19 Best American Restaurants in Fayetteville

“1st time here and it was great! We had the crispy chicken fries, and drink x2 =$20 chicken sandwich nice and crispy and big. Fries were shoestring fries( may favorite) Afterwards had a nice thick strawberry shake! Service was amazing and as it got busier they made sure they had help taking orders! No long lunes at all. will definitely be back soos,to try the burgers!“

“If you find yourself in Fayetteville or stationed nearby, you absolutely need to stop by Gollabs—this hidden gem is a burger lover's paradise! From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a lively atmosphere that perfectly balances bustling energy and cozy comfort. It's the kind of place that makes you feel right at home, whether you're kicking back with friends or grabbing a bite with your fellow troops.

Now, let's talk about the burgers—oh, the burgers! Each one is a masterpiece crafted with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor. The Gollabs Carolina burger and sweet Swiss burgers are a must-try, Their crispy, hand-cut fries are the perfect companion, and trust me when I say you’ll want to order an extra portion for sharing (or not!).

What truly sets Gollabs apart is the customer service. The staff is not just friendly; they’re genuinely enthusiastic about making your experience the best it can be. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular, they treat you like family, always ready with recommendations and a smile.“

“Excellent food and service around 12:30 yesterday! We had a flounder/shrimp platter with fried okra, a porkchop plate with white rice, fried okra, a mushroom Swiss burger with fries and a salad and a chicken fried steak plate with double mashed potatoes and fried okra. The only complaint was the white rice. It was definitely instant rice. That's never appetizing. We're Filipino and know good rice. This wasn't it.“

“I’ve dined at Blue Moon a half-dozen times or so and it’s been excellent every time.“

“❗️MILLERS TOO has been my family's FAVORITE since we moved here 3 years ago❗️ Simple comfort foods done well 🇺🇲 Relaxed like home. Nostalgic The staff treat you like family 🧡 My kids love the food and they feel comfortable eating inside We started a tradition "Catfish 🐈🎣 Friday" and we order it here at least once each month Their 🍳🥓 breakfast 🥞☕️ is #1 in the area We ❤️ this place!“

“My sister and I went to restaurant the food was great. But the older lady who was serving needs to put something on her hair and mouth. I felt she was talking over the food too much.“

“Great fried bologna sandwich!“

“Our first time at the restaurant and it was an amazing experience. Shelby was our server and what an outstanding job she did. Absolutely recommend this location!“

“Bubba's 33 never disappoints dine in or pick always good food and good service 5 stars plus“

“WONDERFUL!!! A time was truly had! I went out to eat with my friends and enjoyed every single second of it. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt inviting and comforting. We didn’t have to wait long to be seated — about a 6-minute wait.Our waiter, Terencia, went above and beyond in every way to make sure we had the best experience possible. She checked on us consistently without ever feeling overbearing, and her energy was so warm and genuine that it instantly made us feel welcomed. You could really tell she cared about making our night special. It’s rare to find service that feels this thoughtful, but she delivered wonderful hospitality from start to finish. The food was amazing, the vibes were top tier, and being with friends made it even better. We left satisfied, full, and already talking about what we’d try next when we come back.Truly a 10/10 experience!“

“Great food and our server Pam was amazing!“

“First time ever at a Kickback restaurant and we were blown away!!! We ordered two appetizers and meals. We found out the appetizers were a meal. Our food was amazing! The atmosphere was so much fun, nearly everyone in the place was singing along to the music. Our total came to 87.00 and we’ll worth it. Our server was so top notch. She was friendly and never once left us waiting for her. So thank you for providing us with a wonderful experience all around. More restaurants could and should model after you. I bet you’re glad they don’t Thanks again!“

“Absolutely fantastic experience and food!! The prices are incredible for the portions, freshness, flavors as well as service. Taylor B was our server and she made the experience even better!!!“

“This was the biscuit chicken sandwich I’ve ever eaten. I haven’t had it in over a decade since I’ve moved out of state, but I’ve been talking this place up since I’ve left and haven’t had a single bad experience from any of the 30+ times I’ve gone here. It’s temporary closed now, but when it opens back up, I highly recommend stopping by here for breakfast!“

“Thank you to Mission BBQ (Fay) for the generous support of Methodist University Religious Life, students, and partner churches! Quality, delicious food delivered with a great mission!“

“fantastic Carolina Burger! 100 times better than the chain restaurant next door.“

“We ordered to go and Zack was working solo holding down the to go orders. The food was fresh & everything was correct, we were highly satisfied! My parents ordered from them the other day and my parents said the food was really good! I appreciate good food and good service!“

“We LOVE Metro Diner and we LOVE Mycaiah. She is the best! Always has a smile on her face, and she always makes sure we are taken care of!! 🩷“