to place a order with them on the phone because the loser idiots had no idea wht they are doing ..it was just duh ,duh,huh,wht,uuumm,hole please, and wht would u like ...just PLAIN IDOTS!!!..I HAVE CALLED 10 TIMES SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THE YEAR TOO ORDER PIZZA AND other things and each time is the same of wht i said in the beginning!!! ..THIS WILL BE THE LAST TIME I WILL EVER ORDER FROM THIS LOCATION!!!!!!“

“Resilient staff, fast food, and makes the whole family happy. Awesome to have from time to time.“

“We ordered the Stromboli to go and it was delicious. Highly recommend for take out!“

“We stopped here for a quiet family dinner and it was amazing. Service was wonderful and food was delicious.“

“This place goes above and beyond when it comes to customer service. We were staying at the beach last week out of town and had dinner here on our last day. My 13 year old son lost his wallet, come to find out it was left here. They went out of their way to contact me and MAIL me my sons wallet with all of his money in it. Thanks!!!!“