Papa Johns Pizza

I have tried to call repeatedly and speak to a manager and have been told this number is temporarily unavailable? What??
I had a very nasty encounter with a delivery driver yesterday. Sunday, July 27, 2025 I specifically put no contact and left a note saying please leave food by the door. I had also paid and left tip when I ordered online. When I realized the delivery driver was at outside I open the door to see if there was a problem and he proceeded to yell and cuss me out saying WHAT THE HELL MAN! ( repeatedly ) and say CAN YOU NOT HEAR???? IS THIS YOUR PHONE NUMBER?? CAN YOU NOT ANSWER YOUR PHONE?
Call didn’t come through. I tried explaining to the guy I had left a note but he didn’t want to hear me out and kept saying WHAT THE HELL MAN! Mind you I was home with my 2 year old ( he was startled hearing all this commotion ) and my cousin.

….. P.S. - I’m very disappointed with this delivery encounter because when I usually do carryout the employees are actually nice and friendly

Service: 1

Fantastic and delicious pizza..!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Papa J’s in Shallotte has an amazing staff. They took the time to give us extra care and attention. John, Stephanie, and Chris took great care of us and we’ll be telling everyone what a terrific team John leads. They showed grace, and were an excellent representation of what customer service should be, even under the pressure of a holiday-weekend Saturday night rush. Thank you Papa John’s of Shallotte!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It was family pizza night and it couldn’t have been more disappointing. The pizza was horribly dry. The mean was hard and impossible to chew. The cheese was nonexistent. After being told by the worker that claimed to have worked there for 13 years that its extra cheese, I was expecting a great pizza and not the one picture. The dough was so incredibly flat and had no taste at all. I will be leaving this review on multiple platforms. I will also be requesting a full refund for my order. Horrible…..just horrible!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I wish I could give this restaurant zero stars. My pizza was disgusting! I paid for extra cheese and it was so dry and overcooked, I could use it as a frisbee. I spoke to the manager and he kept saying it’s extra cheese when clearly a blind person can see it wasn’t extra cheese. I paid $17 for an overcooked, bland piece of cardboard and dried out wings. They Honey Chipotle wings had no sauce. I wasn’t given my Ranch. This is the worst experience I’ve had all year. Highly disappointed. I will be asking for a full refund or be reporting to the BBB. I took a photo to show just how bad and unappetizing it was.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Good food good people

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Fast pick up. Great pizza!

Shout out to Charles my delivery when I tell yall he was quick he was quick props to him

Food is always good. But it's way more expensive than dominoes or some other pizza place

The people here are awesome and the food is great and I'm not just saying that because I drive there. The pay could be a bit better yes and people could tip more often then not but other wise everything is awesome

Quality of food at this location suffers.

Next time I oder a large pepperoni and pineapple pizza. It would be great to actually put pineapple and pepperoni onthe pizza with cheese and sauce

I love doing business with Papa Johns especially this location! Our business Carquest of Supply had (44) pizzas to get for all our accounts. I called and Shyann the manager on Monday to have an order to pickup for Friday and she got it done with her crew. Thanks Papa Johns for having our back so I can look great for my accounts!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very fast and friendly service. I now see how Papa Johns does it better!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Extra Large New York Style Pizza

Adrianna was so awesome she needs be the face of papa John’s ! Give her a raise !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5