NYC Bagels

$ • Bagels, Coffee Shops

Menu Order Online

About NYC Bagels

NYC Bagels offers a variety of freshly baked bagels, including everything, blueberry, and chocolate chip. Their bagels are served with a generous smear of cream cheese. Menu items include bagel sandwiches, such as a bacon, egg, and cheese option, and a lunch menu featuring the Hungryman, which is massive and keeps customers full for hours. The counter service is fast and friendly. Customers praise the bagels for their perfect crisp outside and soft, chewy inside, reminiscent of real New York–style bagels. The bagels also have great texture, a good chew, and generous toppings, and they keep well for weekend treats or freezing. The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese is highly recommended. The staff is attentive, often going the extra mile, like calling to suggest alternative breads if an item is out of stock. The bagels are consistently described as incredible, with some saying they are the best around since moving from Philadelphia and New Jersey. The crumbcake is also noted as being just like home. Delivery orders come with plenty of cream cheese. Service is spot on, quick, and friendly, with no nonsense and no frills. The coffee provides a good jolt for the morning. While the bagels may be slightly smaller than those from New York, the taste and quality make up for the difference. The seating is limited, and the place can get packed.